Abstract
This paper presents an analytical formulation for deriving the three-dimensional (3D) elastodynamic Green’s functions of functionally graded transversely isotropic tri-material composite under time-harmonic loading. With the aid of a complete set of displacement potentials, Fourier expansions, and Hankel integral transforms, displacement and stress components of 3D point-load, patch-load, and ring-load are obtained in the form of complex-plane infinite line-integrals. By virtue of a reliable and fast numerical scheme, i.e., the contour integration method, they are numerically treated, and its accuracy is achieved by comparison with some special cases. Finally, some numerical results are selected to demonstrate the influences of the material inhomogeneity and vibration frequency on the displacement and stress components. Particularly, the dependency of the stress transfer process at the interface of the mediums on the degree of inhomogeneity is presented, which is of high importance in evaluating the performance of composite materials.
Keywords
1. Introduction
An impetus toward the analysis of composite materials including tri-materials has raised by extensive mechanical and industrial applications such as composite laminates and coating on substrates in recent decades [1]. The tri-material composites consist of a finite layer of uniform thickness, bonded to two opposite half-space with different properties. Investigation of defects such as debonding and fracture across the plane interfaces plays an essential role in the evaluation of such layered structures. However, the utilization of innovative and inhomogeneous materials, such as functionally graded materials (FGMs), reduces inevitable problems, including delamination of composite layers. This is because their thermal and mechanical properties have gradual and continuous variation in spatial directions and this leads to an outstanding positive effect on the performance of these materials. This in turn generates widespread applications, including dental implant in bio-medical [2], materials with high wearing resistance, barriers for high temperature, aerospace and automobile industries, etc. [3–5]. Furthermore, the inhomogeneity model can be predominantly employed as an efficient model in the context of geomechanics engineering interests since the properties of many geologic media, such as soil deposits and natural rocks, usually vary with depth due to the sedimentation process [6]. Several forms of continuous variations in modeling of graded materials in one or more axial coordinates have been considered, such as linear [7], exponential [8], and power law [9].
However, the non-destructive evaluation of mentioned defects in composite materials is of major concern. For the analysis of these problems, a semi-analytical/numerical method based on the integral equation formulation such as the boundary-element method (BEM) is a robust treatment. Furthermore, the suitable Green’s functions are central to BEM formulations [10].
Several kinds of research contain the analysis of homogeneous layered structures in the subject of anisotropic composites. By the generalized Stroh’s formulation and Fourier transform, Pan and Yuan [11] studied three-dimensional (3D) static Green’s functions in anisotropic bi-materials. Due to difficulty for explicit expressions of the Green’s functions in the physical domain, they partitioned the corresponding solution into a full-space solution in explicit form and a complementary part that is represented in terms of simple regular line-integrals. Yang and Pan [1] employed the same scheme to examine the 3D static Green’s functions in anisotropic tri-materials. Furthermore, Yang et al. [12] extended the previous approach for the study of Green’s functions in anisotropic half-space and bi-materials corresponding to steady-state motion and limited to the subsonic case. They also illustrated that wave velocity affects stress fields. Khojasteh et al. [13,14], by using two displacement-potential functions and with the aid of Fourier expansions and Hankel integral transforms, tackled 3D dynamic Green’s functions in a transversely isotropic bi-material half-space and bi-material full-space, respectively. They also recently developed this fundamental solution for the class of 3D dynamic Green’s functions in transversely isotropic tri-material composite full-space [15]. For such analysis considering time-harmonic loads in homogeneous multi-layered composites, one might refer to previous studies [16–18].
Many types of research are devoted to inhomogeneity problem for FGMs in the isotropic or anisotropic cases. For instance, Martin et al. [19] examined the 3D exponentially graded elastic isotropic developed problem of a static point force. They also, with the aid of Fourier transforms, obtained the corresponding solution, which contains two parts: a singular part similar to Kelvin solution, plus a nonsingular term. Then, Criado et al. [8] corrected a small error related to one of the formulas in nonsingular grading term—deduced by Martin et al. [19]—and numerically resolved the problem of 3D exponentially graded elastic isotropic. Guzina and Pak [7] and Pak and Guzina [20], by considering a linear shear wave velocity profile and with the aid of potential functions, presented 3D wave propagation and then obtained corresponding Green’s functions under time-harmonic load. Kashtalyan and Rushchitsky [21], by introducing two displacement functions, presented a solution to the 3D equilibrium equations in rectangular Cartesian coordinates for inhomogeneous transversely isotropic media. They also considered two types of inhomogeneity function: the exponential function and the power law. In addition, Plevako’s solution [22] for isotropic inhomogeneous material degenerated in this study. By virtue of displacement-potential functions, Hankel transform, and employing asymptotic decomposition method, Eskandari and Shodja [5] expressed a fundamental solution for an exponentially graded transversely isotropic half-space under arbitrary buried static loads, including two parts: closed-form solution pertinent to Green’s function of the homogeneous transversely isotropic half-space and numerical solution of grading term. By extending the potential functions presented by Eskandari-Ghadi [23], Eskandari-Ghadi and Amiri-Hezaveh [6] introduced a new set of potential functions for obtaining Green’s functions of an exponentially graded transversely isotropic half-space due to buried time-harmonic source. Selvadurai and Katebi [24] considered an incompressible elastic half-space with an exponential variation of the elastic shear modulus with depth, under acting of the axisymmetric interior load and they verified the accuracy of the corresponding solution via finite-element approach. Kalantari et al. [25] analytically investigated the rocking behavior of a rigid disk, embedded in an exponentially graded transversely isotropic half-space. Then, they numerically presented the displacement and stress distribution as the solution to the Fredholm integral equation obtained. Bednarik et al. [26] obtained analytical results for time-harmonic elastic SH-wave propagation through an isotropic inhomogeneous layer, surrounded by two homogeneous half-spaces. Also, for more details about different waves propagating within isotropic or transversely isotropic elastic media, interested readers may refer to previous studies [27–30]. Akbari et al. [31] examined the static response of exponentially graded transversely isotropic substrate–coating system composed of an exponentially graded transversely finite layer perfectly bonded to exponentially graded transversely isotropic half-spaces. Shahmohamadi et al. [32] investigated the smooth interaction of a rigid circular disk with an exponentially graded transversely isotropic coating–substrate system. In the context of functionally graded coating–substrate composite systems, several studies may be found in the literature [33–37].
Zafari et al. [38] treated 3D static Green’s functions problem for exponentially graded tri-material, by using the displacement-potential functions and the aid of Hankel and Fourier transform, and on the assumption, the middle finite layer rested on a rigid base with surface loading with two cases of interfacial conditions: rough-rigid and smooth-rigid.
The present study is concerned with the development of the 3D elastodynamic Green’s functions for functionally graded transversely isotropic tri-material composites under general time-harmonic interfacial loading. Using the displacement-potential functions and by means of integral transforms, dynamic displacement and stress fields are represented in the form of explicit semi-infinite line-integrals for the first time. Owing to the existence of several singularities, including branch points and poles in the path of integration, the method of analytical-numerical contour integration by Pak [39,40] is adopted. The accuracy of the proposed evaluation scheme is confirmed by degenerating the solution to some classic limiting cases. As illustration, the effect of inhomogeneity and excitation frequency on the response of the composite system is explored.
2. Description of the problem and the governing equations
The tri-material configuration as shown in Figure 1 is composed of three different exponentially heterogeneous transversely isotropic solid in such a way two opposite half-spaces (medium I, z < 0 and medium III, z > h) perfectly bonded to middle finite layer of arbitrary thickness h (medium II, 0 < z < h) along their interfaces, in which arbitrary tractional time-harmonic load applied on a finite region Π h located on plane z = h.

