Tobacco use among youth remains one of our nation's most significant public health problems, and yet available evidence from prevention and cessation person-centered approaches has been mixed. Given these disappointing outcomes, some have recommended more public health approaches, and these include tobacco sales-to-minors and possession-use-purchase laws. While community members and police officials have endorsed these types of public health initiatives, many within the public health community have been either guarded or even oppositional to such approaches. The primary reasons for this controversy are reviewed in this article. Outcome studies indicate that sales-to-minors laws can be an effective step toward the reduction of youth access to commercial sources of tobacco. However, even with these laws in place, many youth indicate that they continue to have easy access to tobacco, often by means of social sources. Advocates of these approaches have argued that more comprehensive public health interventions are needed, such as programs that combine youth access and possession-use-purchase laws. This article reviews the ongoing debate behind these types of public health efforts, and examines the evidence of such programs to reduce youth tobacco use.
References
1.
AlesciN.ForsterJ., & BlaineT. (2003). Smoking visibility, perceived acceptability and frequency in various locations amoung youth and adults. Preventative Medicine, 36(3), 272–281.
2.
AltmanD. G.WheelisA. Y.McFarlaneM.LeeH., & FortmannS. P. (1999). The relationship between tobacco access and use among adolescents: A four community study. Social Science and Medicine, 48, 759–775.
3.
AragonaJ.CassadyJ., & DrabmanR. (1975). Treating overweight children through parental training and contingency contracting. Journal of Applied Behavior Analysis, 8(3), 269–278.
4.
BackingerC. L.McDonaldP.Ossip-KleinD. J.ColbyS. M.MauleC. O.FaganP.HustenC., & ColwellB. (2003). Improving the future of youth smoking cessation. American Journal of Health Behavior, 27, S170–S184.
5.
Beyth-MaromR.AustinL.FischhoffB.PalmgrenC., & Jacobs-QuandrelM. (1993). Perceived consequences of risky behavior: Adults and adolescents. Developmental Psychology, 29(3), 549–563.
6.
BrehmJ. (1966). A theory of psychological reactance. New York: Academic Press.
7.
BreslauN., & PetersonE. L. (1996). Smoking cessation in young adults: Age at initiation of cigarette smoking and other suspected influences. American Journal of Public Health, 86, 214–220.
8.
Centers for Disease Control. (1989). Reducing the consequences of smoking: 25 years of progress. A report of the surgeon general (DHHS publication no. CDC89–8411).
9.
RockvilleMD.: U.S. Department of Health and Human Services, Public Health Service, CDC.
Centers for Disease Control. (2004). Cigarette use among high school students—United States, 1991–2003. MMWR, 53, 499–502.
12.
ChaloupkaF. J., & PaculaR. L. (1998, February). Limiting youth access to tobacco: The early impact of the Synar amendment on youth smoking. Paper presented at the 3rd Biennial Pacific Rim Allied Economic Organizations Conference, Bangkok, Thailand.
13.
CrawfordM. A.BalchG. I., & MermelsteinR. (2002). Responses to tobacco control policies among youth. Tobacco Control, 11, 14–19.
EverettS. A.WarrenC. W.SharpD.KannL.HustenC. G., & CrossetL. S. (1999). Initiation of cigarette smoking and subsequent behavior among U.S. high school students. Preventive Medicine, 29, 327–333.
16.
FichtenbergC. M., & GlantzS. A. (2002). Youth access interventions do not affect youth smoking. Pediatrics, 109, 1087–1091.
17.
ForsterJ.ChenV.BlaineT.PerryC., & ToomeyT. (2003). Social exchange of cigarettes by youth. Tobacco Control, 12, 148–154.
18.
ForsterJ. L.MurrayD. M.WolfsonM.BlaineT. M.WagenaarA. C., & HennrikusD. J. (1998). The effects of community policies to reduce youth access to tobacco. American Journal of Public Health, 88, 1193–1198.
19.
ForsterJ. L., & WolfsonM. (1998). Youth access to tobacco: Policies and politics. Annual Review of Public Health, 19, 203–235.
20.
GilpinE. A.ChoiW. S.BerryC., & PierceJ. P. (1999). How many adolescents start smoking each day in the United States?Journal of Adolescent Health, 25, 248–255.
21.
GiovinoG.WakefieldM.ChaloupkaF.JohnstonL.O'MalleyP.SlaterS., & TworekC. (2001, June). Study of youth smoking and state laws prohibiting the purchase, possession, and/or use of cigarettes by minors—United States, 1991–1998. Poster presented at the annual meeting of the Society for Prevention Research, Washington, DC.
