The Use of Objects and Pictures as Language Stimuli: Influence On Response Complexity

Abstract

The influence of object and picture stimuli on the language production of second-grade subjects was investigated. The subjects were presented object or pictorial stimuli and asked to respond to open-ended questions about them. The complexity of the language production was evaluated on the following measures: total words used, total words used in each category, mean length of response, and total sentences used. Statistical anallyses revealed that the object group produced a significantly greater number of total sentences. In addition, type-token ratios and Pearson-r values are reported for each word category studied. Implications for further research and suggestions for the practicing speech-language pathologist are also provided.

References

Barbara, C.A. , The Psychotherapy of Stuttering. Springfield: Charles C. Thomas (1962).

Bloom, L. , Language Development. Cambridge: The MIT Press (1970).

Bruning, J.L. , and B.L. Kintz , Computational Handbook of Statistics. Palo Alto : Scott, Foresman and Company ( 1968).

Carroll, J.B. , Language and Thought. Englewood Cliffs: Prentice Hall (1964).

Darley, F.L. , and K.L. Moll , Reliability of language measures and size of language sample. J. Speech Hearing Res., 3, 166-173 (1960).

Dunn, L. , Peabody Picture Vocabulary Test. Minneapolis: American Guidance Service, Inc. (1965).

Hopper, R. , Communicative development and children's responses to questions. Speech Monogr., 48, 1-9 (1971).

Hopper, R. , and R.C. Naremore , Children's Speech. New York: Harper and Row (1973).

Johnson, W. , F. Darley , and D.C. Spriestersbach , Diagnostic Methods in Speech Pathology. New York: Harper and Row ( 1963).

10.

Labov, W. , Finding out children's language. (1970) Found Lee, L.L. , Developmental Sentence Analysis. Evanston: Northwestern University.

11.

Lee, L.L. , Developmental Sentence Analysis. Evanston: Northwestern University Press (1974).

12.

Lee, L.L. , and S.M. Canter , Developmental sentence scoring. J. Speech Hearing Dis., 36, 315-340 (1971).

13.

Longhurst, T.M. , and J.J. File , A comparison of developmental sentence scores from Headstart children collected in four conditions. J. Lang. Speech Hearing Serv. Schools , 8, 54-64 (1977).

14.

McCarthy, D. , The language development of the preschool child. (1930 ) Found in Johnson, W. , F. Darley , and D. C. Spriestersbach , Diagnostic Methods in Speech Pathology. New York: Harper and Row (1963).

15.

Menyuk, P. , Syntactic structures in the language of children. Child Develpm. , 34, 407-422 (1963).

16.

Nice, M.M. , Length of sentences as a criterion of a child's progress in speech . J. Educ. Psych., 16, 370-379 (1925).

17.

Schneiderman, N. , A study of the relationship between articulatory ability and language ability . J. Speech Hearing Dis., 20, 359-364 (1955).

18.

Sesame Street Magazine. 59 (1977 ), 60 (1977), 61 (1977).

19.

Van Riper, C. , Speech Correction Principles and Methods. (5th ed.) Englewood Cliffs: Prentice-Hall (1972).

20.

Williams, F. , and R.C. Naremore , On the functional analysis of social class differences in modes of speech . Speech Monogr., 36, 77-102 (1969).

21.

Williams, H.M. , An analytical study of language achievement in preschool children . (1937) Found in Darley, F. L., and K. L. Moll, Reliability of language measures and size of language sample. J. Speech Hearing Res., 3, 1966-173 (1960).

22.

Wilson, M.E. , A standardization method for obtaining a spoken language sample. J. Speech Hearing Res., 12, 95-102 (1969).