Methods and Practices of Investigators for Determining Participants' Decisional Capacity and Comprehension of Protocols

Abstract

Ethicists recommend that investigators assess subjects' comprehension prior to accepting their consent as valid. Because children represent an at-risk population, ensuring adequate comprehension in pediatric research is vital. We surveyed all corresponding authors of research articles published over a six-month period in five leading adult and pediatric journals. Our goal was to assess how often subject's comprehension or decisional capacity was assessed in the consent process, whether there was any difference between adult and pediatric research projects, and the rate at which investigators use formal or validated tools to assess capacity. Responses from 102 authors were analyzed (response rate 56%). Approximately two-thirds of respondents stated that they assessed comprehension or decisional capacity prior to accepting consent, and we found no difference between adult and pediatric researchers. Nine investigators used a formal questionnaire, and three used a validated tool. These findings suggest that fewer than expected investigators assess comprehension and decisional capacity, and that the use of standardized and validated tools is the exception rather than the rule.

Keywords

Parental consent informed consent mental competency ethics research

References

American Academy of Pediatrics. (1995). Informed consent, parental permission, and assent in pediatric practice. Committee on Bioethics, American Academy of Pediatrics. Pediatrics, 95(2), 314–317.

American Association for Public Opinion Research. (2000). Standard definitions: Final dispositions of case codes and outcome rates for surveys. Lenexa, Kansas: American Association for Public Opinion Research. Lenexa, Kansas. Available at http://www.aapor.org/pdfs/newstandarddefinitions.pdf.

Appelbaum

P.S.

, & Grisso

(2001). Macarthur competence assessment tool for clinical research (MacCAT-CR). Sarasota, FL: Professional Resource Press.

Appelbaum

P.S.

, & Roth

L.H.

(1982). Competency to consent to research: A psychiatric overview. Archives of General Psychiatry, 39(8), 951–958.

Criscione

L.G.

Sugarman

Sanders

Pisetsky

D.S.

, & St Clair

E.W.

(2003). Informed consent in a clinical trial of a novel treatment for rheumatoid arthritis. Arthritis and Rheumatism, 49(3), 361–367.

Faden

, & Beauchamp

(1986). A history and theory of informed consent. New York: Oxford University Press.

Federal regulations. (2005). Protection of human subjects. Title 45 CFR Part 46. Available at http://www.hhs.gov/ohrp/humansubjects/guidance/45cfr46.htm.

Food and Drug Administration. (1998). Regulations requiring manufacturers to assess the safety and effectiveness of new drugs and biological products in pediatric patients—Food and Drug Administration final rule. Federal Registister, 63(231), 66631–66672.

Food and Drug Administration Modernization Act (FDAMA). (1997). Available at http://www.fda.gov/cder/fdama/default.htm.

10.

Joffe

Cook

E.F.

Cleary

P.D.

Clark

J.W.

, & Weeks

J.C.

(2001a). Quality of informed consent in cancer clinical trials: A cross-sectional survey. Lancet, 358(9295), 1772–1777.

11.

Joffe

Cook

E.F.

Cleary

P.D.

Clark

J.W.

, & Weeks

J.C.

(2001b). Quality of informed consent: A new measure of understanding among research subjects. Journal of the National Cancer Institute, 93(2), 139–147.

12.

Keating

N.L.

Zaslavsky

A.M.

, & Ayanian

J.Z.

(1998). Physicians' experiences and beliefs regarding informal consultation. Journal of the American Medical Association, 280(10), 900–904.

13.

Kim

M.K.

Galustyan

Sato

T.T.

Bergholte

, & Hennes

H.M.

(2003). Analgesia for children with acute abdominal pain: A survey of pediatric emergency physicians and pediatric surgeons. Pediatrics, 112(5), 1122–1126.

14.

Kon

A.A.

(2006). Assent in pediatric research. Pediatrics, 117(5), 1806–1810.

15.

Lacasse

Plante

Martel

, & Raby

(2003). Transthoracic needle biopsy in the diagnosis of solitary pulmonary nodules: A survey of Canadian physicians. The Journal of Thoracic and Cardiovascular Surgery, 126(3), 761–768.

16.

Lynn

Beerten

Laiho

, & Martin

(2001). Recommended standard final outcome categories and standard definitions of response rate for social surveys. Colchester, Essex: The institute for social and economic research. Colchester, Essex. Available at http://www.iser.essex.ac.uk/pubs/workpaps/pdf/2001-23.pdf.

17.

Mangus

R.S.

Dipiero

, & Hawkins

C.E.

(1999). Medical students' attitudes toward physician-assisted suicide. Journal of the American Medical Association, 282(21), 2080–2081.

18.

Mason

S.A.

, & Allmark

P.J.

(2000). Obtaining informed consent to neonatal randomized controlled trials: Interviews with parents and clinicians in the Euricon study. Lancet, 356(9247), 2045–2051.

19.

Meier

D.E.

Emmons

C.A.

Wallenstein

Quill

Morrison

R.S.

, & Cassel

C.K.

(1998). A national survey of physician-assisted suicide and euthanasia in the United States. New England Journal of Medicine, 338(17), 1193–1201.

20.

Miller

V.A.

Drotar

, & Kodish

(2004). Children's competence for assent and consent: A review of empirical findings. Ethics and Behavior, 14(3), 255–295.

21.

National Commission for the Protection of Human Subjects of Biomedical and Behavioral Research. (1978) Research involving children. Federal Registister, 43(9), 2084–2114.

22.

National Institute of Health. (1998). NIH Policy and Guidelines on the Inclusion of Children as Participants in Research Involving Human Subjects. Available at http://grants1.nih.gov/grants/guide/notice-files/not98-024.html.

23.

Nuremberg Military Tribunals. (1947). The Nuremberg code. Available at http://www.nihtraining.com/ohsrsite/guidelines/nuremberg.html.

24.

Peshkin

B.N.

Isaacs

Finch

Kent

, & Schwartz

M.D.

(2003). Tamoxifen as chemoprevention in BRCA1 and BRCA2 mutation carriers with breast cancer: A pilot survey of physicians. Journal of Clinical Oncology, 21(23), 4322–4328.

25.

Rogers

C.G.

Tyson

J.E.

Kennedy

K.A.

Broyles

R.S.

, & Hickman

J.F.

(1998). Conventional consent with opting in versus simplified consent with opting out: An exploratory trial for studies that do not increase patient risk. Journal of Pediatrics, 132(4), 606–611.

26.

Saks

E.R.

Dunn

L.B.

Marshall

B.J.

Nayak

G.V.

Golshan

, & Jeste

D.V.

(2002). The California Scale of Appreciation: A new instrument to measure the appreciation component of capacity to consent to research. American Journal of Geriatriatric Psychiatry, 10(2), 166–174.

27.

Sreenivasan

(2003). Does informed consent to research require comprehension? Lancet, 362(9400), 2016–2018.

28.

World Medical Association. (1964). Helsinki declaration. Available at http://www.fda.gov/oc/health/helsinki89.html.

29.

Yuval

Halon

D.A.

Merdler

Khader

Karkabi

Uziel

(2000). Patient comprehension and reaction to participating in a double-blind randomized clinical trial (ISIS-4) in acute myocardial infarction. Archives of Internal Medicine, 160(8), 1142–1146.

30.

Zachry

W.M.

3rd Dalen

J.E.

, & Jackson

T.R.

(2003). Clinicians' responses to direct-to-consumer advertising of prescription medications. Archives of Internal Medicine, 163(15), 1808–1812.