22.
GottliebN. H.LoukasA.CorraoM.McAlisterA.SnellC., & HuangP. P. (2004). Minors' tobacco possession law violations and intentions to smoke: Implications for tobacco control. Tobacco Control, 13, 237–243.
23.
HarrisonP. A.FulkersonJ. A., & ParkE. (2000). The relative importance of social versus commercial sources in youth access to tobacco, alcohol, and other drugs. Preventative Medicine, 31, 39–48
24.
JasonL. A.BerkM.Schnopp-WyattD. L., & TalbotB. (1999). Effects of enforcement of youth access laws on smoking prevalence. American Journal of Community Psychology, 27, 143–160.
25.
JasonL. A.JiP. Y.AnesM., & BirkheadS. H. (1991). Active enforcement of cigarette control laws in the prevention of cigarette sales to minors. Journal of American Medical Association, 266(22), 3159–3161.
26.
JasonL. A.KatzR.VavraJ.Schnopp-WyattD. L., & TalbotB. (1999). Long term follow-up of youth access laws on smoking prevalence. Journal of Human Behavior in the Social Environment, 2, 1–13.
27.
JasonL. A.PokornyS. B.SanemJ. R., & AdamsM. L. (in press). Monitoring and decreasing public smoking among youth. Behavior Modification.
28.
JasonL. A.PokornyS. B., & SchoenyM. (2003). Evaluating the effects of enforcements and fines on youth smoking. Critical Public Health, 13, 33–45.
29.
JasonL. A.PokornyS. B.TurnerP. L.FreelandM.CorbinS., & DriscollM. (in press). Decreasing public smoking among youth: A Preliminary Study. Education & Treatment of Children.
30.
JonesS. E.SharpD. J.HustenC. G., & CrossettL. S. (2002). Cigarette acquisition and proof of age among U.S. high school students who smoke. Tobacco Control, 11, 20–27.
31.
KahnemanD., & TverskyA. (1974). Judgment under uncertainty: Heuristics and biases. Science, 185, 1124–1131.
32.
LangerL., & WarheitG. (2000). Teen tobacco court: A determination of the short term outcomes of judicial processes with teens engaging in tobacco possession. Adolescent & Family Health, 1(1), 5–10.
33.
LangerL.WarheitG.AlanS. (1999, December 3). State of Florida: Final report. Teen tobacco court evaluation project 1999. Center for Youth Development, Florida International University.
34.
LazovichD.FordJ.ForsterJ., & RileyB. (2001). A pilot study to evaluate a tobacco diversion program. American Journal of Public Health, 91(11), 1790–2001.
35.
LeventhalH., & ClearyP. D. (1980). The smoking problem: A review of the research and theory in behavioral risk modification. Psychological Bulletin, 88, 370–405.
36.
LeventhalH.FlemingR., & GlynnK. (1988). A cognitive-developmental approach to smoking intervention. In MaesS.SpielbergerC. D.DefaresP. B., & SarasonI. G. (Eds.), Topics in health psychology (pp. 79–105). New York: Oxford University Press.
37.
LingP. M.LandmanA., & GlantzS. A. (2002). Is it time to abandon youth access tobacco programmes. Tobacco Control, 11, 3–6.
38.
LivingoodW. W.WoodhouseC. D.Jopling SayreJ., & WludkaP. (2001). Impact study of tobacco possession law enforcement in Florida. Health Education and Behavior, 28(6), 733–748.
39.
MaG. X.ShiveS., & TracyM. (2001). The effects of licensing and inspection enforcements to reduce tobacco sales to minors in Greater Philadelphia, 1994–1998. Addictive Behaviors, 26, 677–687.
40.
MarholinD., & GrayD. (1976). Effects of group response-cost procedures on cash shortages in a small business. Journal of Applied Behavior Analysis, 9(1), 25–30.
41.
McDonaldP.ColwellB.BackingerC. L.HustenC., & MauleC. O. (2003). Better practices for youth tobacco cessation: Evidence of review panel. American Journal of Health Behavior, 27, S144–S158.
42.
McSweenyJ. (1978). Effects of response-cost on the behavior of a million persons: Charging for directory assistance in Cincinnati. Journal of Applied Behavior Analysis, 11(1), 47–51.
43.
