The Sachs Report: Investing in Health for Economic Development —Or Increasing the Size of the Crumbs from the Rich Man's Table? Part I

Abstract

The Commission on Macroeconomics and Health report (Sachs report) of 2001 has been heralded as inspiring and groundbreaking and is being adopted as the blueprint for global health policymaking. This article argues that the report is deeply conservative and unoriginal. It encourages medico-technical solutions to public health problems; it ignores macroeconomic determinants and other root causes of both poor health and poverty; it reverses public health logic and history; it is based on a set of flawed assumptions; it reflects one particular economic perspective to the exclusion of all others; and it recommends greater amounts of charity while preserving the status quo of a deeply unjust and irrational international economic order. A set of assumptions deriving from a neoliberal approach to health underlies the report. The author proposes an alternative set of assumptions deriving from a social justice and human rights–based approach to health.

References

World Health Organization. Macroeconomics and Health: Investing in Health for Economic Development. WHO, Geneva, December 2001.

Sachs

Letter to readers from the Chair of the Commission on Macroeconomics and Health. Geneva, December 20, 2001.

Feachem

R. G. A.

Commission on Macroeconoinics and Health (editorial). Bull. World Health Organ. 80(2): 87, 2002.

World Health Organization. Health, a Key to Prosperity: Success Stories in Developing Countries. WHO/CDS/2000.4. Geneva, 2000.

Banerji

Report of the WHO Commission on Macroeconomics and Health: A critique. Int. J. Health Serv. 32(4): 733–754, 2002.

Morrow

R. H.

Macroeconomics and health. BMJ 325: 53–54, 2002.

Rosen

A History of Public Health, exp. ed. Johns Hopkins University Press, Baltimore, 1993.

McKeown

The Role of Medicine. Blackwell, Oxford, 1979.

McChesney

Global media, neoliberalism and imperialism. Int. Socialist Rev. August/September 2001.

10.

Madaley

A People's World: Alternatives to Economic Globalization. Zed Books, London, 2003.

11.

Centre Tricontinentale. A la Recherche d'Alternatives—un Autre Monde est Possible. Alternatives Sud, Vol. VIII(2). L'Harmattan, Paris, 2001.

12.

Todaro

M. P.

Economic Development. Addison-Wesley, Reading, Mass., 1997.

13.

Berkman

Kawachi

(eds.). Social Epidemiology. Oxford University Press, Oxford, 2000.

14.

Pannenborg

An economic and financial look at health in low and middle-income countries. In Health Matters: Public Health in North-South Perspective, ed. Van der Velden

, pp. 43–62. Health Policy Series, Part 9. Royal Tropical Institute, Amsterdam, 1995.

15.

Wackernagel

Monfreda

Deumling

Ecological Footprint of Nations: How Much Nature Do They Use? How Much Nature Do They Have? Sustainability Issue Brief. Redefining Progress, Oakland, Calif., November 2002.

16.

World Health Organization. Our Planet, Our Earth: Report of the WHO Commission on Health and Environment. Geneva, 1992.

17.

Eatwell

International Financial Liberation: The Impact on World Development. United Nations Development Program, New York, 1996.

18.

Bello

The crisis of the globalist project and the new economics of George Bush. New Labor Forum, Fall 2003.

19.

United Nations Development Program. Human Development Report, 2003. New York, 2003.

20.

Weisbrot

The Scorecard on Globalization 1980–2000: Twenty Years of Diminished Progress. Center for Economic and Policy Research, Washington, D.C., 2001.

21.

Cornia

G. A.

Courat

Inequality, Growth and Poverty in the Era of Liberalization and Globalization. United Nations University, World Institute for Development Economic Research, Helsinki, 2001.

22.

United Nations Development Program. Human Development Report 1998. New York, 1998.

23.

Houtart

Polet

L'Autre Davos: Mondialisation des Résistances et des Luttes. L'Harmattan, Paris, 1999.

24.

Weller

C. E.

Scott

R. E.

Hersh

A. S.

The Unremarkable Record of Liberalized Trade. Economic Policy Institute, Washington, D.C., 2001.

25.

United Nations Research Institute for Social Development. Visible Hands: Taking Responsibility for Social Development. Geneva, 2000.

26.

Levy

B. S.

Sider

V. W.

(eds.). War and Public Health. Oxford University Press, New York, 1997.

27.

