This article advances on existing studies in agenda-building theory, examining how a prominent sports magazine can build an agenda for mainstream press coverage, which in turn assists in building policy agendas. When Ken Caminiti, a former Most Valuable Player in the National League, admitted to Sports Illustrated in June 2002 that he used anabolic steroids during his award-winning season, mainstream newspaper journalists reported the revelations heavily, with many calling for changes in policy and the introduction of drug testing. As discussed here, policy-makers apparently listened: approximately three months after the magazine exposé appeared, baseball instituted a drug testing procedure. The study reveals how mainstream newspaper reports (n = 231) built on the Sports Illustrated investigation and how policy-makers reacted to a widespread condemnation of professional baseball, namely its apparent inability to police itself.
References
1.
Alzado, Lyle and Shelley Smith (1991) ‘I’m Sick and I’m Scared’, Sports Illustrated, 8 July: 21–27.
2.
Anderson, William B. (2001) ‘Saving the National Pastime’s Image: Crisis Management during the 1919 Black Sox Scandal’ , Journalism History27(3): 105–111 .
3.
Associated Press (2002) ‘Caminiti: I Used Steroids During MVP Season’, Newsday, 29 May.
4.
Bennett, W. Lance and Regina G. Lawrence (1995) ‘News Icons and the Mainstreaming of Social Change’ , Journal of Communication45(3): 20–39 .
5.
Berkowitz, Dan (1987) ‘TV News Sources and News Channels: A Study in Agenda Building’ , Journalism Quarterly64(2–3): 508–513 .
6.
Berkowitz, Dan and Douglas B. Adams (1990) ‘Information Subsidy and Agenda-Building in Local Television News’ , Journalism Quarterly67(4): 723–731 .
7.
Boston Herald (2002) ‘Baseball Must Stop Player Steroid Use’, 2 June.
Cassara, Catherine (1998) ‘U.S. Newspaper Coverage of Human Rights in Latin America, 1975–1982: Exploring President Carter’s Agenda Building Process’ , Journalism & Mass Communication Quarterly75(3): 478–487 .
10.
Denham, Bryan (1997) ‘Sports Illustrated, “The War on Drugs,” and the Anabolic Steroid Control Act of 1990: A Study in Agenda Building and Political Timing’ , Journal of Sport & Social Issues21(3): 260–273 .
11.
Denham, Bryan (1999) ‘Building the Agenda and Adjusting the Frame: How the Dramatic Revelations of Lyle Alzado Impacted Mainstream Press Coverage of Anabolic Steroid Use’ , Sociology of Sport Journal16(1): 1–15 .
12.
Denham, Bryan (2001) ‘Editorial Reaction to the Jim Gray–Pete Rose Confrontation’ , Media Ethics (Spring): 4-4, 19–21 .
13.
DePledge, Derrick (2002) ‘Lawmakers Urge Drug Testing in Baseball’, USA Today, 12 July: C1-C1.
14.
Elder, Charles D. and Roger W. Cobb (1984) ‘Agenda-building and the Politics of Aging’ , Policy Studies Journal13: 115–129 .
15.
Epstein, Edward (2002) ‘Senators Warn Baseball about Use of Steroids’, San Francisco Chronicle, 19 June.
16.
Gans, Herbert J. (1979) Deciding What’s News. New York: Vintage .
17.
Hermoso, Rafael and Tyler Kepner (2002) ‘Steroid Use Becomes a Topic of Discussion in Clubhouses’, The New York Times, 30 May.
18.
Houston Chronicle (2002) ‘Congress Casts an Eye on the Juice’, 11 June.
19.
Kennamer, J. David (1994) Public Opinion, The Press, and Public Policy. Westport, CT: Praeger .
20.
Kingdon, John W. (1984) Agendas, Alternatives, and Public Policies. Boston, MA: Little, Brown .
21.
Knapp, Gwen (2002) ‘Baseball Must Deal with Steroid Shame; League’s Legitimacy Is at Stake’, San Francisco Chronicle, 30 May.
22.