MiltonburgerR. G. (2001). Behavior modification: Principles and procedures (2nd ed.). Belmont, CA: Wadsworth.
44.
PerkinsH. W., & WechslerH. (1996). Variation in perceived college drinking norms and its impact on alcohol abuse: Anationwide study. Journal of Drug Issues, 26, 961–975.
45.
PetersonA. V.KealeyK. A.MannS. L.MarekP. M., & SarasonI. G. (2000). Hutchinson smoking prevention project: Long-term randomized trial in school-based tobacco use prevention—Results on smoking. Journal of the National Cancer Institute, 92, 1979–1991.
46.
PokornyS. B.JasonL. A., & SchoenyM. E. (2003). The relation of retail tobacco availability to initiation and continued cigarette smoking. Journal of Clinical Child and Adolescent Psychology, 32, 193–204.
47.
PokornyS. B.JasonL. A., & SchoenyM. E. (2005). Youth supplying tobacco to other minors: Evaluating individual and town level correlates. Manuscript submitted for publication.
48.
QuandrelM.FischhoffB., & DavisW. (1993). Adolescent (in)vulnerability. American Psychologist, 48, 102–116.
49.
RigottiN. A.DiFranzaJ. R.ChangY.TisdaleT.KempB., & SingerD. E. (1997). The effect of enforcing tobacco sales laws on youths' access to tobacco and smoking behavior. New England Journal of Medicine, 337, 1044–1051.
50.
RossH., & ChaloupkaF. J. (2004). The effect of public policies and prices on youth smoking. Southern Economic Journal, 70, 796–815.
51.
ShiveS.MaG. X., & ShiveE. (2001). A study of young adults who provide tobacco products to minors. The Journal of School Health, 71, 218–222.
52.
ShoreE. R., & MaguinE. (1988). Deterrence of drinking-driving: The effect of changes in the Kansas driving under the influence law. Evaluation and Program Planning, 11, 245–254.
53.
SussmanS. (2002). Effects of sixty-six adolescent tobacco use cessation trials and seventeen Prospective studies of self-initiated quitting. Tobacco Induced Diseases, 1(1), 35–81.
54.
SussmanS.LichtmanK.RittA., & PallonenU. (1999). Effects of thirty-four adolescent tobacco use cessation and prevention trials on regular users of tobacco products. Substance Use & Misuse, 34, 1469–1503.
55.
TalbotB. (1992). Adolescent smokers' rights laws. Tobacco Control, 1, 294–295.
56.
ThomasC. W., & BishopD. M. (1984). The effect of formal and informal sanctions on delinquency: A longitudinal comparison of labeling and deterrence theories. Journal of Criminal Law & Criminology, 75, 1222–1245.
57.
TownsendS. M.PokornyS. B.JasonL. A.CurieC. J., & SchoenyM. E. (2002). An assessment of the relationship between the quality of school-based tobacco prevention programs and youth tobacco use. Journal of Prevention & Intervention in the Community, 24, 47–61.
58.
UngerJ. B.RohrbachL. A.HowardK. A.CruzT. B.JohnsonC. A., & ChenX. (1999). Attitudes toward anti-tobacco policy among California youth: Associations with smoking status, psychosocial variables and advocacy actions. Health Education Research, 14, 751–763.
59.
U.S. Department of Health and Human Sciences. (1994). Preventing tobacco use among young people: A report of the Surgeon General. Atlanta: U.S. Department of Health and Human Services, Public Health Service, CDC, National Center for Chronic Disease Prevention and Health Promotion, Office on Smoking and Health.
60.
U.S. Department of Health and Human Services. (2000). Healthy people 2010 (2nd ed.). With understanding and improving health and objectives for improving health (2 vols.). Washington, DC: U.S. Government Printing Office.
61.
WakefieldM., & ChaloupkaF. (2000). Effectiveness of comprehensive tobacco control programs in reducing teenage smoking in the USA. Tobacco Control, 9, 177
62.
WakefieldM., & GiovinoG. (2003) Teen penalties for tobacco possession, use and purchase: Evidence and issues. Tobacco Control, 12(Suppl I), i6–i13.
63.
WeithornL., & CampbellS. (1982). The competency of children to make in formed treatment decisions. Child Development, 53(6), 1589–1598.
64.
WieheS. E.GarrisonM. M.ChristakisD. A.EbelB. E., & RivaraF. P. (2005). A systematic review of school-based smoking prevention trials with long-term follow-up. Journal of Adolescent Health, 36, 162–169.
