Abstract
For the first time, present paper addresses the nonlinear vibrations analysis of a truncated conical shell made of bidirectional functionally graded (BDFG) materials whose mechanical properties varied continuously through the thickness and the length directions of the conical shell based on the power law distribution. Accordingly, the set of nonlinear equation of motions of the conical shell are derived based on first-order shear deformation theory (FSDT) and von Karman strain-displacement relations using Hamilton’s principle. System of partial differential equations of the BDFG conical shell are transformed into time-dependent ordinary differential equations using Galerkin approach. Afterward, the nonlinear equations are analytically solved by means of modified Poincaré–Lindstedt method, and the nonlinear frequency of the BDFG conical shell is obtained. For verification purpose, the present outcomes are compared with those available in previous researches. Eventually, the effect of longitudinal and transverse gradient indexes, vibration amplitude, and geometrical parameters on the nonlinear frequency of the BDFG conical shell is investigated. The present research may give benchmark solutions and some guidelines for designing BDFG truncated conical shells.
Keywords
1. Introduction
Shell is a three-dimensional structure whose thickness is very small compared to other dimensions. Among them, cylindrical and conical shells have more applications in engineering structures; some examples are pressure tanks, submarine and ship hulls, plane wings and hulls, pipes, outer surfaces of rockets, vehicle tires, reinforced concrete roofs, and liquid tanks (Sobhani et al., 2021). The mentioned components and structures are subjected to extreme dynamical loads during the operation most of the time. When the excitation frequency of the external load approaches the natural frequency of the structure, a resonance phenomenon occurs, and consequently, the structure immensely vibrates and is finally damaged. Therefore, vibrations behavior analysis of such structures has become a noteworthy issue among researchers in recent years, which some of them will be explored in the next paragraph.
Asymmetric transverse vibrations analysis of truncated conical shells with consideration of flexural and membrane rigidity as well as inertia terms resulting from transverse and in-plane motion was investigated by Lindholm and Hu (1966). Weingarten (1966) determined the internal and external pressure on the free vibrations of fully simply supported conical shells using Donnel assumptions and Galerkin method. Qin et al. (2017) developed a comparison study on the free vibrations investigation of cylindrical shells with various boundary supports based on Sanders shell theory and using Rayleigh–Ritz method. Dong et al. (2022) studied nonlinear vibrations of a cylindrical shell coupled with multi-mode under different boundary supports by considering in-plane inertia terms. Lian et al. (2022) investigated the free vibration analysis of semi-closed shells of revolution with variable curvature, with a focus on the analytical solution to the natural frequency of such shells. Sobhani et al. (2022) studied the vibrational behavior of coupled hemispherical-conical-conical shells structures made composite materials reinforced with nanofillers using Donnell’s shell theory.
Conventional composite materials experience a rapid change in their mechanical properties at the interface where different phases meet. This creates elevated levels of stress at the boundary, which frequently results in failure (Kazemzadeh-Parsi et al., 2023). With the advances in technology, new materials with unique properties have been replaced by traditional ones. Functionally graded materials (FGMs) are inhomogeneous composite materials that occur of two or more materials with different properties (such as ceramic and metal) which are changed gradually and continuously throughout one or more directions (Civalek and Avcar, 2022). Nowadays, FGMs have attracted the attention of many researchers due to their impressive mechanical and thermal characteristics. Hence, numerous studies on the vibrations analysis of functionally graded (FG) shells have been reported recently, which some of them will be reported in the following paragraph.
Xue et al. (2023) studied free vibrations analysis of FG cylindrical panels and shells with porosity that has been symmetrically and non-symmetrically distributed in thickness direction with two novel dispersal types. Kim et al. (2023) investigated free and forced vibration behavior of relatively thick FG doubly curved shell of revolution according to first-order shear deformation theory (FSDT). Sofıyev and Kuruoglu (2015) studied vibration characteristics of the geometrically imperfect FG truncated conical shell with nonlinear von Karman–Donnell strain-displacement relations. Esfahani et al. (2022) examined the free vibrations analysis of sandwich conical shell with a saturated FG porous core via FSDT using differential quadrature method (DQM). Hashemi and Jafari (2020a) investigated nonlinear free vibrations of FG rectangular plates based on FSDT using modified Lindstedt–Poincaré method. Hashemi and Jafari (2021) determined the effect of fluid on the nonlinear fundamental frequency of the FG rectangular plates based on FSDT using modified Lindstedt–Poincaré method. Hashemi et al., 2023 analyzed the free vibrations of FG annular plate with elastic edge supports resting on Winkler foundation. Dastjerdi et al. (2020) investigated the nonlinear dynamic analysis of FG torus-shaped and cylindrical shell-like structures using semi-analytical method. Civalek et al. (2022) analyzed the buckling and free vibrations of FG carbon nanotube reinforced cross-ply laminated composite plates based on FSDT.
