Rates,Patterns,and Frequency of Child Maltreatment Recurrences among Families known to CPS

Abstract

Child maltreatment is a widespread and costly social problem. A primary purpose of child maltreating reporting is to prevent its recurrence. Despite the widespread belief that the system designed to prevent its recurrence is failing miserably, little empirical data are actually compiled to support this contention. This article reviews available research on the rates, patterns, and frequency of child maltreatment recurrences. Findings are difficult to interpret and integrate because of differences in definitions, units of analysis, follow-up intervals, and data analysis strategies. Rates of recurrence range from 1% or 2% for cases deemed low-risk to over 50% for families followed more than 5 years. Findings from studies that have used survival analysis techniques seem to indicate that the risk of recurrence declines with intervention. Future research should be prospective, document definitions and methods, and use survival analysis so that this possible encouraging trend can be further examined.

References

Baird, S. C. (1988). Development of risk assessment indices for the Alaska Department of Health and Social Services. In T. Tatara (Ed.), Validation research in CPS risk assessment: Three recent studies (Occasional Monograph Series No. 2, pp. 84-142). Washington, DC: American Public Welfare Association.

Baird, C. , Wagner, D. , & Neuenfeldt, D. (1993). Actuarial risk assessment and case management in child protective services. In T. Tatara (Ed.), Sixth National Roundtable on CPS Risk Assessment Summary of Highlights (pp. 152-168). Washington, DC: American Public Welfare Association.

Berkeley Planning Associates . (1983). Evaluation of the clinical demonstrations of the treatment of child abuse and neglect: Vol. 2. The exploration of client characteristics, services, and outcomes: Final report and summary of findings (HEW 105-78-1108). Washington, DC: U.S. Department of Health and Human Services, Office of Human Development Services, National Center on Child Abuse and Neglect.

Browne, D. (1986). The role of stress in the commission of subsequent acts of child abuse and neglect. Journal of Family Violence, 1(4), 289-297.

Cohn, A. H. (1979). Effective treatment of child abuse and neglect. Social Work, 24, 513-519.

Cohn, A. H. , & Daro, D. (1987). Is treatment too late: What ten years of evaluative research tell us. Child Abuse and Neglect, 11, 433-442.

Coleman, H.D.J. (1995). A longitudinal study of a family preservation program. Unpublished doctoral dissertation, University of Utah, School of Social Work.

Dennis-Small, L., & Washburn, K. (1986). Family-centered, home-based intervention project for protective services clients. Unpublished manuscript, Texas Department of Human Services, Protective Services for Families and Children Branch, Austin.

DePanfilis, D. (1982). Clients who refer themselves to child protective services. Children Today, 11(2), 21-25.

10.

DePanfilis, D. (1993). A proximate test of the construct and predictive validity of the Child at Risk Field decision-making system. Unpublished manuscript, University of Maryland at Baltimore, School of Social Work, Baltimore.

11.

DePanfilis, D. (1995). Epidemiology of child maltreatment recurrences. Unpublished doctoral dissertation, University of Maryland at Baltimore, School of Social Work, Baltimore.

12.

DePanfilis, D., & Salus, M. (1992). Child protective services: A guide for caseworkers (Government Printing Office No. 1992-625-670/60577). Washington, DC: National Center on Child Abuse and Neglect.

13.

DePanfilis, D. , & Zuravin, S. (1992, September). Predicting the recurrence of child maltreatment. Ninth International Congress on Child Abuse and Neglect, Chicago, IL.

14.

English, D. , & Aubin, S. W. (1993). An update on risk assessment research in Washington State. In T. Tatara (Ed.), Sixth National Roundtable on CPS Risk Assessment Summary of Highlights (pp. 288-309). Washington, DC: American Public Welfare Association.

15.

Faller, K. C. (1991). What happens to sexually abused children identified by Child Protective Services? Children and Youth Services Review, 13, 101-111.

16.

Ferleger, N. , Glenwick, D. , Gaines, R. , & Green, A. (1988). Identifying correlates of reabuse in maltreating parents. Child Abuse and Neglect, 12, 41-49.

17.

Fryer, G. E. , & Miyoshi, T. J. (1994). A survival analysis of the revictimization of children: The case of Colorado. Child Maltreatment, 18, 1063-1071.

