Studies in multiple sclerosis (MS) report conflicting conclusions regarding fatigue and cognition, which may partly be due to the use of small sample sizes and frequent reliance on a cross-sectional approach.
Objective
The ability to distinguish between these two disabling symptoms is necessary in order to properly assess and treat MS patients.
Methods
In a retrospective analysis, we assessed the correlation between fatigue and neuropsychological (NP) testing using a cross-sectional (n = 465) and longitudinal approach (n = 69). Cognition was measured using a comprehensive battery called the Minimal Assessment of Cognitive Function in MS (MACFIMS), and fatigue was measured with the Fatigue Severity Scale (FSS). FSS scores were categorized as normal (≤4.0), borderline fatigue (4 < FSS < 5.0), and fatigued (≥5.0). Repeat assessments (n = 69) were categorized as improved or worsened by a change in FSS of either 0.5 or 1.0.
Results
MS patients had significantly higher FSS scores than normal controls (P < 0.001). No correlation was found between FSS and NP scores in either cross-sectional or longitudinal analyses. Fatigue was moderately correlated with depression, assessed using the Beck Depression Inventory Fast Screen (BDIFS) (r = 0.44, P < 0.001). Longitudinally, there was a medium correlation between change in FSS and BDIFS (r = 0.34, P = 0.001), but no significant differences on NP scores using either definition of change.
Conclusion
We conclude that self-reported fatigue, while correlated with self-reported depression, is not significantly related to cognitive capacity in MS.
1 Miller, DM. Multiple Sclerosis Council for Clinical Practice Guidelines. Fatigue and multiple sclerosis: evidence-based management strategies for fatigue in multiple sclerosis. In: Clinical practice guidelines. Washington, DC: Paralyzed Veterans of America; 1998: pp. 1–46.
2.
2 Putzki N Katsarava Z Vago S Diener HC Limmroth V . Prevalence and severity of multiple-sclerosis-associated fatigue in treated and untreated patients. Eur Neurol2008; 59: 136–142.
3.
3 Lerdal A Celius EG Krupp L Dahl AA . A prospective study of patterns of fatigue in multiple sclerosis. Eur J Neurol2007; 14: 1338–1343.
4.
4 Wynia K Middel B van Dijk JP De Keyser JH Reijneveld SA . The impact of disabilities on quality of life in people with multiple sclerosis. Mult Scler2008; 14: 972–980.
5.
5 Freal JE Kraft GH Coryell JK . Symptomatic fatigue in multiple sclerosis. Arch Phys Med Rehabil1984; 65: 135–138.
6.
6 Fisk JD Pontefract A Ritvo PG Archibald CJ Murray RJ . The impact of fatigue on patients with multiple sclerosis. Can J Neurol Sci1994; 21: 9–14.
7.
7 Debouverie M Pittion-Vouyovitch S Brissart H Guillemin F . Physical dimension of fatigue correlated with disability change over time in patients with multiple sclerosis. J Neurol2008; 255: 633–636.
8.
8 Tellez N Rio J Tintore M Nos C Galan I Montalban X . Fatigue in multiple sclerosis persists over time: a longitudinal study. J Neurol2006; 253: 1466–1470.
9.
9 Johansson S Ytterberg C Hillert J Widen Holmqvist L von Koch L . A longitudinal study of variations in and predictors of fatigue in multiple sclerosis. J Neurol Neurosurg Psychiatry2008; 79: 454–457.
10.
10 Bobholz JA Rao SM . Cognitive dysfunction in multiple sclerosis: a review of recent developments. Curr Opin Neurol2003; 16: 283–288.
11.
11 Benedict RHB Cookfair D Gavett R . Validity of the minimal assessment of cognitive function in multiple sclerosis (MACFIMS). J Int Neuropsychol Soc2006; 12: 549–558.
12.
12 Rao SM Leo GJ Ellington L Nauertz T Bernardin L Unveragt F . Cognitive dysfunction in multiple sclerosis. II. Impact on employment and social functioning. Neurology1991; 41: 692–696.
13.
13 Benedict RHB Wahlig E Bakshi R . Predicting quality of life in multiple sclerosis: accounting for physical disability, fatigue, cognition, mood disorder, personality, and behavior change. J Neurol Sci2005; 231: 29–34.
14.
14 Benedict RH Zivadinov R . Predicting neuropsychological abnormalities in multiple sclerosis. J Neurol Sci2006; 245: 67–72.
15.