Nguyen et al. (2021) investigated nonlinear vibration analysis of full-filled fluid corrugated sandwich FG cylindrical shells using the fourth-order Runge–Kutta method.
In the above-aforementioned articles, the vibrations behavior of conical and cylindrical shells is limited to one-directional FGMs. However, conventional FGM may also not be very effective in some engineering components such as rocket warheads and propulsion systems. Therefore, vibrations characteristics of bidirectional functionally graded (BDFG) (Hashemi et al., 2022; Hashemi and Jafari, 2020b) conical and cylindrical shells is an important issue that has been worked on less, which will be discussed in the following.
Amirabadi et al. (2021) worked on linear free vibrations of the BDFG graphene nanoplatelets reinforced rotating conical shells resting on elastic foundation whose material properties varied along the length and thickness of the shell. Allahkarami et al., 2020b analyzed the dynamical buckling of BDFG porous conical and cylindrical shells on elastic foundation with various boundary supports based on FSDT and using generalized differential quadrature method (GDQM). Chen et al. (2018) examined the vibrations analysis of BDFG porous sector cylindrical shells with elastic boundary conditions using FSDT and Hamilton’s principle. Tahouneh and Naei (2016) investigated the effects of multi-directional nanocomposites on the linear vibrations of thick cylindrical shell panels on elastic foundation by means of two-dimensional DQM. Bahadori and Najafizadeh (2015) studied linear vibrations of BDFG porous cylindrical shells resting on Winkler elastic foundation on the basis of FSDT. Shariyat and Asgari (2013) worked on nonlinear buckling and postbuckling temperature-dependent BDFG truncated cylindrical shells with variable thickness according to the higher-order shear deformation theory (HSDT) and Hamilton’s principle. Mohammadzadeh et al. (2013) examined buckling analysis of BDFG cylindrical shells subjected to combined axial and external pressure using classical shells theory and DQM. Jafari Mehrabadi and Aragh (2013) investigated thermal analysis of temperature-dependent BDFG cylindrical shells based on HSDT using DQM. Pilafkan et al. (2013) reported a three-dimensional frequency analysis for thick BDFG cylindrical shells. Wu and Li (2021) presented a semi-analytical method based on finite element in order to analyze three-dimensional bending of BDFG toroidal shells exposed to uniform compression load. Khorsand et al. (2019) utilized multi-directional FG to increase the durability and longevity of the shell structures whose mechanical properties changed along the radial and axial direction and were subjected to mechanical loads. Wu and Huang (2020) studied stress and deformation analysis of BDFG truncated conical shells subjected to sinusoidal compression load using a semi-analytical method.
To the best knowledge of the authors, up to now, the nonlinear free vibrations analysis of BDFG truncated conical shell based on FSDT has not been reported in open literatures. Therefore, the present study introduces a novel investigation into the bidirectional effect of FGMs on the nonlinear vibrational behavior of truncated conical shells. The mechanical properties of the graded materials vary continuously through both the thickness and length directions of the shell based on a power law distribution, which has not been previously explored in the literature. The main innovation of this paper is to examine the bidirectional nature of the graded materials and its impact on the nonlinear vibrations analysis of the conical shell for the first time. For this purpose, in the first section, the equations of motion of the system have been derived using Hamilton’s principle and nonlinear von Karman strain-displacement relations based on FSDT. In the second section, in order to obtain nonlinear natural frequency of the system, the nonlinear equations of the BDFG truncated conical shell have been analytically solved by modified Poincaré–Lindstedt method. Eventually, the effect of some significant parameters on the nonlinear frequency of the shell has been deeply investigated.
2. Model description
Figure 1 depicts the schematic view of a BDFG truncated conical shell with length of Schematic of a BDFG truncated conical shell.
Mechanical properties
According to power law distribution, the volume fraction of a BDFG truncated conical shell is written as the following form (Allahkarami et al., 2020a):
Mechanical properties of pure ceramic and pure metal (Hashemi et al., 2023).