18.

Gelles, R. J. (1993). The doctrine of family reunification: Child protection or risk? The Advisor, 6(2), 9-11.

19.

Grossnickle, D.H.C., & White, J. (1986). An outcome study of child protective services. Unpublished manuscript, Children's Services Division, Department of Human Resources, State of Oregon, Salem.

20.

Herrenkohl, R. C. , Herrenkohl, E. C. , Egolf, B. , & Seech, M. (1978). Final report from the project: An investigation of the effects of a multidimensional service program on recidivism/discontinuation of child abuse and neglect (Prepared for the National Center on Child Abuse and Neglect, Grant No. 90-C-428). Bethlehem, PA: Lehigh University, Center for Social Research.

21.

Herrenkohl, R. C. , Herrenkohl, E. C. , Egolf, B. , & Seech, M. (1979). The repetition of child abuse: How frequently does it occur? Child Abuse and Neglect, 3, 67-72.

22.

Johnson, W. (1994). Maltreatment recurrence as a criterion for validating risk assessment instruments. In T. Tatara (Ed.), Seventh National Roundtable on CPS Risk Assessment Summary of Highlights (pp. 175-182). Washington, DC: American Public Welfare Association.

23.

Johnson, W. (1995a). Culturally-sensitive risk assessment: A conceptual framework and supporting data. In T. Tatara (Ed.), Eighth National Roundtable on CPS Risk Assessment Summary of Highlights (pp. 131-141). Washington, DC: American Public Welfare Association.

24.

Johnson, W. (1995b, June). Using risk assessment in the evaluation of public agency child protective services. Paper presented at the Ninth National Roundtable on CPS Risk Assessment, San Francisco.

25.

Johnson, W. , & Clancy, T. (1990). Preliminary findings from a study of risk assessment accuracy and service effectiveness in home-based services physical abuse cases. In T. Tatara (Ed.), Third National Roundtable on CPS Risk Assessment Summary of Highlights (pp. 159-171). Washington, DC: American Public Welfare Association.

26.

Johnson, W. , & L'Esperance, J. (1984). Predicting the recurrence of child abuse. Social Work Research and Abstracts, 20(2), 21-26.

27.

Jones, M. A. (1985). A second chance for families. New York: Child Welfare League of America.

28.

Laughlin, J. , & Weiss, M. (1981). An outpatient milieu therapy approach to treatment of child abuse and neglect problems. Social Casework, 62, 106-109.

29.

Layzer, J. I. , & Goodson, B. D. (1981). Impact evaluation of twenty demonstration and innovative child abuse and neglect treatment projects final report (Vol. 2, Contract No. 105-77-1047 to ABT Associates). Washington, DC: U.S. Department of Health and Human Services, Office of Human Development Services, National Center on Child Abuse and Neglect.

30.

Lee, E. (1992). Statistical methods for survival data analysis (2nd ed.). New York: John Wiley.

31.

Levy, H. B. , Markovic, M. A. , Chaudhry, M. D. , Ahart, S. , & Torres, H. (1995). Reabuse rates in a sample of children followed for five years after discharge from a child abuse inpatient assessment program. Child Abuse and Neglect, 19, 1363-1377.

32.

Luttrell, J. , Hull, S. , & Wagner, D. (1995, June). The Michigan Department of Social Services Structured Decision Making System. An evaluation of its impact on child protection services. Paper presented at the Ninth National Roundtable on CPS Risk Assessment, San Francisco.

33.

Lutzker, J. R. , & Rice, J. M. (1984). Project 12-ways: Measuring outcome of a large in-home service for treatment and prevention of child abuse and neglect. Child Abuse and Neglect, 8, 519-524.

34.

Lutzker, J. R. , & Rice, J. M. (1987). Using recidivism data to evaluate project 12-Ways: An ecobehavioral approach to the treatment and prevention of child abuse and neglect. Journal of Family Violence, 2, 283-290.

35.

Marks, J. , & McDonald, T. (1989). Risk assessment in child protective services: Predicting the recurrence of child maltreatment. Portland: University of Southern Maine, National Child Welfare Resource Center for Management and Administration.

36.