Lagarde, Dave (2002) ‘Baseball Should Outlaw Steroids’, New Orleans Times-Picayune, 2 June.
23.
Lang, Gladys Engel and Kurt Lang (1983) The Battle for Public Opinion: The President, The Press, and The Polls During Watergate. New York: Columbia University Press .
24.
McCombs, Maxwell (1994) ‘News Influence on Our Pictures of The World’, in Jennings Bryant and Dolf Zillmann (eds) Media Effects: Advances in Theory and Research, pp. 1–16. Hillsdale, NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum .
25.
McCombs, Maxwell E. and David L. Protess (1991) Setting the Agenda: Readings on Media, Public Opinion, and Policymaking. Hillsdale, NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum .
26.
McCombs, Maxwell E. and Donald L. Shaw (1972) ‘The Agenda-Setting Function of Mass Media’ , Public Opinion Quarterly36: 176–187 .
27.
Manning, Paul (2001) News and News Sources: A Critical Introduction. London: Sage .
28.
Manoff, Robert K. and Michael Schudson (1986) Reading the News. New York: Pantheon .
29.
Matthews, Gray (1995) ‘Epideictic Rhetoric and Baseball: Nurturing Community through Controversy’ , Southern Communication Journal60(4): 275–291 .
30.
Newsday (2002) ‘Rule Out Roids’, 1 June.
31.
Ohl, Coral M., J. David Pincus, Tony Rimmer and Denise Harrison (1995) ‘Agenda Building Role of News Releases in Corporate Takeovers’ , Public Relations Review21(2): 89–102 .
32.
Ostler, Scott (2002) ‘Baseball Players Have the Juice to Stop It’, San Francisco Chronicle, 30 May.
Protess, David L., Fay Lomax Cook, Jack C. Doppelt, James S. Ettema, Margaret T. Gordon, Donna R. Leff, and Peter Miller (1991) The Journalism of Outrage: Investigative Reporting and Agenda Building in America. New York: The Guilford Press .
35.
Pugmire, Lance (2002) ‘Dying to be Heard’, The Los Angeles Times, 31 July.
36.
Reid, Jason (2002) ‘Caminiti Admits Using Steroids’, The Los Angeles Times, 29 May.
37.
San Francisco Chronicle (2002) ‘Powered by Steroids?’, 31 May.
38.
Saraceno, Jon (2002) ‘Drug Use Dirties Game, Records’, USA Today, 30 May.
Smizik, Bob (2002) ‘Time to Change Stance on Steroids’, Pittsburgh Post-Gazette, 30 May.
45.
Strauss, Joe (2002) ‘La Russa Wants Steroid Use Punished’, St Louis Post-Dispatch, 30 May.
46.
The Baltimore Sun (2002) ‘Freak Show’, 3 June.
47.
Tuchman, Gaye (1978) Making News: A Study in the Construction of Reality. New York: The Free Press .
48.
USA Today (2002) ‘Drug Tests Approved in California’, 27 June: C1-C1.
49.
Van Slyke Turk, Judy (1986) ‘Information Subsidies and Media Content: A Study of Public Relations Influences on the News’ , Journalism Monographs (December).
50.
Verducci, Tom (2002) ‘Totally Juiced’, Sports Illustrated, 3 June: 34–48.
51.
Walder, Barbara (2002) ‘Expose Should Spur Stronger Coverage’, Newsday, 7 June.
52.
Walters, T. N., L. M. Walters and Roger Gray (1996) ‘Agenda Building in the 1992 Presidential Campaign’ , Public Relations Review22(1): 9–25 .
53.
Wanta, Wayne (1991) ‘Presidential Approval Ratings Variable in the Agenda-Building Process’ , Journalism Quarterly68(4): 672–680 .
54.
Weaver, David and S. N. Elliott (1985) ‘Who Sets the Agenda for the Media? A Study of Local Agenda-Building’ , Journalism Quarterly62(2): 54–60 .
55.
Williamson Kanervo, Ellen and David Kanervo (1989) ‘How Town Administrator’s View Relates to Agenda Building in Community Press’ , Journalism Quarterly66(2): 308–316 .