15 Middleton LS Denney DR Lynch SG Parmenter B . The relationship between perceived and objective cognitive functioning in multiple sclerosis. Arch Clin Neuropsychol2006; 21: 487–494.
16.
16 Diamond BJ Johnson SK Kaufman M Graves L . Relationships between information processing, depression, fatigue and cognition in multiple sclerosis. Arch Clin Neuropsychol2008; 23: 189–199.
17.
17 Schwid SR Tyler CM Scheid EA Weinstein A Goodman AD McDermott MP . Cognitive fatigue during a test requiring sustained attention: a pilot study. Mult Scler2003; 9: 503–508.
18.
18 Krupp LB . Fatigue and declines in cognitive functioning in multiple sclerosis. Neurology2000; 55: 934–939.
19.
19 Bailey A Channon S Beaumont JG . The relationship between subjective fatigue and cognitive fatigue in advanced multiple sclerosis. Mult Scler2007; 13: 73–80.
20.
20 Parmenter BA Denney DR Lynch SG . The cognitive performance of patients with multiple sclerosis during periods of high and low fatigue. Mult Scler2003; 9: 111–118.
21.
21 Figved N Benedict R Klevan G . Relationship of cognitive impairment to psychiatric symptoms in multiple sclerosis. Mult Scler2008; 14: 1084–1090.
22.
22 Flachenecker P Kumpfel T Kallmann B . Fatigue in multiple sclerosis: a comparison of different rating scales and correlation to clinical parameters. Mult Scler2002; 8: 523–526.
23.
23 Bakshi R Shaikh ZA Miletich RS . Fatigue in multiple sclerosis and its relationship to depression and neurologic disability. Mult Scler2000; 6: 181–185.
24.
24 Polman CH Reingold SC Edan G . Diagnostic criteria for multiple sclerosis: 2005 revisions to the "McDonald Criteria". Ann Neurol2005; 58: 840–846.
25.
25 Kurtzke JF . Rating neurologic impairment in multiple sclerosis: an expanded disability status scale (EDSS). Ann Neurol1983; 13: 227–231.
26.
26 Krupp LB LaRocca NG Muir-Nash J Steinberg AD . The fatigue severity scale. Application to patients with multiple sclerosis and systemic lupus erythematosus. Arch Neurol1989; 46: 1121–1123.
27.
27 Chipchase SY Lincoln NB Radford KA . Measuring fatigue in people with multiple sclerosis. Disabil Rehabil2003; 25: 778–784.
28.
28 Benedict RHB Fischer JS Archibald CJ . Minimal neuropsychological assessment of MS patients: a consensus approach. Clin Neuropsychol2002; 16: 381–397.
29.
29 Benedict RH Duquin JA Jurgensen S . Repeated assessment of neuropsychological deficits in multiple sclerosis using the Symbol Digit Modalities Test and the MS Neuropsychological Screening Questionnaire. Mult Scler2008; 14: 940–946.
30.
30 Rao SM; . A manual for the brief, repeatable battery of neuropsychological tests in multiple sclerosis. National Multiple Sclerosis Society, New York, NY; 1991.
31.
31 Fischer JS Rudick RA Cutter GR Reingold SC . The Multiple Sclerosis Functional Composite Measure (MSFC): an integrated approach to MS clinical outcome assessment. National MS Society Clinical Outcomes Assessment Task Force. Mult Scler1999; 5: 244–250.
32.
32 Delis DC Kramer JH Kaplan E Ober BA . California verbal learning test: adult version.San Antonio, TX: Psychological Corporation; 2000.
33.
33 Benedict RHB . Brief visuospatial memory test - Revised: professional manual.Odessa, FL: Psychological Assessment Resources; 1997.
34.
34 Benton, AL, Hamsher, K. Multilingual aphasia examination.Iowa City: AJA Associates; 1989.
35.
35 Benton AL Sivan AB Hamsher K Varney NR Spreen O . Contributions to neuropsychological assessment.2nd ed.New York: Oxford University Press; 1994.
36.
36 Delis, DC, Kaplan, E, Kramer, JH. California sorting test.Psychological Corporation, San Antonio, TX; 2001.
37.
37 Benedict RHB Fishman I McClellan MM Bakshi R Weinstock-Guttman B . Validity of the Beck Depression Inventory - Fast Screen in multiple sclerosis. Mult Scler2003; 9: 393–396.
38.
38 Duquin JA Parmenter BA Benedict RHB . Influence of recruitment and participation bias on neuropsychological research among MS patients. J Int Neuropsychol Soc2008; 14: 494–498.
39.