McDonald, T. , & Johnson, W. (1992). Predicting recurrence of maltreatment for child sexual abuse cases. In T. Tatara (Ed.), Fifth National Roundtable on CPS Risk Assessment Summary of Highlights (pp. 72-89). Washington, DC: American Public Welfare Association.

37.

McDonald, T. P. , & Johnson, W. (1993). Tracking reported sexual abuse cases. Journal of Child Sexual Abuse, 2(2), 1-11.

38.

McDonald, T. , & Marks, J. (1991). A review of risk factors assessed in child protective services. Social Services Review, 65, 112-132.

39.

Miller, J. S. , Williams, K. M. , English, D, J. , & Olmstead, J. (1987). Risk assessment in child protection: A review of the literature. Washington, DC: American Public Welfare Association.

40.

Murphy, J. M. , Bishop, S. J. , Jellinek, M. S. , & Quinn, D. (1992). What happens after the care and protection petition?: Reabuse in a court sample. Child Abuse and Neglect, 16, 485-493.

41.

Nelson, K., Emlen, A., Landsman, M., & Hutchinson, J. (1988). Factors contributing to success and failure in family-based child welfare services. Unpublished manuscript, National Resource Center on Family Based Services, Iowa City.

42.

Neuenfeldt, D. , & DeMares, M. (1995). Risk assessment validation study and its use in four urban Wisconsin counties. In T. Tatara (Ed.), Eighth National Roundtable on CPS Risk Assessment (pp. 7-23). Washington, DC: American Public Welfare Association.

43.

Owen, G. , & Fercello, C. (1995, June). Family options: Preliminary results from an experiment in child abuse prevention. Poster session presented at the Third National Colloquium of the American Professional Society on the Abuse of Children, Tucson, AZ.

44.

Rivara, F. P. (1985). Physical abuse in children under two: A study of therapeutic outcomes. Child Abuse and Neglect, 9, 81-87.

45.

Schuerman, J. R. , Rzepnicki, T. L. , & Littell, J. H. (1994). Putting families first an experiment in family preservation. New York: Walter de Gruyter.

46.

Sedlak, A. J. , & Broadhurst, D. D. (1996). Third national incidence study of child abuse and neglect final report. Washington, DC: U.S. Department of Health and Human Services, National Center on Child Abuse and Neglect.

47.

Shapiro, D. (1979). Parents and protectors. New York: Child Welfare League of America.

48.

Shireman, J. F. , Grossnickle, D. , Hinsey, C. , & White, J. (1990). Outcome study of protective services: Comparison of interviews and records as data sources. Child Welfare, 69(2), 167-179.

49.

Squadrito, E. , Neuenfeldt, D. , & Fluke, J. (1995). Findings of Rhode Island's two-year research and development efforts. In T. Tatara (Ed.), Eighth National Roundtable on CPS Risk Assessment (pp. 173-193). Washington, DC: American Public Welfare Association.

50.

U.S. Department of Health and Human Services, U.S. Advisory Board on Child Abuse and Neglect . (1991, September). Creating caring communities: Blueprint for an effective federal policy on child abuse and neglect. Washington, DC: Author.

51.

Wagner, D. (1994). The use of actuarial risk assessment in criminal justice. What can we learn from the experience? In T. Tatara (Ed.), Seventh National Roundtable on CPS Risk Assessment Summary of Highlights (pp. 211-223). Washington, DC: American Public Welfare Association.

52.

Weedon, J. , Torti, T. , & Zunder, P. (1988). Vermont Division of Social Services Family Risk Assessment Matrix: Research and evaluation. In T. Tatara (Ed.), Validation research in CPS risk assessment: Three recent studies (Occasional Monograph Series No. 2, pp. 2-43). Washington, DC: American Public Welfare Association.

53.

Wood, J. M. (1995, June). NCCD predictors of re-abuse and re-neglect in a predominantly Hispanic population. Paper presented at the Ninth National Roundtable on CPS Risk Assessment, San Francisco.

54.

Zunder, P. (1990). Recent empirical findings of the Vermont family risk assessment instrument. In National Conference on CPS Risk Assessment From Research to Practice: Designing the Future of Child Protective Services Summaries of Highlights (pp. 1-16). Washington, DC: Vermont Division of Social Services, American Public Welfare Association, American Association for Protecting Children.