The focus of this paper is the effect of nationality on prison disposition in Israel.
An interaction between the nationality of the judge, the perpetrator and the victim
is examined. The data were collected in the northern district courts in Israel and
consist of 1394 court records. The results show that being an Arab defendant is an
inherent liability in the Israeli criminal justice system – they are more
likely than Jews to receive prison sentences. Arab judges seem to be more punitive
than their Jewish colleagues are. The nationality of the victim plays a significant
role only in cases tried by Arab judges. In the case of an Arab judge and a Jewish
victim the likelihood of an Arab defendant getting a prison sentence is higher than
when the victim is an Arab. This leads to a consideration of the effect of
stereotypes and the majority–minority and in–out group relations
on the performance of the justice system.
Baldus, D. C.
,
Pulaski, C. A.
and
Woodworth, G.
(1983).
Comparative review of death sentences: An empirical study of the Georgia experience
. Journal of Criminal Law and Criminology74,
661–673
.
2.
Bernard, J. L.
(1979).
Interaction between the race of the defendant and that of jurors in
determining verdicts
. Law and Psychology Review5,
103–111
.
3.
Brewer, M. B.
(1979).
Intergroup bias in the minimal intergroup situation: A cognitive motivation analysis
. Psychological Bulletin86,
307–324
.
4.
Cohen, B. Z.
(1985).
Judicial discretion and sentencing disparity in adult felony courts in Israel
. Journal of Criminal Justice13,
99–115
.
5.
Crawford, C.
,
Chiricos, T. D.
and
Kleck, G.
(1998).
Race, racial threat and sentencing of habitual offenders
. Criminology36,
481–511
.
6.
Crenshaw, K.
(1989)
Demarginalizing the intersection of race and sex: A black feminist critique
of anti-discrimination doctrine, feminist theory and antiracist politics
. University of Chicago Legal Forum1989,
139–167
.
7.
Crocker, J.
and
Luhtanen, R.
(1990).
Collective self-esteem and in-group bias
. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology58,
60–67
.
8.
Curry, R. T.
,
Gang, L.
and
Rodriguez, F. S.
(2004).
Does victim gender increase sentence severity? Further explorations of
gender dynamics and sentencing outcomes
. Crime and Delinquency50,
319–343
.
9.
Donziger, S.
(1996). The real war on crime: The report of the national
justice commission.
New York: Harper Perennial
.
10.
Fagan, E. J. S.
and
Hartstone, E.
(1987).
Blind justice: The impact of race on the juvenile justice process
. Crime and Delinquency33,
259–286
.
11.
Fishman, G.
,
Rattner, A.
and
Weimann, G.
(1987).
The effect of ethnicity on crime attribution
. Criminology25,
507–524
.
12.
Foley, L. A.
and
Chamblin, M. H.
(1982).
The effects of race and personality on mock jurors decisions
. Journal of Psychology112,
47–51
.
13.
Frishtik, M. (1983). The relative importance of four alternative models in
judging young adults aged 18–21 in the Israeli courts. Unpublished PhD
dissertation, Bar Ilan University (in Hebrew).
14.
Hans, V.
and
Vidmar, N.
(1986). Judging the jury.
New York: Plenum
.
15.
Hassin, Y.
and
Kremnitzer, M.
(1988). Uniformity in sentencing in traffic
offence. Mishpatim 18(in Hebrew).
16.
Hawkins, D. F.
(1987).
Beyond anomalies: Rethinking the conflict perspective on race and criminal punishment
. Social Forces65,
719–745
.
17.
Hood, R.
and
Cordovil, G.
(1992). Race and sentencing: A study in the crown
court.
New York: Clarendon Press
.
18.
Hunter, J. A.
,
Stringer, M.
and
Watson, R. P.
(1991).
Intergroup violence and intergroup attributions
. British Journal of Social Psychology30,
261–266
.
19.
Hymes, W. R.
,
Leinart, M.
,
Rowe, S.
and
Rojers, W.
(1993).
Acquaintance rape: The effect of race of defendant and race of victim on
white juror decision
. Journal of Social Psychology133,
627–634
.
20.
Kretzmer, D.
(1990). The legal status of Arabs in Israel.
Boulder, CO: Westview Press
.
21.
LaFree, G. D.
(1980).
The effect of sexual stratification by race on official reactions to rape
. American Sociological Review45,
842–854
.
22.
LaFree, G. D.
(1989). Rape and criminal justice: The social construction of
sexual assault.
Belmont, CA: Wadsworth
.
23.
Mann, C. R.
(1993). Unequal justice: A question of colour.
Bloomington, IN: University Press
.
24.
Petersilia, J.
(1983). Racial disparities in the criminal justice
system.
Santa Monica, CA: Rand
.
25.
Quereshi, M. Y.
and
King, M. S.
(1998).
Processing time as a function of ethnicity, gender, and psychopathology
. Journal of Offender Rehabilitation27,
15–22
.
26.
Rattner, A.
and
Fishman, G.
(1998). Justice for all? Jews and Arabs in the Israeli
criminal justice system.
Westport, CT: Praeger
.
27.
Rattner, A. and Yagil, D. (2003). Legal culture: The criminal justice system
in the mirror of the Israeli society 2000–2003.Research Report, Center for
the Study of Crime, Law and Society, University of Haifa.
28.
Sidanus, J.
,
Pratto, F.
and
Mitchell, M.
(1994).
In-group identification, social dominance orientation, and differential
intergroup social allocation
. Journal of Social Psychology134,
151–167
.
29.
Singer, S.
(1996). Recriminalizing delinquency: Violent juvenile crime
and juvenile justice reform.
New York: Cambridge University Press
.
30.
Spohn, C.
(1994). Crime and the social control of blacks:
Offender/victim race and the sentencing of violent offenders. In
G. S. Bridges
and
M. A. Myers
(eds) Inequality, crime, and social control,
249–268.
Boulder, CO: Westview
.
31.
Spohn, C.
and
DeLone, M.
(2000).
When does race matter? An analysis of the conditions under which race
affects sentence severity
. Sociology of Crime, Law, and Deviance2,
3–37
.
32.
Steffensmeier, D.
and
Britt, C. L.
(2001).
Judges' race and judicial decision making. Do black judges
sentence differently?Social Science Quarterly82,
749–764
.
33.
Steffensmeier, D.
,
Ulmer, J.
and
Kramer, J.
(1998).
The interaction of race, gender, and age in criminal sentencing: The
punishment cost of being young, black, and male
. Criminology36,
736–793
.
34.
Tajfel, H.
and
Turner, J. C.
(1979). An integrative theory of intergroup
conflict. In
W. G. Austin
and
S. Worchel
(eds), The social psychology of intergroup relations.
Monterey, CA: Brooks-Cole
.
35.
Tonry, M.
(1995). Malign neglect – race, crime, and
punishment in America.
New York: Oxford University Press
.
36.
Walker, S.
and
Gruhl, J.
(1996). The color of justice.
Belmont, CA: Wadsworth
.
37.
Weimann, G.
,
Fishman, G.
and
Rattner, A.
(1986).
Social distance and misidentification
. International Journal of Comparative Sociology27,
217–225
.
38.
Ynon, Y.
and
Bizman, A.
(1994). Perceptions of aggression between groups among Jews
and Arabs.
Tel Aviv: Tami Steinmetz Center for Peace Research
(in Hebrew).
39.
Zatz, M.
(1985).
Pleas, priors, and prisons: Racial/ethnic differences in sentencing
. Social Science Research14,
169–193
.
