This study supplements extant literature on implementation in the European Union
(EU). The quantitative analysis, which covers the EU transport acquis, reveals five
main findings. First, the EU has a transposition deficit in this area, with almost
70% of all national legal instruments causing problems. Second, transposition delay
is multifaceted. The results provide strong support for the assertion that
distinguishing between the outcomes of the transposition process (on time, short
delay or long delay) is a useful method of investigation. Third, factors specific to
European directives (level of discretion and transposition deadline) and
domestic-level factors (national transposition package and number of veto players)
have different effects on the length of delay. Furthermore, the timing of general
elections in member states as well as policy (sub)sector-related accidents influence
the timeliness of national transposition processes.
Alesina, A.
and
A. Drazen
(1991)
`Why Are Stabilizations Delayed?'
, American Economic Review81:
1170—88.
2.
Alesina, A.
,
I. Angeloni
and
L. Schuknecht
(2005)
`What Does the European Union Do?'
, Public Choice123(3—4):
275—319.
3.
Berglund, S.
,
I. Gange
and
F. van Waarden
(2006)
`Mass Production of Law. Routinization in Transposition ofEuropean Directives. A Sociological-Institutional Account', Journal of European
Public Policy13(5):
692—716.
4.
Börzel, T.A.
(2001)
`Non-Compliance in the European Union: Pathology or Statistical
Artifact?'
, Journal of European Public Policy8(5):
803—24.
5.
Börzel, T.A.
(2003) Environmental Leaders and Laggards in Europe: Why
There Is (Not) a `Southern Problem'. Aldershot, UK:
Ashgate
.
6.
Börzel, T.A.
and
T. Risse
(2003) `Conceptualizing the Domestic Impact of Europe
', in
Kevin Featherstone
and
Claudio Radaelli
(eds) The Politics of Europeanization , pp.
57—82. Oxford:
Oxford University Press.
7.
Börzel, T.A.
,
T. Hoffmann
and
M. Dudziak
(2005) `
Who's Afraid of the ECJ? Member States, Court Referrals, and
(Non-)Compliance
', paper presented at the 33rd Joint Sessions of
Workshops, Granada, Spain.
8.
Borghetto, E.
,
F. Franchino
and
D. Giannetti
(2006) `
Complying with the Transposition Deadlines of EU Directives. Evidence from
Italy
', Rivista Italiana di Politiche Pubbliche1:
7—38.
9.
Bursens, P.
(2002)
`Why Denmark and Belgium Have Different Implementation Records: On
Transposition Laggards and Leaders in the EU'
, Scandinavian Political Studies25(2):
173—95.
10.
Conant, L.
(2002) Justice Contained. Law and Politics in theEuropean Union. New
York:
Cornell University Press
.
11.
Drazen, A.
and
V. Grilli
(1993)
`The Benefit of Crises for Economic Reforms'
, American Economic Review83(3):
598—607.
12.
Duina, F.
(1997)
`Explaining Legal Implementation in the European Union'
, International Journal of the Sociology of Law25:
155—79.
13.
Eijlander, P.
and
W. Voermans
(2000) Wetgevingsleer. Den
Haag: Boom Juridische
Uitgevers.
14.
Elmore, R.F.
(1979)
`Backward Mapping: Implementation Research and Policy Decisions'
, Political Science Quarterly94(4):
601—16.
15.
Epstein, D.
and S. O'Halloran (1999) Delegating Powers: A Transaction
Cost Politics Approach to Policy Making under Separate Powers.
Cambridge: Cambridge University
Press.
16.
European Commission
(2006) Internal Market Scoreboard.
Brussels: Internal Market and
Services DG.
17.
Falkner, G.
,
E. Causse
and
C. Wiedermann
(2006) `
Post-Accession Compliance in Central and Eastern Europe: Transposition and
Application after the Age of Carrots and Sticks
', paper presented at the eps-net plenary conference ,
16—17 June, Budapest, Hungary.
18.
Falkner, G.
,
M. Hartlapp
,
S. Leiber
and
O. Treib
(2004)
`Non-Compliance with EU Directives in the Member States: Opposition through
the Backdoor?'
, West European Politics27(3):
452—73.
19.
Falkner, G.
,
O. Treib
,
M. Hartlapp
and
S. Leiber
(2005) Complying with Europe? The Impact of EU Minimum
Harmonisation and Soft Law in the Member States.
Cambridge : Cambridge University
Press.
20.
Franchino, F.
(2004)
`Delegating Powers in the European Community'
, British Journal of Political Science34:
269—93.
21.
Franchino, F.
(2005a)
`A Formal Model of Delegation in the European Union'
, Journal of Theoretical Politics17(2):
217—47.
22.
Franchino, F.
(2005b)
`The Study of EU Public Policy — Results of a Survey'
, European Union Politics6(2):
243—52.
