Responses of Blue Jays (Cyanocitta Cristata) to Raptors that Differ in Predatory Threat

Abstract

Some species of birds use their vocalisations to communicate predator presence and the level of threat they pose, including two species of corvids (Corvidae), American Crows (Corvus brachyrhynchos) and Siberian Jays (Perisoreus infaustus). Our objective was to determine if Blue Jays (Cyanocitta cristata), another corvid, also use specific calls or vary the characteristics of certain calls to convey information about the level of threat posed by aerial predators. During the non-breeding seasons of 2014 and 2015, we recorded and analysed the vocal responses of Blue Jays to study skins of six species of raptors that varied in size and the level of threat they pose to Blue Jays. Experiments were conducted at seven locations in Madison County, Kentucky. The mean number of Blue Jays present during trials was 2.6, and Blue Jays uttered five different vocalisations during trials, with ditonal and monotonal jeers given most frequently. The rate at which Blue Jays uttered ditonal jeers differed among trials, with rates highest during trials with an Eastern Screech-Owl (Megascops asio) and a Sharp-shinned Hawk (Accipiter striatus). However, the characteristics of ditonal and monotonal jeers (duration, low frequency, high frequency, and peak frequency) did not differ among trials. These results suggest that Blue Jays may either perceive Eastern Screech-Owls and Sharp-shinned Hawks as the greatest threats or, alternatively, as potential, but less threatening predators, and, therefore, they were willing to take greater risks when mobbing them. In contrast, Blue Jays mobbed the other raptors, i.e. American Kestrels (Falco sparverius), Red-tailed Hawks (Buteo jamaicensis), and Great Horned Owls (Bubo virginianus), with much less intensity, likely because they posed less of a threat or, in the case of Cooper's Hawks (Accipiter cooperii) that are known predators of Blue Jays, perhaps because mobbing with greater intensity, e.g. approaching more closely, posed too great a risk. Blue Jays in our study used the same calls with the same characteristics when responding to potential predators, only calling rates differed. However, such variation in calling rates when mobbing would likely provide useful information about the presence of, and possibly the threat posed by, potential predators for conspecifics and, perhaps, heterospecifics.

Keywords

Accipiter striatus Corvidae Megascops asio non-referential calls move-on hypothesis

References

Artuso

(2010) The diet of the Eastern Screech-Owl, Megascops asio, at the northern periphery of its range. Can. Field Nat., 124, 122–133.

Artuso

, Houston

C.S.

, Smith

D.G.

and Rohner

(2014) Great Horned Owl (Bubo virginianus). In: Rodewald

P.G.

(ed.), The birds of North America. Cornell Lab of Ornithology, Ithaca.

Baker

M.C.

and Becker

A.M.

(2002) Mobbing calls of Black-capped Chickadees: effects of urgency on call production. Wilson Bull., 114, 510–516.

Bielefeldt

, Rosenfield

R.N.

and Papp

J.M.

(1992) Unfounded assumptions about diet of the Cooper's Hawk. Condor, 84, 427–436.

Bildstein

K.L.

(1982) Responses of Northern Harriers to mobbing passerines. J. Field Ornithol., 53, 7–14.

Bildstein

K.L.

and Meyer

(2000) Sharp-shinned Hawk (Accipiter striatus). In: Rodewald

P.G.

(ed.), The birds of North America. Cornell Lab of Ornithology, Ithaca.

Browning

S.A.

(2015) Mixed-species flock members’ reactions to novel and predator stimuli. PhD thesis, University of Tennessee, Knoxville.

Clode

, Birks

J.D.S.

and Macdonald

D.W.

(2000) The influence of risk and vulnerability on predator mobbing by terns (Sterna spp.) and gulls (Larus spp.). J. Zool., 252, 53–59.

Cohen

S.M.

(1977) Blue Jay vocal behavior. PhD thesis, University of Michigan.

10.

Cohen

S.M.

, Stebbins

W.C.

and Moody

D.B.

(1978) Audibility thresholds of the Blue Jay. Auk, 95, 563–568.

11.

Collopy

M.W.

and Koplin

J.R.

(1983) Diet, capture success, and mode of hunting by female American Kestrels in winter. Condor, 85, 369–371.

12.

Conant

(1972) Visual and acoustic communication in the Blue Jay, Cyanocitta cristata (Aves, Corvidae). PhD thesis, University of Oklahoma.

13.

Courter

J.R.

and Ritchison

(2010) Alarm calls of Tufted Titmice convey information about predator size and threat. Behav. Ecol., 21, 936–942.

14.

Cunha

F.C.R.D.

, Fontenelle

J.C.R.

and Griesser

(2017) Predation risk drives the expression of mobbing across bird species. Behav. Ecol., 28, 1517–1523.

15.

Ellis

J.M.

(2008) The vocal repertoire of the White-throated Magpie-Jay (Calocitta formosa). PhD thesis, Cornell University.

16.

Ficken

M.S.

(1989) Are mobbing calls of Steller's Jays a “confusion chorus”? J. Field Ornithol., 60, 52–55.

17.

Fitch

H.S.

(1958) Home ranges, territories, and seasonal movements of vertebrates on the natural history reservation. Univ. Kansas Publ. Mus. Nat. Hist., 11, 63–326.

18.

