Reducing student ‘suspension rates’ and engaging students in learning: principal and teacher approaches that work

Abstract

The negative effects of student suspension from school on both the individual and the community are well documented and relate to a wide range of matters, including school completion rates, homelessness and crime. Two recent, extensive reviews of student suspensions in government and non-government schools in N.S.W. (Gonczi and Riordan, 2002; Riordan and Gonczi, 2003) suggest that variations among schools in rates of student suspension may be best explained by ‘school effects’ and not characteristics of students. This article explores the key issues of principal and teacher attitudes and actions in relation to student suspensions with reference to three case studies. The discussion of these cases raises some key considerations for principals and teachers in difficult schools who wish to re-engage students in learning. Key themes discussed in this article include: the importance of a pedagogical as opposed to a punitive response to student misbehaviour; working in partnership with parents and the broader community to address behaviour and learning problems; and interpreting ‘state’ and ‘school system’ policies on student welfare and discipline through the lens of the school’s local context.

Keywords

community engagement leadership student suspension

References

Banks, R. (1997) Bullying in Schools. ERIC Digest. Champaign, IL: ERIC Clearinghouse on Elementary and Early Childhood Education .

Chung, G. & Paul, R. (1996) School-Wide Discipline Policies: In-School Suspension in One Middle School. Charlottesville, VA: University of Virginia (ERIC Document Reproduction Service Number ED420105).

Downing, H. & Keaster, R. (1998) Involving the community in in-school suspension . Middle School Journal, 30(1), 40-44 .

Farner, C. D. (1996) Proactive alternatives to school suspension . Reclaiming Children & Youth: Journal of Emotional & Behavioral Problems, 5(1), 47-51 .

Gladden, R. M. (2002) Reducing school violence: strengthening student programs and addressing the role of school organisations. In W. G. Secada (ed.) Review of Research in Education, pp. 263-299. Washington, DC: American Educational Research Association .

Gonczi, A. & Riordan, G. (2002) Measuring and Reporting on Discipline and Student Suspensions in NSW Government Schools. Sydney: University of Technology, Sydney .

Howard, S. & Johnson, B. (2000) What makes the difference? Children and teachers talk about resilient outcomes for children ‘at risk’ . Educational Studies, 26(3), 321-337 .

Meyenn, B. & Parker, J. (2001) Naughty boys at school: perspectives on boys and discipline. In W. Martino & B. Meyenn (eds) What about the Boys? Issues of Masculinity in Schools, pp. 169-185. Buckingham: Open University Press .

N. S. W. Department of Education and Training (1996) Student Welfare, Good Discipline and Effective Learning. Sydney: NSW Department of Education Training .

10.

N. S. W. Department of Education and Training (1999) Procedures for the Suspension and Expulsion of School Students. Sydney: NSW Department of Education Training .

11.

N. S. W. Department of Education and Training (2004) Statistical Bulletin: Schools and Students in New South Wales, 2003. Sydney: NSW Department of Education and Training .

12.

Pounder, D. G. , ed. (1998) Restructuring Schools for Collaboration: Promises and Pitfall. New York: S.U.N.Y .

13.

Rigby, K (2002) How successful are anti-bullying programs for schools ? Paper presented at the Role of Schools in Crime Prevention Conference, Carlton Crest Hotel, Melbourne, 30 September -1 October.

14.

Riordan, G. & Gonczi, A. (2003) Suspension and Expulsion of Students from Non-government Schools in NSW: Current Policies and Practices. Sydney: University of Technology Sydney .

15.

Schetzer, L. (2000) Being fair: procedural fairness in school disciplinary decisions . In Y. Webb (ed.) ‘The Law: Sword or Shield? Proceedings of the Australian and New Zealand Education Law Association (ANZELA) 2000 Annual Conference, pp. 48-52 . Adelaide: Australian and New Zealand Education Law Association.

16.

Stranger, M. (2002) Student Absence from School and Juvenile Crime Project. Hobart, Tasmania: Faculty of Law and School of Sociology and Social Work, University of Tasmania .