23.
Giuliani, M.
(2003) `Europeanization in Comparative Perspective:
Institutional Fit and National Adaptation', in
Kevin Featherstone
and
Claudio Radaelli
(eds) The Politics of Europeanization, pp.
134—55. Oxford:
Oxford University Press.
24.
Giuliani, M.
(2005) `EU Policies and Domestic Compliance: Between
International Relations, Implementation and Europeanization', Working
Paper No. 5, Unità di Ricerca sulla Governance Europea
(URGE), Fondazione Collegio Carlo Alberto,
Moncalieri.
25.
Giuliani, M.
(2006) `Dov'è il problema? L'Italia e il
recepimento della normativa comunitaria',
Unità di Ricerca sulla Governance Europea
(URGE), Fondazione Collegio Carlo Alberto,
Moncalieri.
26.
Giuliani, M.
and
S. Piattoni
(2006) `Italy: Back to the Future or Steps Toward
Normalità? ', in
E. Zeff
and
E.B. Pirro
(eds) The European Union and the Member States, pp.
85—106. London:
Lynne Rienner Publishers.
27.
Haverland, M.
(2000) `
National Adaptation to European Integration: The Importance of
Institutional Veto Points
', Journal of Public Policy20(1):
83—103.
28.
Haverland, M.
and
M. Romeijn
(2007) `
Do Member States Make European Policies Work? Analyzing the EU
Transposition Deficit
', Public Administration (forthcoming).
29.
Héritier, A.
(2002)
`Public-Interest Services Revisited'
, Journal of European Public Policy9(6):
995—1019.
30.
Héritier, A.
,
D. Kerwer
,
C. Knill
,
D. Lehmkuhl
,
M. Teutsch
and
A.-C. Douillet
(2001), Differential Europe: New Opportunities and
Restrictions for Policymaking in the Member States.
Lanham, MD: Rowman &
Littlefield.
31.
Hille, P.
and
C. Knill
(2006)
`“It's the Bureaucracy, Stupid”. The Implementation
of the Acquis Communautaire in EU Candidate Countries,
1999—2003'
, European Union Politics7(4):
531—52.
32.
Hudson, G.
(2005) `On the Trail of National Implementation Measures',
Focus,
University of Bradford
, July/August.
33.
Kaeding, M.
(2006)
`Determinants of Transposition Delay in the European Union. The Member
State Perspective,'Journal of Public Policy26(3):
229—53.
34.
Kaeding, M.
(2007) Better Regulation in the European Union —
Lost in Translation or Full Steam Ahead? The Transposition of EU Transport
Directives across Member States. Leiden:
Leiden University Press.
35.
Knill, C.
and
Lehmkuhl, D.
(2000)
`An Alternative Route of European Integration: The Community's Railways
Policy'
, West European Politics23(1):
65—88.
36.
Kok, W.
(2004) Facing the Challenge. The Lisbon Strategy for Growth
and Employment. Luxembourg:
European Commission
.
37.
König, T.
,
B. Luetgert
and
L. Mäder
(2005) `
Troubles with Timeliness: Explaining Trends in Transposition Delay
', paper presented at the 33rd Joint Sessions of Workshops in
Granada, Spain.
38.
Koutalakis, C.
(2004)
`Environmental Compliance in Italy and Greece: The Role of Non-State
Actors'
, Environmental Politics13(4):
754—74.
39.
Krislov, S.
,
C. Ehlermann
and
J. Weiler
(1986) `The Political Organs and the Decision-Making Process
in the United States and the European Community', in
M. Cappelletti
,
M. Seccombe
and
J. Weiler
(eds) Integration through Law: Europe and the American Federal
Experience, vol. 1, book 2, pp. 3—110.
Berlin: Walter de
Gruyter.
40.
Linos, K.
(2007)
`How Can International Organizations Shape National Welfare States?
Evidence from Compliance with European Union Directives'
, Comparative Political Studies40(5):
547—70.
41.
Long, J.S.
(1997) Regression Models for Categorical and Limited
Dependent Variables, Vol. 7 of Advanced Quantitative Techniques in the Social
Sciences . Thousand Oaks, CA:
Sage Publications .
42.
Long, J.
and
J. Freese
(2003) Regression Models for Categorical Dependent Variables
using Stata. Texas:
Stata Press
.
43.
Majone, G.
(1996) Regulating Europe.
London:
Routledge.
44.
Mastenbroek, E.
(2003)
`Surviving the Deadline: Transposition of EU Directives in the
Netherlands'
, European Union Politics4(4):
371—55.
45.
Mastenbroek, E.
(2005)
`EU Compliance: Still a “Black Hole”?'
, Journal of European Public Policy12(6):
1103—20.
46.