3. Theory and equations of motion
Longitudinal (U), circumferential (V), and transverse (W) displacement of any point on a truncated conical shell based on the FSDT is written as follows (Allahkarami et al., 2020a):
where
In which
where variable elastic coefficients Q
ij
are
The strain energy (VE) and kinetic energy (KE) of the BDFG truncated conical shell is stated as follows (Allahkarami et al., 2020a):
In which force resultants (N), moments resultants (M), transverse force resultants (Q), and inertia related terms (I) of the BDFG truncated conical shell are defined as follows:
where
The boundary conditions of the shell which simply supported on both edges are considered as follows:
The geometric boundary conditions are satisfied by the following approximate function:
where n and m refer to circumferential and longitudinal wave numbers, respectively. For the sake of generality of the formulations, a set of non-dimensional parameters are introduced as follows:
By substituting equations (38)–(42) into equations (31)–(35) and employing Galerkin approach, the nonlinear partial differential equations of motion are transformed into the time-dependent nonlinear ordinary differential equations in the following form:
where
where
4. Improved Lindstedt–Poincaré method
In this section, in order to analytically solve the nonlinear equation (49), the improved Lindstedt–Poincaré method is used (Hashemi and Jafari, 2021). For this purpose, equation (49) should be rewritten in the following form:
The coefficients
The solution of equation (54) is
By substituting equation (57) into equation (55):
The solution of equation (58) is as follows:
Finally, from equation (53), the nonlinear natural frequency of the BDFG truncated conical shell is obtained:
5. Results and discussion
5.1. Validation
Frequency parameter results for isotropic conical shells for different values of circumferential wave number (m = 1, h/R 2 = 0.01, L sin(α)/R 2 = 0.25, ν = 0.3, α = 45o,60°).
1*: (Mohammadrezazadeh and Jafari, 2021a); 2*: (Irie, 1984); 3*: (Li et al., 2009); 4*: (Lam and Hua, 1999).
Comparison of the frequency parameter results of this study with literature for isotropic conical shells (m = 1, h/R 2 = 0.01, L sin(α)/R 2 = 0.25, ν = 0.3, α = 30°).
1*: (Lam and Hua, 1999); 2*: (Mohammadrezazadeh and Jafari, 2021b); 3*: (Pradhan and Reddy, 2004).
5.2. Parametric study
The present section concentrates on the nonlinear vibrations analysis of BDFG truncated conical shell with simply supported boundary conditions. The studied BDFG conical shell is made of two materials: Aluminum (Al) as the metal phase and alumina (Al2O3) as the ceramic phase of FGM, whose material properties have been given in Table 1.
Figure 2 illustrates the effect of semi-vertex angle (α) on the nonlinear vibration response (backbone curve) of a BDFG truncated conical shell for constant coefficients of m = n = 1, h/R
2
= 0.01, L
2
= 2, N
x
= N
z
= 1. According to this figure, it is observed that by increasing the semi-vertex angle, the linear natural frequency of the BDFG conical shell decreases. However, the hardening behavior of the shell impressively increases by increasing semi-vertex angle. Vibration amplitude versus nonlinear to linear frequency ratio diagram of a BDFG conical shell for various semi-vertex angle.
The effect of thickness to large radius ratio (h/R
2
) on the backbone curve of a BDFG truncated conical shell is shown in Figure 3. This figure is plotted for constant parameters of m = n = 1, α = 60°, L
2
= 2, N
x
= N
z
= 1. According to this figure, it is revealed that by increasing thickness to large radius ratio, both linear natural frequency and hardening behavior of the BDFG conical shell significantly increases. The reason is that by increasing the thickness to large radius ratio, while the other parameters are assumed to be constant, the shell becomes thicker and consequently stiffer, and as a result, its natural frequency and hardening behavior increases. Vibration amplitude versus nonlinear to linear frequency ratio diagram of a BDFG conical shell for various thickness to large radius ratios.
Figure 4 depicts the efficacy of the length ratio (L
2
/L) on the nonlinear vibration response of a BDFG truncated conical shell for constant parameters of m = n = 1, h/R
2
= 0.01, α = 60°, N
x
= N
z
= 1. This figure represents that the linear natural frequency, nonlinear frequency ratio, and hardening behavior of the shell increases as the length ratio of the shell increases. Vibration amplitude versus nonlinear to linear frequency ratio diagram of a BDFG conical shell for various length ratios.
Figure 5 reveals the nonlinear vibration response diagram of a BDFG truncated conical shell for different circumferential wave number (n) when other parameters are m = 1, L
2
/L = 2, h/R
2
= 0.01, α = 60°, N
x
= N
z
= 1. The results of this figure indicate that increasing the circumferential wave number from 2 to 6 leads to an increase in the hardening behavior of the shell. Furthermore, by increasing the circumferential wave number from 2 to 4, the shell’s linear natural frequency decreases while by increasing the circumferential wave number from 4 to 6, the shell’s linear natural frequency increases. Vibration amplitude versus nonlinear to linear frequency ratio diagram of a BDFG conical shell for various circumferential wave number.
