Perceptual Evaluation of Speech and Velopharyngeal Function in Children with and without Cleft Palate and the Relationship to Nasal Airflow Patterns

Abstract

Objectives

The aim was to study the relationship between perceptual evaluation of speech variables related to velopharyngeal function and the pattern of nasal airflow during the velopharyngeal closing phase in speech in children with and without cleft palate.

Participants

Fourteen children with cleft lip and palate or cleft palate only and 15 controls aged 7 and 10 years. All were native Swedish speakers.

Method

Three experienced listeners performed a blinded perceptual speech evaluation. Nasal airflow was transduced with a pneumotachograph attached to a nasal mask. The duration from peak to 5% nasal airflow, maximum flow declination rate, and nasal airflow at selected points in time during the transition from nasal to stop consonants in bilabial and velar articulatory positions in sentences were estimated. The analysis was focused on the perceptual ratings of “velopharyngeal function” and “hypernasality.”

Results

A strong association was found between ratings of “velopharyngeal function” and “hypernasality” and the pattern of nasal airflow during the bilabial nasal-to-stop combination /mp/. Both the sensitivity and specificity were 1.00 for the bilabial temporal airflow measure in relation to ratings of “velopharyngeal function.” The nasal airflow rate during /p/ in /mp/ had a sensitivity of 1.00 and specificity of 0.92 to 0.96 in relation to ratings of “hypernasality.”

Conclusion

Assessment of the nasal airflow dynamics during the velopharyngeal closing phase in speech presents quantitative, objective data that appear to distinguish between perceptually normal and deviant velopharyngeal function with high sensitivity and specificity.

Keywords

cleft palate speech nasal airflow perceptual speech evaluation speech aerodynamics speech production measurements velopharyngeal insufficiency

References

Ackermann

, Hertrich

, Scharf

. Kinematic analysis of lower lip movement in ataxic dysarthria. J Speech Hear Res. 1995; 38: 1252–1259.

Altman

D.G.

. Practical Statistics for Medical Research. London: Chapman and Hall; 1991.

Connor

N.P.

, Abbs

J.H.

. Task-dependent variation in parkinsonian motor impairments. Brain. [Abstract] 1991; 114: 321–332.

Dalston

R.M.

, Warren

D.W.

. Comparison of Tonar II, pressure-flow, and listeners' judgments of hypernasality in the assessment of velopharyngeal function. Cleft Palate J. 1986; 23: 108–115.

Dalston

R.M.

, Warren

D.W.

, Dalston

E.T.

. The temporal characteristics of aerodynamic phenomena associated with patients manifesting varying degrees of velopharyngeal adequacy. Folia Phoniatr 1991; 43: 226–233.

Dalston

R.M.

, Warren

D.W.

, Smith

L.R.

. The aerodynamic characteristics of speech produced by normal speakers and cleft palate speakers with adequate velopharyngeal function. Cleft Palate J. 1990; 27: 393–399.

D'Antonio

L.L.

, Scherer

N.J.

. The evaluation of speech associated with clefting. In: Sphrintzen

R.J.

, Bardach

, eds. Cleft Palate Speech Management. A Multidisciplinary Approach. St. Louis: Mosby Year Book, Inc.; 1995: 176–220.

Dotevall

, Ejnell

, Bake

. Nasal airflow patterns during the velopharyngeal closing phase in speech in children with and without cleft palate. Cleft Palate Craniofac J. 2001; 38: 358–373.

Folkins

J.W.

. Issues in motor speech control and their relation to the speech of individuals with cleft palate. Cleft Palate J. 1985; 22: 106–122.

10.

Friede

, Möller

, Lilja

, Lauritzen

, Johanson

. Facial morphology and occlusion at the stage of early mixed dentition in cleft lip and palate patients treated with delayed closure of the hard palate. Scand J Plast Reconstr Surg. 1987; 21: 65–71.

11.

Gilbert

H.R.

, Ferrand

C.T.

. A respirometric technique to evaluate velopharyngeal function in speakers with cleft palate, with and without prostheses. J Speech Hear Res. 1987; 30: 268–275.

12.

Hess

D.A.

. A new experimental approach to assessment of velopharyngeal adequacy: nasal manometric bleed testing. J Speech Hear Dis. 1976; 41: 427–443.

13.

Horii

. An accelerometric approach to nasality measurement: a preliminary report. Cleft Palate J. 1980; 17: 254–261.

14.

Jaeger

, Hertich

, Stattrop

, Schonle

P.W.

, Ackermann

. Speech disorders following severe traumatic brain injury: kinematic analysis of syllable repetitions using electromagnetic articulography. Folia Phoniatr Logop. 2000; 52: 187–196.

15.

Karnell

M.P.

, Folkins

J.W.

, Morris

H.L.

. Relationship between the perception of nasalization and speech movements in speakers with cleft palate. J Speech Hear Res. 1985; 28: 63–72.

16.

Karnell

M.P.

, Seaver

E.J.

. Measurement problems in estimating velopharyngeal function. In: Bardach

, Morris

H.L.

, eds. Multidisciplinary Management of Cleft Lip and Palate. Philadelphia: WB Saunders; 1990: 776–786.

17.

Laine

, Warren

D.W.

, Dalston

R.M.

, Morr

K.E.

. Screening of velopharyngeal closure based on nasal airflow rate measurements. Cleft Palate J. 1988; 25: 220–225.

18.