Flasskamp

(1994) The adaptive significance of avian mobbing V. An experimental test of the ‘move on’ hypothesis. Ethology, 96, 322–333.

19.

Gates

J.M.

(1972) Red-tailed Hawk populations and ecology in east-central Wisconsin. Wilson Bull., 84, 421–433.

20.

Gehlbach

F.R.

(1994) The Eastern Screech-Owl: life history, ecology, and behavior in the suburbs and countryside. Texas A & M University Press, USA.

21.

Gill

S.A.

and Bierema

A.M.-K.

(2013) On the meaning of alarm calls: a review of functional reference in avian alarm calling. Ethology, 119, 449–461.

22.

Griesser

(2008) Referential calls signal predator behavior in a group-living bird species. Curr. Biol., 18, 69–73.

23.

Griesser

(2009) Mobbing calls signal predator category in a kin group-living bird species. Proc. R. Soc. B, 276, 2887–2892.

24.

Holroyd

G.L.

(2002) Mobbing Black-billed Magpie, Pica hudsonia, killed by Cooper's Hawk, Accipiter cooperii. Can. Field Nat., 116, 137–138.

25.

Holzhaider

J.C.

, Sibley

M.D.

, Taylor

A.H.

, Singh

P.J.

, Gray

R.D.

and Hunt

G.R.

(2011) The social structure of New Caledonian Crows. Anim. Behav., 81, 83–92.

26.

Koboroff

, Kaplan

and Rogers

L.J.

(2013) Clever strategists: Australian Magpies vary mobbing strategies, not intensities, relative to different species of predator. PeerJ, 1, e56.

27.

Krams

, Krama

, Freeberg

T.M.

, Kullberg

and Lucas

J.R.

(2012) Linking social complexity and vocal complexity: a parid perspective. Phil. Trans. R. Soc. B, 367, 1879–1891.

28.

Layne

J.N.

and Smith

D.R.

(1992) Size comparison of resident and wintering American Kestrels in south-central Florida. J. Field Ornithol., 63, 256–263.

29.

McWhirter

S.N.

(2000) Confirmed breeding of Cooper's Hawk in urban Shelby County. Migrant, 71, 4–6.

30.

Preston

C.R.

and Beane

R.D.

(2009) Red-tailed Hawk (Buteo jamaicensis). In: Rodewald

P.G.

(ed.), The birds of North America. Cornell Lab of Ornithology, Ithaca.

31.

Ritchison

and Cavanagh

P.M.

(1992) Prey use by Eastern Screech-Owls: seasonal variation in central Kentucky and a review of previous studies. J. Raptor Res., 26, 66–73.

32.

Roth

T.C.

and Lima

S.L.

(2003) Hunting behavior and diet of Cooper's Hawks: an urban view of the small-bird-in-winter paradigm. Condor, 105, 474–483.

33.

Roth

T.C.

and Lima

S.L.

(2006) Predatory behavior and diet of wintering male Cooper's Hawks in a rural habitat. J. Raptor Res., 40, 287–290.

34.

Roth

T.C.

, Lima

S.L.

and Vetter

W.E.

(2006) Determinants of predation risk in small wintering birds: the hawk's perspective. Behav. Ecol. Sociobiol., 60, 195–204.

35.

Smith

K.G.

, Tarvin

K.A.

and Woolfenden

G.E.

(2013) Blue Jay (Cyanocitta cristata). In: Rodewald

P.G.

(ed.), The birds of North America. Cornell Lab of Ornithology, Ithaca.

36.

Soard

C.M.

and Ritchison

(2009) “Chick-a-dee” calls of Carolina Chickadees convey information about degree of threat posed by avian predators. Anim. Behav., 78, 1447–1453.

37.

Sordahl

T.A.

(1990) The risks of avian mobbing and distraction behavior: an anecdotal review. Wilson Bull., 102, 349–352.

38.

Stokes

D.W.

and Stokes

L.Q.

(2010) The Stokes field guide to the birds of North America. Little, Brown and Company, USA.

39.

Storer

R.W.

(1966) Sexual dimorphism and food habits in three North American accipiters. Auk, 83, 423–436.

40.

Strnad

, Nìmec

, Veselý

and Fuchs

(2012) Red-backed Shrikes (Lanius collurio) adjust the mobbing intensity, but not mobbing frequency, by assessing the potential threat to themselves from different predators. Ornis Fennica, 89, 206–215.

41.

Suzuki

T.N.

(2011) Parental alarm calls warn nestlings about different predatory threats. Curr. Biol., 21, R15–R16.

42.

Suzuki

T.N.

(2012) Referential mobbing calls elicit different predator-searching behaviours in Japanese Great Tits. Anim. Behav., 84, 53–57.

43.

Templeton

C.N.

and Greene

(2007) Nuthatches eavesdrop on variations in heterospecific chickadee mobbing alarm calls. Proc. Natl Acad. Sci. USA, 104, 5479–5482.

44.

Templeton

C.N.

, Greene

and Davis

(2005) Allometry of alarm calls: Black-capped Chickadees encode information about predator size. Science, 308, 1934–1937.

45.

Yorzinski

J.L.

and Vehrencamp

S.L.

(2009) The effect of predator type and danger level on the mob calls of the American Crow. Condor, 111, 159–168.