39 Ytterberg C Johansson S Holmqvist LW von Koch L . Longitudinal variations and predictors of increased perceived impact of multiple sclerosis, a two-year study. J Neurol Sci2008; 270: 53–59.
40.
40 Rossini PM Pasqualetti P Pozzilli C . Fatigue in progressive multiple sclerosis: results of a randomized, double-blind, placebo-controlled, crossover trial of oral 4-aminopyridine. Mult Scler2001; 7: 354–358.
41.
41 Rammohan KW Rosenberg JH Lynn DJ Blumenfeld AM Pollak CP Nagaraja HN . Efficacy and safety of modafinil (Provigil) for the treatment of fatigue in multiple sclerosis: a two centre phase 2 study. J Neurol Neurosurg Psychiatry2002; 72: 179–183.
42.
42 Voss VD Arnett PA Higginson C Randolph JJ Campos MD Dyck DG . Contributing factors to depressed mood in Multiple Sclerosis. Arch Clin Neuropsych2002; 17: 103–115.
43.
43 Lerdal A Celius EG Krupp L Dahl AA . A prospective study of patterns of fatigue in multiple sclerosis. Eur J Neurol2007; 14: 1338–1343.
44.
44 Hoogervorst EL van Winsen LM Eikelenboom ML Kalkers NF Uitdehaag BM Polman CH . Comparison of patients self-report, neurological examination and functional impairment in MS. Neurology2001; 56: 934–937.
45.
45 Glanz BI Holland CM Gauthier SA . Cognitive dysfunction in patients with clinically isolated syndromes or newly diagnosed multiple sclerosis. Mult Scler2007; 13: 1004–1010.
46.
46 Christodoulou C Krupp LB Liang Z . Cognitive performance and MR markers of cerebral injury in cognitively impaired MS patients. Neurology2003; 60: 1793–1798.
47.
47 Parmenter RHB Weinstock-Guttman B Garg N Munschauer F Benedict RH . Screening for cognitive impairment in multiple sclerosis using the Symbol Digit Modalities Test. Mult Scler2007; 13: 52–57.
48.
48 Houtchens MK Benedict RHB Killiany R . Thalamic atrophy and cognition in multiple sclerosis. Neurology2007; 69: 113–123.
49.
49 Tekok-Kilic A Benedict RHB Weinstock-Guttman B . Independent contributions of cortical gray matter atrophy and ventricle enlargement for predicting neuropsychological impairment in multiple sclerosis. Neuroimage2007; 36: 1294–1300.
50.
50 Johnson SK Lange G DeLuca J Korn LR Natelson BH . The effects of fatigue on neuropsychological performance in patients with chronic fatigue syndrome, multiple sclerosis, and depression. Appl Neuropsychol1997; 4: 145–153.
51.
51 Rao SM Leo GJ Bernardin L Unverzagt F . Cognitive dysfunction in multiple sclerosis. I. Frequency, patterns, and prediction. Neurology1991; 41: 685–691.
52.
52 Paul RH Beatty WW Schneider R Blanco CR Hames KA . Cognitive and physical fatigue in multiple sclerosis: relations between self-report and objective performance. Appl Neuropsychol1998; 5: 143–148.
53.
53 Archiron A Barak Y . Cognitive impairment in probable multiple sclerosis. J Neurol Neurosurg Psychiatry2003; 74: 443–446.
54.
54 Amato MP Ponziani G Siracusa G Sorbi S . Cognitive dysfunction in early-onset multiple sclerosis: a reappraisal after 10 years. Arch Neurol2001; 58: 1602–1606.
55.
55 Barker-Collo SL . Within session practice effects on the PASAT in clients with multiple sclerosis. Arch Clin Neuropsychol2005; 20: 145–152.
56.
56 Tombaugh TN . A comprehensive review of the Paced Auditory Serial Addition Test (PASAT). Arch Clin Neuropsychol2006; 21: 53–76.
57.
57 Nagels G D'Hooghe MB Kos D Engelborghs S De Deyn PP . Within-session practice effect on paced auditory serial addition test in multiple sclerosis. Mult Scler2008; 14: 106–111.
58.
58 Amato MP Zipoli V Portaccio E . Multiple sclerosis-related cognitive changes: a review of cross-sectional and longitudinal studies. J Neurol Sci2006; 245: 41–46.
59.
59 Rudick R Antel J Confavreux C . Recommendations from the National Multiple Sclerosis Society Clinical Outcomes Assessment Task Force. Ann Neurol1997; 42: 379–382.