The configuration of functionally graded transversely isotropic composite under arbitrary applied load.
In the above, cylindrical coordinate system (r, θ, z) is attached to the tri-material composite where z-axis is the axis of symmetry of mediums. Furthermore, the symbols I, II, and III denote the properties pertinent to the upper, middle, and lower mediums, respectively.
The equations of time-harmonic motion in the assumed cylindrical coordinate system for a vertically exponentially graded transversely isotropic solid, in terms of displacement components ur, uθ, and uz, can be expressed as follows [6]:
where the body force fields are neglected and ω = circular frequency; ur, uθ, and uz are the displacement components in the radial, angular, and vertical directions, respectively.
ρ = mass density and Cij = elasticity coefficients of the transversely isotropic solid correspond to I, II, III mediums, while they are z-independent and assigned to z = 0 plane.
C 66 = (C11–C12)/2; β is the exponential factor characterizing the degree of the material gradient in z-direction; as β = 0 represents homogeneous transversely isotropic and for the sake of brevity, the terms e2βz and eiωt are suppressed from equation (1).
Under consideration of the exponential depth-wise inhomogeneity of properties in each medium, one can take the following relation for all three mediums, along z-axis:
where cij = elastic constants and
In order to uncouple equation (1), a set of displacement-potential functions F and χ presented by Eskandari-Ghadi and Amiri-Hezaveh [6] are employed. Accordingly, the displacement components ur, uθ, and uz are expressed with respect to F and χ as follows:
where
and
Substituting equation (3) into equation (1), two separated governing partial differential equations (PDEs) for the potential functions, F and χ, can be achieved as follows:
Here,
and
Here,
By means of Fourier expansions with respect to the angular coordinate θ, then employing the mth order Hankel transform with respect to the radial coordinate r, equations (6) and (7) can be reduced as follows:
where
It should be noted for the corresponding definitions of Fourier expansions and Hankel transform, one can refer to Rahimian et al. [42] as well. In the above, the superscript m over a quantity with tilde sign denotes mth order of Hankel transform, where ξ is the Hankel transform parameter. Likewise, the subscript m is utilized for the mth term of its Fourier expansion [43].
The general solutions of the ordinary differential equations (ODEs)—equations (12) and (13)—are written as follows:
In the previous equations, positive sign, beside β, is assigned to I medium, and negative sign belongs to II and III mediums.
where
To satisfy the radiation condition, the value of λ1, λ2, and λ3 are selected in such a way that
Analogously, stress potential relations can be written as follows:
3. The potential functions in the transformed domain
By means of the radiation condition and due to selection of the branches of λ1, λ2, and λ3, terms of
in medium I,
in medium II, and
in medium III.
Seeking for the 12 unknown coefficients
where P(r, θ), Q(r, θ) and R(r, θ) are the radial, angular, and vertical components of f(r, θ), respectively. The traction interfacial conditions and the continuity of displacement in z = 0 and z = h provide two matrix equations for obtaining the two sets of integration constants:
where I1(ξ) and I2(ξ) are given in Appendix 1, and
In the equations (27) and (28),
After determination of the unknown coefficients
4. Green’s functions
In this section, Green’s functions related to three types of specific load distribution, including point-load, circular patch-load, and ring-load are expressed. These Green’s functions are very powerful tools for the treatment of practical integral equation formulations in boundary value problems and development of the BEMs.
4.1. Point-load Green’s functions
To obtain the Green’s functions associated with point-load, f P (r, θ, z) as the concentrated traction vector can be decomposed into two components as follows:
δ is the 1D Dirac delta function, eh is the unit horizontal vector in the θ = θ0 direction and is given as follows (Figure 2):

