Various Attempts to Establish a Basic Form of Beauty: Experimental Aesthetics,Golden Section,and Square

Abstract

Several aspects of proportionality and non-empirical investigations of proportions are discussed. Most of these studies intended to establish a general type of pleasant forms of beauty. Objections against the empirical method are refuted although it is admitted that the feeling of the artist may be the best way to find the most beautiful solution. The major part of the article reports the empirical proof on the pleasantness of proportions based on the selections among ten different quadrangles (proportions from 1:1 to 5:2). The peak of pleasingness was found with the golden section rectangle (35%), based on the choices of 347 Ss. Data on preference for and rejection of rectangles, as well as details of Ss' reactions are reported. Musically defined proportions did not show any superiority over other kinds of proportion. The preference for the golden section, however, was not found in a task of dividing a vertical line. It is concluded that the importance of the golden section has been overemphasized.

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Note: Fechner himself did not list any references. Thus—except his own literature—the references given here are possibly the books and articles he referred to. Any mistakes are fully under the responsibility of Holger Höge.

Fechner

G. T.

(1865). Über die Frage des goldenen Schnittes. [On the question of the golden section]. Archiv für die zeichnenden Künste, 11, 100–112.

Fechner

G. T.

(1871). Zur experimentalen Aesthetik. [On experimental aesthetics]. Leipzig: Hirzel.

Fechner

G. T.

(1871). Zur experimentalen Aesthetik. [On experimental aesthetics]. Abhandlungen der königlich-sächsischen Gesellschaft der Wissenschaften, mathematisch-physikalische Klasse, 9, 555–635. Reprinted in Fechner

G. T.

(1876/1925/1978). Vorschule der Aesthetic. [Preschool of aesthetics]. Hildesheim etc.: Olms.

Fechner

G. T.

(1872). Bericht über das auf der Dresdener Holbein-Ausstellung ausgelegte Album. [Report on the album presented at the Holbein exhibition in Dresden]. Leipzig: Breitkopf & Härtel.

Fechner

G. T.

(1876/1925/1978). Vorschule der Aesthetik. [Preschool of aesthetics]. Hildesheim: Olms. (Part 1 and 2; reprint of the 3rd edition 1925, Leipzig: Breitkopf & Härtel. 1st edition 1876).

Hay , (1851). The geometric beauty of the human figure defined.

Hay , (1852). The natural principles of beauty.

Heigelin , (date unknown). Lehrbuch der höhern Baukunst. [Textbook of higher architecture].

10.

Hogarth

(1697–1764). The analysis of beauty.

11.

Liharzik

(1865). Das Quadrat, die Grundlage aller Proportionalität in der Natur und das Quadrat aus der Zahl sieben—die Uridee des menschlichen Körperbaus. [The square, foundation of all proportionality in nature and the square of the number seven—the basic idea of the human physique]. Vienna.

12.

Röber

F. G.

(1861). Elementarbeiträge zur Bestimmung des Naturgesetzes der Gestaltung und des Widerstandes und Anwendung dieser Beiträge auf Natur und alte Kunstgestaltung. [Elementary contributions to the definition of the natural law of design and the resistance and application of these contributions on nature and ancient art-design]. Leipzig.

13.

Thiersch , (date unknown). Lehrbuch der Aesthetic. [Textbook of aesthetics].

14.

Winckelmann

J. J.

(1762). Anmerkungen über die Baukunst der alten Tempel zu Girgenti in Sizilien. [Remarks on the art of construction of the old temples of Girgenti in Sicily].

15.

Wolff , (date unknown). Beiträge zur Aesthetik der Baukunst. [Contributions to the aesthetics of architecture].

16.

Zeising

(1855). Aesthetische Forschungen. [Aesthetic inquiries], Frankfurt am Main: Medinger.