Initiating a Clinical Trials Cooperative Group in an Increasingly Managed Care Environment: Successes and Problems in Establishing Collaboration

Abstract

The Communication Sciences and Disorders Clinical Trials Research Group (CSDRG) was organized in 1995 and funded in 1997 by the National Institute of Deafness and Other Communication Disorders (NIDCD) as a cooperative clinical trials group. It designs and conducts multiinstitutional randomized clinical trials focusing on treatments delivered by speech-language pathologists (SLPs) and audiologists for disorders of speech, language, hearing, balance, and voice/swallowing. Data are presented on a comparison of the number of site participants from the group’s onset in 1995 through 31 December 1997. Successes and problems experienced by CSDRG are defined with regard to organizing the group and designing and conducting clinical trials in a managed care environment with nonprimary care professionals. Different barriers to participation are identified at various levels of care/types of institutions and with various types of patient populations, for example, children receiving their health care through the schools versus elderly, demented individuals in nursing care facilities.

References

Baum, H. M.

J. A. Logemann

, and

D. E. Lilienfeld

. 1998. Clinical Trials and Their Application to Communication Sciences and Disorders. Journal of Medical Speech-Language Pathology6 (2): 55-64.

Cutler, C. M.

1996. Research Needs for Managed Care. Health Affairs (Millwood)15 (3): 93-94.

Donahue, C. D.

B. E. Lewis

I. S. Ockene

, and

G. Saperia

. 1996. Research Collaboration between an HMO and an Academic Medical Center: Lessons Learned. Academic Medicine71 (2): 126-132.

Eddy, D. M.

1993. Clinical Decision Making: From Theory to Practice. Three Battles to Watch in the 1990s. Journal of the American Medical Association270 (4): 520-526.

Fried, B. M.

, and

R. W. Besdine

. 1996. A Perspective on Academic Medicine from the Nation’s Largest Managed Care Purchaser. Academic Medicine71 (3): 260-261.

Mechanic, R. E.

, and

A. Dobson

. 1996. The Impact of Managed Care on Clinical Research: A Preliminary Report. Health Affairs (Millwood)5 (3): 72-89.

Moy, E.

A. J. Mazzaschi

R. J. Levin

D. A. Blake

, and

P. F. Griner

. 1997. Relationship between National Institutes of Health Research Awards to U.S. Medical Schools and Managed Care Market Penetration. Journal of the American Medical Association278 (3): 217-221.

Shine, K. I.

1997. Some Imperatives for Clinical Research. Journal of the American Medical Association278 (3): 245-246.