Agee

Producing the proper crisis. Speech by former CIA agent. Z Magazine, October 1990.

28.

Feffer

Foreign Policy in Focus: Globalization and Militarization. Global Policy, February 2002. www.globalpolicy.org/soecon/ffd/2002/02military.htm (November 2003).

29.

Beelman

U.S. Contractors Reap the Windfalls of Post-War Reconstruction. Center for Public Integrity, October 30, Washington, D.C., 2003.

30.

Schulman

Corporate War Profiteering and Tax Avoidance. Fact Sheet. Institute for Policy Studies, Washington, D.C., 2003.

31.

Petrella

Udry

C. A.

Aguitton

Expropriés du monde: Construisons ensemble une autre mondialisation—premiere partie: Les mécanismes de l'exclusion. In L'Autre Davos: Mondialisation des résistances et des luttes, ed. Houtart

Polet

, L'Harmattan, Paris, 1999.

32.

Hildyard

Maastricht: The protectionism of free trade. The Cornerhouse, 1993.

33.

Phelps

E. S.

Phillips curves, expectations of inflation and optimal unemployment over time. Economica 34, 1967.

34.

Cassen

Les bacchanales des patrons voyous. Le Monde Diplomatique, August 2003.

35.

Singh

Taming Global Financial Flows: A Citizen's Guide. Zed Books, London, 2000.

36.

Renner

Corporate mergers skyrocket. In Vital Signs. Worldwatch Institute, Washington, D.C., 2000.

37.

Centre Tricontinental. Le Pouvoir des Transnationales: Point de Vue du Sud. Alternatives Sud, Vol. IX(1). L'Harmattan, Paris, 2002.

38.

Chan

Liberalism, Democracy and Development. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, 2002.

39.

Robinson

N. A.

Agenda 21 Earth's Action Plan. Oceana Publications, New York, 1993.

40.

Platt

A. E.

Infecting Ourselves: How Environmental and Social Disruptions Trigger Disease. Worldwatch Paper 129. Worldwatch Institute, Washington, D.C., 1996.

41.

Brown

Kane

Full House: Reassessing the Earth's Carrying Capacity. Worldwatch Books, Williamsport, Pa., 1994.

42.

World Health Organization. Healthy Environments for Children: Initiating an Alliance for Action. WHO/SDE/PHE/02.06. Geneva, 2002.

43.

The Ecologist and Friends of the Earth. Keeping score: Which countries are the most sustainable? The Ecologist, March 22, 2001.

44.

Ziegler

The Right to Food: Report by the Special Rapporteur on the Right to Food. Economic and Social Council of the United Nations, Geneva, 2001.

45.

Madaley

Hungry for Trade: How the Poor Pay for Free Trade. Global Issues Series. Zed Books, London, 2000.

46.

Chase-Dunn

Grimes

World systems analysis. Annu. Rev. Sociol. 21: 387–417, 1995.

47.

Navarro

Assessment of the World Health Report 2000. Lancet 356, November 4, 2000.

48.

Navarro

Summary and conclusions of the study (Special Project on the Political and Social Contexts of Health). Int. J. Health Serv. 33(4): 743–749, 2003.

49.

World Health Organization. World Health Report: Reducing Risks, Promoting Healthy Lives. Geneva, 2002.

50.

Oxfam. Rigged Rules and Double Standards. Oxford, 2002.

51.

Sogge

Give and Take: What's the Matter with Foreign Aid? Zed Books, London, 2002.

52.

Buina

(ed.). Challenges to the World Bank and the IMF: Developing Country Perspectives. Anthem Press, London, 2003.

53.

Monbiotm

The Age of Consent: A Manifesto for a New World Order. Flamingo, London, 2003.

54.

Schraeder

Clarifying the foreign aid puzzle: A comparison of American, Japanese, French and Swedish aid flows. World Polit. 50: 294–323, 1998.

55.

Wallerstein

The Modern World-System, Vols 1 and 2. Academic Press, New York, 1974/1980.

56.

Stewart

Wang

Do PRSPs Empower Poor Countries and Disempower the World Bank, or Is It the Other Way Round? QEH Working Papers Series, Working Paper 108. Queen Elizabeth House, University of Oxford, Oxford, 2003.

57.

Gould

Ojanen

The Politics of Tanzania's Poverty Reduction Strategy. European Network on Debt and Development, July 15, 2003. www.eurodad.org/articles/default.aspx?id=486 (November 2003).

