Delivering Environmental Education in Kazakhstan through Civic Action: Second-Wave Values and Governmental Responses 1

Abstract

The severity of Kazakhstan's ecological problems impels civic activists and state agencies to build public support for ecological rehabilitation in the country, through a comprehensive national programme of environmental education.

This paper is a qualitative analysis whose main focus is the relations of civic groups and NGOs with the national government, occurring in the delivery of programmes for environmental education during the post-glasnost era.

Provisional successes of civic groups in establishing environmental education programmes, and useful steps by the government to facilitate civic environmental activism, give reasons for optimism for improved environmental governance.

Keywords

Kazakhstan environmental education environmental values environmental policy ENGOs civic society

References

ADB (Asian Development Bank), 2007. Kazakhstan – Overview of NGOs/Civil Society, 10pp. http://www.adb.org/Documents/Reports/Civil-Society-Briefs/KAZ/CSB-KAZ.pdf (accessed 2 November, 2009).

ADB 2004. Kazakhstan: Country Environmental Analysis, March, 145pp. http://www.adb.org/Documents/Reports/CEA/kaz-mar2004.pdf (accessed 22 July, 2009).

Aitekenov

2001. ‘Progress v ekologicheskom informirovanii i obrazovanii’. Ekologiia i ustoichivoe razvitie (December): 25–30.

Aknazarov

2001. ‘Uchastie obshchestvennosti v ispolnenii orkhusskoi konventsii’. Ekologiia i ustoichivoe razvitie (December): 39–43.

Alimbaiev

2000. ‘Ekologicheskoe obrazovanie i vospitanie v vuzakh Kazakhstana v 70–80 gody’. Vysshaia Shkola Kazakhstana 3: 80–85.

Amantaiev

2006. ‘Ekologicheskie NPO na strazhe pryrody’. Ekologicheskii Kur'er (September): 1–15, 3.

Arisheva

Z.A.

2008. ‘Almatinskii gorodskoi mesiachnik po ekologicheskomu vospita-niiu’. Ekologiia i obshchestvo No. 56, 23: 8–10.

Aruova

L.B.

and Darmaganbetova

K.Kh.

, 2003. ‘Obshchestvennye organizatsii – effektivnyi ekologicheskii istochnik’. Ekologiia i ustoichivoe razvitie (May): 27.

Astanina

Lidiia

, 2001. ‘Deiatel'nost’ nepravitel'stvennykh organizatsii po informirovaniu v ramkakh Orkhusskoi Konventsii’. Ekologiia i ustoichivoe razvitie (December): 44–48.

10.

Balashova

Irina

, 2004. ‘Uchebnye posobiia “Okruzhaiushcha sreda dlia budushchikh pokolenii”’. Ekologiia i ustoichivoe razvitie (June): 34.

11.

Beisenova

A.S.

2008. ‘Kontseptsiia nepreryvnogo ekologicheskogo obrazovaniia i vospitaniia’. Ekologicheskoe obrazovanie v Kazakhstane (January-February): 11.

12.

Bekturganov

2001. ‘Perspektivy razvitiia ekologicheskogo obrazovaniia’. Ekologiia i ustoichivoe razvitie No. 10.

13.

Chebotarev

Andrei

, 2004. ‘Vlast’ i instituty grazhdanskogo obshchestva v kazakhstane; problemy i perspektivy dialoga’. http://www.caapr.kz/show.php?kza270104–02htm (accessed 2 November, 2009).

14.

Critchlow

James

, 1995. ‘Central Asia: How to Pick up the Pieces?’ In DeBardeleben

Joan

and Hannigan

John

(eds.), Environmental Security and Quality After Communism, pp. 139–153. Boulder: Westview Press.

15.

Dominick

Raymond

, 1998. ‘Capitalism, communism, and environmental protection: lessons from the German experience’. Environmental History 3: 311–332. CrossRef.

16.

Doyle

Timothy

and McEachern

Doug

, 2001. Environment and Politics, 2nd edn. London and New York: Routledge.

17.

Durbaieva

Asel’

, 2005. ‘Ezhegodnaia vstrecha konsul'tativnogo soveta RETsTsA’. Ekologiia i ustoichivoe razvitie No. 9, 2.

18.

Ekologiia i obshchestvo, 2007. ‘Ot redaktsii’. No. 7, 2.

19.

Ekologiia i ustoichivoe razvitie, 2003. ‘Ekologicheskie organizatsii Kazakhstana’. (March): 43–47.

20.

Eleusizov

Mels

, 2006. ‘Partiia “Zelenykh”’. Ekologicheskii Kur'er (15 March–1 April): 5.

21.