Mastenbroek, E.
and
M. Kaeding
(2006)
`Europeanization beyond the Goodness of Fit: Domestic Politics in the
Forefront'
, Comparative European Politics4:
331—54.
47.
Mbaye, H.A.D.
(2001)
`Why National States Comply with Supranational Law'
, European Union Politics2(3):
259—81.
48.
Müller, W.C.
and
K. Strom
(2004) Coalition Governments in Western Europe.
Oxford: Oxford University
Press.
49.
Nicolaides, P.
and
H. Oberg
(2006) The Compliance Problem in the European Union.
EIPASCOPE 2001/1.
50.
Pappas, S.A.
and
P. Arpino
(1995) National Administrative Procedures for the Preparation
and Implementation of Community Decisions.
Maastricht: Institut
européen d'administration
publique.
51.
Ponsati, C.
(1995)
`The Deadline Effect: A Theoretical Note'
, Economics Letters48:
281—5.
52.
Prechal, S.
(1995) Directives in European Community Law. A Study of
Directives and Their Enforcement in National Courts.
Oxford : Oxford University
Press.
53.
Pressman, J.L.
and
A. Wildavsky
(1973) Implementation. How Great Expectations in Washington
Are Dashed in Oakland; or, Why It's Amazing That Federal Programs Work at
All. Los Angeles: University of
California Press.
54.
Raiffa, H.
,
J. Richardson
and
D. Metcalfe
(2002) Negotiation Analysis: The Science and Art of
Collaborative Decision-Making. Cambridge,
MA: Harvard University
Press.
55.
Shepsle, K.A.
and
M.S. Boncheck
(1997) Analyzing Politics. Rationality, Behavior, and
Institutions. London: W.W.
Norton .
56.
Siedentopf, H.
and
J. Ziller
(1988) Making European Policies Work: The Implementation of
Community Legislation in the Member States.
London: Sage
Publications.
57.
Smith, A.
and
A.C. Stam
(2004)
`Bargaining and the Nature of War'
, Journal of Conflict Resolution48(6):
783—813.
58.
Steunenberg, B.
(2006)
`Turning Swift Policymaking into Deadlock and Delay: National Policy
Coordination and the Transposition of EU Directives'
, European Union Politics7(3):
293—319.
59.
Steunenberg, B.
and
M. Rhinard
(2005) `Hare or Turtle? Member States Catching up with the
Transposition of EU Directives', Leiden University Working
Paper.
60.
Steunenberg, B.
and
W. Voermans
(2005) De omzetting van Europese richtlijnen: Instrumenten,
technieken en processen in zes lidstaten vergleken [The Transposition of EU
Directives: Instruments, Techniques and Processes in Six Member States].
Leiden: WODC, Leiden
Universiteit.
61.
Stevens, H.
(2004) Transport Policy in the European Union.
London:
Palgrave.
62.
Strom, K.
,
W.C. Müller
and
T. Bergman
(2003) Delegation and Accountability in Parliamentary
Democracies. Oxford: Oxford
University Press.
63.
Sverdrup, U.
(2004)
`Compliance and Conflict Resolution in the European Union —
Nordic Exceptionalism'
, Scandinavian Political Studies27(1):
23—43.
64.
Sverdrup, U.
(2005) `Implementation and European Integration: A Review
Essay', Arena Working Paper 25, October. URL (accessed 22 October
2007): http://www.arena.uio.no.
65.
Teutsch, M.
(2001) `Regulating Reforms in the German Transport Sector:
How to Overcome Multiple Veto Points', in A. Héritier, D.
Kerwer, C. Knill, D. Lehmkuhl, M. Teutsch and A.-C. Douillet, Differential
Europe: New Opportunities and Restrictions for Policymaking in the Member
States, pp. 133—72.
Lanham, MD: Rowman &
Littlefield.
66.
Thomson, R.
,
R. Torenvlied
and
J. Arregui
(2005) `
Executive Discretion and the Paradox of Compliance in the European
Union
', paper presented at the ECPR Joint Sessions, Granada,
Spain, 14—19 April.
67.
Treib, O.
(2003)
`Die Umsetzung von EU-Richtlinien im Zeichen der Parteipolitik: Eine
akteurzentrierte Antwort auf die Misfit-These'
, Politische Vierteljahresschrift44(4):
506—28.
68.
Tsebelis, G.
(2001) `Veto Players Data'. URL (accessed 4 July
2004): http://www.polisci.ucla.edu/tsebelis/.
69.
Versluis, E.
(2004) `
Explaining Variations in Implementation of EU Directives
', European Integration online papers
8(19). URL (accessed 22 October 2007):
http://eiop.or.at/eiop/texte/2004—019a.htm .
70.
Wessels, W.
,
A. Maurer
and
J. Mittag.
(2003) Fifteen into One. The European Union and Its Member
States. Manchester: Manchester
University Press.