Vertical and horizontal point-load configurations.
er, eθ, and ez are the unit vector in radial, angular, and vertical directions, respectively; Fh and Fv are the point-load magnitudes. By means of the angular expansions of the stress discontinuities across the z = h plane and invoking to orthogonality of the angular eigenfunctions
Afterward, the transformed loading coefficients Xm, Ym, and Zm can be written as follows:
4.2. Patch-load Green’s functions
The loading coefficients Xm, Y m , and Zm for a uniform, time-harmonic circular patch-load of radius a, with resultants Fh and Fv as patch-load resultants values in horizontal and vertical directions at z = h, respectively, can be shown as follows:
4.3. Ring-load Green’s functions
In order to determine the loading coefficients Xm, Ym, and Zm corresponding to a uniform, time-harmonic radial ring-load of radius a, with resultants Fh and Fv as in horizontal and vertical directions, respectively, one may find as follows:
Depending on point-load, patch-load, or ring-load, the corresponding loading coefficients Xm, Ym, and Zm can be found. Then, by appropriate substitution in the source terms equations (27) and (28), the source terms are fully determined. Henceforth, as described in the previous section, the 12 unknown coefficients and the transformed displacement potentials can be obtained. With the aid of Hankel inversion theorem and Fourier expansions, the displacement and stress for point-load, patch-load, or ring-load Green’s functions can finally be written as follows:
In the previous equations, the symbols “
5. Numerical scheme
The closed-form solution for the semi-infinite 1D integrals presented in the previous section—due to the complexity, inherent oscillatory, and singular nature of the kernels—is not possible. In dealing with numerical evaluation of integrations, two challenges are ahead: First, inherent oscillatory and weak decay of the integrands; due to the existence of Bessel functions. Second, multiplicity of singularities is located in line of integration, including poles and branch points.
As a remedy for the first problem, an adaptive quadrature numerical method can be proposed. In this method, unlike the trapezoidal and Simpson rules, depending on the changes in the integrand function, range of integration is divided to unequal intervals. In this study, the suggested adaptive quadrature method is employed, which is incorporated in Wolfram Mathematica software. Moreover, encountered in the second problem, one can try to extend the method of residues in Rahimian et al. [42], But, because of the multiplicity of layers and the inhomogeneity involved, several strong and weak singularities such as poles and branch points are located along the line of integration. This in turn causes great difficulties for finding the exact location of corresponding points. So, such a method is impractical and inaccurate. Accordingly, an alternative and reliable approach for such problems is desired. By the method of numerical contour integration pioneered by Pak [39,40], the original path of integration, Г0+Г3, can be replaced by a new contour, Г1+Г2+Г3 (see Figure 3). The alternative contour is chosen such that all singularities in the first quadrant are enclosed between it and the original real axis of integration, while the new contour is free of any singularities. On this contour, the integrals can readily be evaluated by ordinary quadrature methods. The result is verified to ensure getting the same responses under different replaced contours and that all integrations are path-independent. So, stable convergence and reliable results can also be achieved economically. It is worth noting that for the sake of numerical purposes, the upper limit of semi-infinite line-integrals is truncated at a prescribed finite value in such a way, a negligible error may occur, by comparisons with available results in the literature.