Lilja

, Friede

, Johansson

. Changing philosophy of surgery of the cleft lip and palate in Göteborg, Sweden. In: Berkowitz

, ed. Cleft Lip and Palate—Perspectives in Management With an Introduction to Other Craniofacial Anomalies. Vol. II. San Diego: Singular Press; 1995: 155–176.

19.

Lohmander-Agerskov

. Speech in Children With Cleft Lip and Palate Treated With Delayed Closure of the Hard Palate. Göteborg, Sweden: Göteborg University; 1996a. Dissertation.

20.

Lohmander-Agerskov

, Dotevall

, Lith

, Söderpalm

. Speech and velopharyngeal function in children with an open residual cleft in the hard palate, and the influence of temporary covering. Cleft Palate Craniofac J. 1996b; 33: 324–332.

21.

Lubker

J.F.

, Schweiger

J.W.

. Nasal airflow as an index of success of prosthetic management of cleft palate. J Dent Res. 1969; 48: 368–375.

22.

Lubker

J.F.

, Schweiger

J.W.

, Morris

H.L.

. Nasal airflow characteristics during speech in prostethically managed cleft palate speakers. J Speech Hear Res. 1970; 13: 326–338.

23.

McHenry

M.A.

. Aerodynamic, acoustic, and perceptual measures of nasality following traumatic brain injury. Brain Injury. 1999; 13: 281–290.

24.

McWilliams

B.J.

, Glaser

E.R.

, Philips

B.J.

, Lawrence

, Lavorato

A.S.

, Beery

Q.C.

, Skolnick

M.L.

. A comparative study of four methods of evaluation velopharyngeal adequacy. Plast Reconstr Surg. 1981; 68: 1–10.

25.

McWilliams

B.J.

, Morris

L.M.

, Shelton

R.L.

. Cleft Palate Speech. Philadelphia: BC Decker Inc.; 1990.

26.

Moll

. ‘Objective” measures of nasality. [Letter to the editor.] Cleft Palate J. 1964; 1: 371–374.

27.

Munhall

K.G.

, Ostry

D.J.

, Parush

. Characteristics of velocity profiles of speech movements. J Exp Psychol Hum Percept Perform. [Abstract.] 1985; 11: 457–474.

28.

Poppelreuter

, Engelke

, Bruns

. Quantitative analysis of the velopharyngeal sphincter function during speech. Cleft Palate Craniofac J. 2000; 37: 157–165.

29.

Quigley

L.F.

, Cobb

C.M.

, Vargervik

. Nasality ratings and airflow measures during speech. Plast Reconstr Surg. 1969; 43: 292–299.

30.

Samlan

R.A.

, Barlow

S.M.

. The effect of transition rate and vowel height on velopharyngeal airway resistance. In: Barlow

S.M.

, ed. Handbook of Clinical Speech Physiology. San Diego: Singular Publishing Group; 1999: 247–264.

31.

Sapienza

C.M.

, Brown

W.S.

, Williams

W.N.

, Wharton

P.W.

, Turner

G.E.

. Respiratory and laryngeal function associated with experimental coupling of the oral and nasal cavities. Cleft Palate Craniofac J. 1996; 33: 118–126.

32.

Selley

W.G.

, Zananiri

M-C

, Ellis

R.E.

, Flack

F.C.

. The effect of tongue position on division of airflow in the presence of velopharyngeal defects. Br J Plast Surg. 1987; 40: 377–383.

33.

Sphrintzen

. Genetics, Syndromes, and Communication Disorders. San Diego: Singular Publishing Group; 1997.

34.

Subtelny

J.D.

, McCormack

R.M.

, Curtin

J.W.

, Subtelny

J.D.

, Musgrave

K.S.

. Speech, intraoral air pressure, nasal airflow—before and after pharyngeal flap surgery. Cleft Palate J. 1970; 7: 68–90.

35.

Warren

D.W.

. Perci: a method for rating palatal efficiency. Cleft Palate J. 1979; 16: 279–285.

36.

Warren

D.W.

. Regulation of speech aerodynamics. In: Lass

N.J.

, ed. Principles of Experimental Phonetics. St. Louis: Mosby Year Book, Inc.; 1996: 46–91.

37.

Warren

D.W.

, Dalston

R.M.

, Mayo

. Hypernasality and velopharyngeal impairment. Cleft Palate Craniofac J. 1994; 31: 257–262.

38.

Warren

D.W.

, Dalston

R.M.

, Mayo

. Hypernasality in the presence of ‘adequate’ velopharyngeal closure. Cleft Palate Craniofac J. 1993; 30: 150–154.

39.

Warren

D.W.

, Dalston

R.M.

, Morr

K.E.

, Hairfield

W.M.

, Smith

L.R.

. The speech regulating system: temporal and aerodynamic responses to velopharyngeal inadequacy. J Speech Hear Res. 1989; 32: 566–575.

40.

Warren

D.W.

, Dalston

R.M.

, Trier

W.C.

, Holder

M.B.

. A pressure-flow technique for quantifying temporal patterns of palatopharyngeal closure. Cleft Palate J. 1985; 22: 11–19.

41.

Witt

P.D.

, Mackatyn

, Marsh

J.L.

, Grames

L.M.

, Dowton

S.B.

. Need for velopharyngeal management following palatoplasty: an outcome analysis of syndromic and nonsyndromic patients with Robin sequence. Plast Reconstr Surg. 1997; 99: 1522–1529.

42.

Witzel

M.A.

. Communicative impairment associated with clefting. In: Sphrintzen

R.J.

, Bardach

, eds. Cleft Palate Speech Management. A Multidisciplinary Approach. St. Louis: Mosby Year Book, Inc. 1995: 137–166.