Emelianova

Elena

and Starik

Mark

, (n.d.). ‘Russian environmental values and strategies: historical development and role of NGOs’. www.americancouncisl.org/JER/v3n2/3–2-6.pdf (accessed 24 December, 2010).

22.

Esekin

Bulat

, 2001. ‘Progress Kazakhstana v dostizhenii tselei Povestki Dnia na 21 vek’. Ekologiia i ustoichivoe razvitie No. 1: 16–23.

23.

Esnazarova

U. A.

and Imangulova

T.V.

, 2008. ‘Ekologicheskoe obrazovanie i vospitanie uchashchikhsia dlia ustoichivogo razvitiia obshchestva’. Ekologiia i obshchestvo v Kazakhstane (January-February): 13–14.

24.

Feshbach

Murrary

and Friendly

Alfred

Jr . 1992. Ecocide in the USSR: Health and Nature under Siege. New York: BasicBooks.

25.

Freedman

Eric

, 2009. ‘Environmental journalism and ecological nongovernmental organizations in Kyrgyzstan and Kazakhstan: Too rarely shall the twain meet’, 29pp. Paper presented at the Central Eurasian Studies Society annual conference, Toronto, October, 2009.

26.

Goudie

Cheryl A.

2009. ‘Institutionalizing ecological literacy: a critical component of the new “green” economy’. Business Perspectives 19: 16–22.

27.

Hamdouch

Abdelillah

and Zuindeau

Bertrand

, 2010. ‘Sustainable development 20 years on: methodological innovations, practices and open issues’. Journal of Environmental Planning and Management 53: 427–438. CrossRef.

28.

INforEEP, (n.d.). ‘What is Environmental Education and why the need for it?’ http://www.bcb.uwc.ac.za/inforeep/what's_EE2.htm (accessed 23 December, 2010).

29.

Irgebaieva

N.M.

and Nasyrkhanova

B.K.

, 2008. ‘Voprosy ekologicheskogo obrazova-niia v vuzakh’. Vysshaia shkola Kazakhstana No. 2: 112–114.

30.

Iskakov

2008. ‘Priroda blagodenstviia’. Ekologicheskii kur'er (16–31 March): 3.

31.

Iudina

Irina

, 2007. ‘Ekoobrazovanie v interesakh ustoichivogo razvitiia’. Ekologiia i obshchestvo No. 3:. 17–18.

32.

Jancar-Webster

Barbara

, 1995. ‘Environmental Degradation and Regional Instability in Central Europe’. In DeBardeleben

Joan

and Hannigan

John

(eds.), Environmental Security and Quality After Communism, pp. 43–68. Boulder: Westview Press.

33.

Kappasov

Ibragim

, 2007. ‘Rol’ NPO sektora v formirovanii grazhdanskogo obshchestva Kazakhstana’. http://www.la-centr.ru/archive/public_details0e56.html?id=590, 6 pp. (accessed 2 November, 2009).

34.

Karakulova

Elina

, 2003. ‘Environmental NGOs in Kazakhstan Wield Increasing Influence Over Policy in Kazakhstan’. 25 July, 1–3, http://www.eurasianet.org/departments/environment/articles/eav072503.shtml (accessed 17 May, 2009).

35.

Kazakhstan , 2002. ‘Prikaz Ministerstva obrazovaniia i nauki RK ot 25 sentabria 2002 g. No. 69. Kontseptsiia ekologicheskogo obrazovaniia Respubliki Kazakhstan’. Cited in Ekologiia i ustoichivoe razvitie (October, 2003): 56–64.

36.

Kazakhstan, 1996 ‘Prilozheniie No. 2 k rasporiazheniiu Presidenta Respubliki Kazakhstan N 2967 ot 30 aprelia 1996 g. Kontseptsiia ekologicheskoi bezopas-nosti Respubliki Kazakhstan’ Cited in Ekologiia i ustoichivoe razvitie No. 1, 2001, 59–71.

37.

Kazakhstanskaia Pravda , 2003. ‘O Kontseptsii ekologicheskoi bezopasnosti Respubliki Kazakhstan na 2004–2015 gody. Ukaz Prezidenta Respubliki Kazakhstan ot 3 dek-abria 2003 goda N 1241’. (10 December): 7–8.

38.

Kesikbaiev

2004. ‘Informatsiia o sostoianii okhrany okruzhaiushchei sredy v Respublike Kazakhstan: itogi raboty po okhrane okruzhaiushchei sredy za 2003 god i polugodie 2004 goda’. Ekologiia i ustoichivoe razvitie (November): 2.

39.

Koshelev

V.K.

2006. ‘Nepreryvnoe ekologicheskoe obrazovanie na puti ekonomicheskogo razvitiia’. Ekologicheskoe obrazovanie v Kazakhstane (July-August): 11–13.

40.