Contour of integration.
6. Specific cases and verification
In the previous section, the 3D dynamic Green’s functions in the form of explicit semi-infinite line-integrals, involved of point-load, patch-load, and ring-load, are presented. Subsequently, the numerical scheme for their treatment was mentioned. In this section, attention will now be confined to verification of three degenerated cases as discussed in what follows. It should be noted, henceforth, all numerical results presented here are dimensionless, with non-dimensional frequency defined as
6.1. Transversely isotropic tri-materials
By taking material properties—presented in Table 1—and upon setting β
I
= β
II
= β
III
= 0, the problem associated with a transversely isotropic tri-material composite studied by Khojasteh et al. [15] is recovered. Figures 10 and 11 show the real and imaginary parts of horizontal displacement
Properties of transversely isotropic tri-material.
6.2. Exponentially graded transversely isotropic half-space
Imposing the limit

Real parts of displacement Green’s function

Imaginary parts of displacement Green’s function
6.3. Exponentially graded incompressible isotropic half-space
Upon taking the same description in previous verification, for achievement of exponentially graded incompressible isotropic half-space, one may set c44 = c66 = μ, c12 = c13 = λ, c11 = c33 = λ+ 2μ as follows:
where λ and μ are Lame constants and v is Poisson’s ratio, and for the sake of considered static conditions, ω0 is set equal to zero. Figure 6 shows the variation of vertical displacement with the initial shear modulus of μ0 = 1 for different depths of loading

Variation of vertical displacement with different depth of loading
7. Graphical illustrations and discussions
In what follows, to assess the effect of material inhomogeneity and vibration frequency on the displacement and stress Green’s functions, some plots corresponding to the final solution of semi-infinite line-integrals are represented with the assumption; the degree of inhomogeneity of the materials are equal (i.e., β I = β II = β III ), and the properties of media I, II, and III of the considered composite tri-materials are listed in Table 1.
Figure 7 depicts the vertical displacement Green’s function due to the vertical patch-load with unit resultant

Displacement Green’s function due to unit resultant patch-load

Variation of vertical displacement under action of vertical point-load

Stress Green’s function
The real and imaginary parts of radial displacement components

Real parts of displacement Green’s function

Imaginary parts of displacement Green’s function

Displacement Green’s function due to unit resultant patch-load

Variation of vertical displacement under action of vertical point-load
In view of the variation of the stress components

Real parts of stress Green’s function

Imaginary parts of stress Green’s function
8. Conclusion
In this paper, 3D dynamic Green’s functions for an exponentially graded transversely isotropic tri-material composite—arising from time-harmonic point-loads, patch-loads, and ring-loads—are examined. With the aid of displacement-potential functions, Fourier and Hankel transforms, the corresponding solution reduced to explicit semi-infinite line-integral representations. The contour integration method as an efficient numerical scheme has also been employed and its accuracy achieved by comparison with some special cases. Finally, some numerical examples are included to demonstrate the significant influences of the material inhomogeneity and vibration frequency on the displacement components and stress transfer process of tri-material composite.