The effect of two-directional functionally graded materials on the nonlinear behavior of the cylindrical shells are revealed in Figures 6 to 11. The constant parameters of m = n = 1, h/R
2
= 0.01, L
2
= 2, and α = 60 are considered in these figures. Amplitude–frequency curves of a BDFG truncated conical shell for various transverse gradient index when N
x
= 0. Amplitude–frequency curves of a BDFG truncated conical shell for various transverse gradient index when N
x
= 1. Amplitude–frequency curves of a BDFG truncated conical shell for various transverse gradient index when N
x
= 2. Amplitude–frequency curves of a BDFG truncated conical shell for various longitudinal gradient index when N
z
= 0. Amplitude–frequency curves of a BDFG truncated conical shell for various longitudinal gradient index when N
z
= 1. Amplitude–frequency curves of a BDFG truncated conical shell for various longitudinal gradient index when N
z
= 2.





The effect of the transverse gradient index (N z ) on the amplitude-frequency curves of a BDFG truncated conical shell for different longitudinal gradient index (N x ) are examined in Figures 6 to 8 As indicated in Figures 6 to 8, it is figured out that by increasing the transverse gradient index from 0 to 4, the dimensionless linear frequency of the BDFG truncated conical shell remarkably decrease by about 32%, 26%, and 20% for N x = 0,1, and 2, respectively. It is also to be noted that maximum frequency corresponds to N z = N x = 0 which is the case of the homogeneous isotropic truncated conical shell with pure ceramic material constituents. In addition, these figures indicate that by increasing the transverse gradient index from 0 to 4, the dimensionless nonlinear frequency of the BDFG truncated conical shell significantly decreases by about 55%, 50%, and 44% for N x = 0,1, and 2, respectively. The results illustrate that the effect of transverse gradient index on the nonlinear frequency is significantly more than linear natural frequency of the shell. In fact, by increasing the transverse gradient index, the volume fraction of ceramic phase of the shell decreases while those of metal phase of the shell increases that it causes to decrease in total stiffness, and consequently the linear and nonlinear natural frequency of the structure. Furthermore, these figures illustrate that by increasing vibration amplitude, the nonlinear frequency of the BDFG truncated conical shell increases, which means hardening behavior of the shell, whereas linear frequency remains constant.
The influence of the longitudinal gradient index (N x ) on the amplitude-frequency diagrams of a BDFG truncated conical shell for different transverse gradient index (N z ) are investigated in Figures 9 to 11. According to these figures, it is found that by increasing the longitudinal gradient index from 0 to 4, the dimensionless linear frequency of the BDFG truncated conical shell remarkably decrease by about 39%, 32%, and 26% for N z = 0, 1, and 2, respectively. Another fact that is observed in these figures is that by increasing the longitudinal gradient index from 0 to 4, the dimensionless nonlinear frequency of the BDFG truncated conical shell significantly decreases by about 38%, 24%, and 17% for N z = 0,1, and 2, respectively. In addition, by comparing Figures 6 to 11, it is revealed that the effect of transverse gradient index on the nonlinear frequency of the system is more than longitudinal gradient index.
6. Conclusion
In this research, the nonlinear free vibrations analysis of bidirectional functionally graded (BDFG) truncated conical shells based on first-order shear deformation theory (FSDT) was conducted. The materials were assumed to be isotropic and inhomogeneous through the length and thickness of truncated conical shell. The system of partial differential equations was converted into the set of ordinary differential equations by Galerkin approach and then solved through improved Lindstedt–Poincaré method. Previously published data were employed to verify results for isotropic truncated conical shell, and results show outstanding agreement with them. Eventually, the effects of some system parameters on the linear and nonlinear frequency parameters of the BDFG truncated conical shell were carried out. The main important outcomes of the present study could be listed as follows: • As the semi-vertex angle increases, the linear natural frequency of the BDFG conical shell decreases while the hardening behavior of the shell significantly increases. • By increasing thickness to large radius ratio, linear natural frequency and hardening behavior of the BDFG conical shell significantly increases. • As the length ratio of the shell increases, the linear natural frequency, nonlinear frequency ratio, and hardening behavior of the shell increases. • By increasing the circumferential wave number from 2 to 4, the shell’s linear natural frequency decreases, while by increasing the circumferential wave number from 4 to 6, the shell’s linear natural frequency increases. However, increasing the circumferential wave number from 2 to 6 leads to an increase in the hardening behavior of the shell. • Independently of all the system parameters, increasing the vibration amplitude leads to an increase in the nonlinear to linear frequency ratio of the plate. • By enlarging the longitudinal and transverse gradient indexes, the linear and nonlinear frequency of the BDFG truncated conical shells decrease. • The influence of transverse gradient index on the nonlinear frequency is significantly more than linear natural frequency of the shell. • The effect of transverse gradient index on the nonlinear frequency of the system is more than longitudinal gradient index.
Footnotes
Declaration of conflicting interests
The author(s) declared no potential conflicts of interest with respect to the research, authorship, and/or publication of this article.
Funding
The author(s) received no financial support for the research, authorship, and/or publication of this article.