58.

Miliband

Divided Societies: Class Struggle in Contemporary Capitalism. Oxford University Press, Oxford, 1989.

59.

Pilger

Hidden Agendas. Vintage, London, 1999.

60.

Chomsky

Rogue States: The Rule of Force in World Affairs. Pluto Press, London, 2000.

61.

Gills

Low Intensity Democracy. Pluto Press, London, 1999.

62.

Garrigou

Derrière la façade démocratique: L'abstention gagne les classes moyennes. Le Monde Diplomatique, April 2002.

63.

Chomsky

Deterring Democracy. South End Press, Cambridge, Mass., 1992.

64.

Blum

Killing Hope: US Military and CIA Interventions since World War II. Zed Books, London, 2003.

65.

Jones

(ed.). Genocide, War Crimes and the West. Zed Books, London, 2003.

66.

Roy

Instant mix imperial democracy: Buy one and get one free. Outlook, May 26, 2003, pp. 46–56.

67.

Mekay

Rich Nations Continue to Wield Power in Global Bodies. Interpress Service News Agency. www.ipsnews.net/interna.asp?idnews=18012 (November 2003).

68.

Bennis

Calling the Shots: How Washington Dominates Today's UN. Olive Branch Press, Brooklyn, N.Y., 1996.

69.

Aksu

Camilleri

J. A.

(eds.). Democratizing Global Governance. Palgrave Macmillan, Basingstoke, 2003.

70.

George

The Lugano Report. Pluto Press, London, 1999.

71.

Woodward

Trading Health for Profit: The Implications of the GATS and Trade in Health Services for Health in Developing Countries. Global Health, March 15, 2003. www.ukglobalhealth.org/content/Text/GATS_Woodward.pdf (November 2003).

72.

Jawara

Kwa

Behind the Scenes at the WTO: The Real World of Trade Negotiations. Zed Books, London, 2003.

73.

United Nations Development Program. Human Development Report 1993. New York, 1993.

74.

Monbiot

Captive State: The Corporate Takeover of Britain. Macmillan, Basingstoke, 2000.

75.

Alliance for Democracy. Call for UN Convention on Corporate Accountability. Paper presented at an NGO conference on corporate accountability and the WSSD, January 26–28, 2002.

76.

Richter

Building on Quicksand: The Global Compact, Democratic Governance and Nestlé. CETIM, IBFAN-GIFA, and Déclaration de Berne, Geneva, 2003.

77.

Deacon

Global Social Governance: Themes and Prospects. Globalism and Social Policy Programme, Ministry for Foreign Affairs, Department for International Cooperation, Helsinki, 2003.

78.

Kapur

Webber

Governance Related Conditionalities of the IFIs. G-24 Discussion Paper Series, No. 6. UNCTAD, Geneva, 2000.

79.

Brautigan

Aid Dependence and governance, pp. 16–20. Almquist and Wiksell, Stockholm, 2002. www.egdi.gov.se/pdf/2001pdf/2000-1.pdf (November 2003).

80.

Chang

H.-J.

Kicking Away the Ladder—Development Strategy in Historical Perspective. Anthem Press, London, 2002.

81.

Herman

Real Terror Networks. South End Press, Boston, 1982.

82.

Barya

J.-J.

The new political conditionalities of aid: An independent view from Africa. IDS Bull. 24(1): 16–23, 1993.

83.

Page

The Revolution That Never Was: Northeast Brazil 1955–1964. Grossman, New York, 1972.

84.

Bagdikian

The Media Monopoly. Beacon Press, Boston, 2000.

85.

Klinenberg

Dix maîtres pour les médias américains: Obsession du rendement, connivances avec les industrials. Le Monde Diplomatique, April 2003.

86.

Herman

McChesney

R.W.

The Global Media: The New Missionaries of Corporate Capitalism. Cassell, London, 1997.

87.

Pilger

The crusaders: The hidden history of Western media propaganda. New Internationalist, No. 333, April 2001.

88.

Thomas

P. N.

Nain

(eds.). Who Owns the Media? Global Trends and Local Resistances. Zed Books, London, 2003.

89.

Megalo media: The voice of globalization. New Internationalist, No. 333, April 2001.

90.

Ainger

Empires of the senseless. New Internationalist, No. 333, April 2001.

91.

Amin

Capitalism in the Age of Globalization: The Management of Contemporary Society. Zed Books, London, 1997.