Kreiser

Konstantin

and Lachmann

Lars

, 2003. Local Environmental NGOs in Kazakhstan: An Assessment of Efficiency Bonn: Naturschutzbund Deutschland.

41.

Lepsibaiev

Chingiz

, 2009. ‘O volonterstve v Kazakhstane: doklad na IV grazhdanskii forum’. http://my.mail.ru/community/yuthofkazakhstan/6DC855B64B8 (accessed 10 February, 2011).

42.

Luong

Pauline Jones

and Weinthal

Erika

, 1999. ‘Democratic goals and non-democratic outcomes in Kazakhstan’. Europe-Asia Studies 51, 1267–1284. CrossRef.

43.

Marston-Nicholson, [sic] 2009. ‘Civil Society: Kazakhstan to encourage NGO-activities’. http://www.kazakhstanlive.com/2.aspx?ProdID=88627a56–4bff-476c-898e-9305abd3c211&CatID=9f9f8034–6dd6–4f7eadcf-0f6a7co406d9&sr=100&page=1 (accessed 9 November, 2009).

44.

Ministry of Defense of Kazakhstan, 2009. ‘Constitution of the Republic of Kazakhstan’. http://mod.kz/upload/Zakoni_doc/Postanovle/Constitution.doc (accessed 8 July, 2009).

45.

Mol

Arthur

, 2009. ‘Environmental deinstitutionalization in Russia’. Journal of Environmental Policy and Planning 11: 223–241. CrossRef.

46.

Mustafina

A.S.

and Mustafina

V.V.

, 2008. ‘Ob ekologicheskom obrazovanii v ramkakh ustoichivogo razvitiia’. Ekologicheskoe obrazovaniie v Kazakhstane (November– December): 23–24.

47.

Mynbaieva

B. N.

and Gaidobrusova

M.N.

, 2009. ‘Poslevuzovskoe ekologicheskoe obrazovanie: problemy, razmyshleniia, perspektivy’. Ekologicheskoe obrazovanie v Kazakhstane (March-April): 14.

48.

Vadim

, 2004. ‘Gosudarstvo i NPO: formy vzaimodeistviia’. Ekologiia i ustoichivoe razvitie (February): 50.

49.

Neill

James

, 2006. ‘What is Environmental Education?’ http://wilderdom.co/environment/EnvironmentalEducation.html (accessed 23 December, 2010).

50.

Nikolaienko

Aleksandr

, 2004. ‘RETsTsA prezentovala uchebnoe posobie po ekoobrazovaniiu’. Ekologiia i ustoichivoe razvitie No. 5, 55.

51.

Nukezhanov

E.B.

2008. ‘Razvitiie i problemy nepravitel'stvennykh organizatsii v formirovanii grazhdanskogo obshchestva v Kazakhstane’. http://www.zakon.kz/109077-razvitie-i-problemy-nepravitelstvennykh.html (accessed 9 November, 2009).

52.

O'Lear

Shannon

, 1997. ‘Electronic communication and environmental policy in Russia and Estonia’. Geographical Review 87: 275–290. CrossRef.

53.

Ostergren

David

and Jacques

Peter

, 2002. ‘A Political Economy of Russian Nature Conservation Policy: Why Scientists Have Taken a Back Seat’. Global Environmental Politics 2(4): 102–124. CrossRef.

54.

Ostergren

David

, 2001. ‘The nexus of science and protected area policy making: a case study of Russian scientists, national parks, and zapovedniks, 1970–2000,’ pp. 349–354. Proceedings of the 11th Conference on Research and Resource Management in Parks and Public Lands, The 2001 George Wright Society Biennial Conference, Flagstaff: Northern Arizona University.

55.

Ovcharenko

Vsevolod

, 2004. ‘The state-civil society relationship in Kazakhstan: Mechanisms of cooperation and support’. The International Journal of Not-for-Profit Law June, 2 http://www.icnl.org/KNOWLEDGE/IJNL/vol6iss3/art_4.htm (accessed 4 May, 2009).

56.

Panin

M.S.

2007. ‘Prioritetnie napraveleniia ekologicheskogo obrazovaniia v Respublike Kazakhstan’. Ekologicheskoe obrazovanie v Kazakhstane September-October, 2–3.

57.

Pavlinek

Petr

and Pickles

John

, 2000. Environmental Transitions: Transformation and Ecological Defence in Central and Eastern Europe. London: Routledge.

58.

Peterson

D.J.

1993. Troubled Lands: The Legacy of Soviet Environmental Destruction, http://www.rand.org/pubs/commercial_books/CB367.html (accessed 24 December, 2010).

59.

Poliakov

Aleksandr

, 2003. ‘Grazhdanskii forum’. Ekologiia i ustoichivoe razvitie (November): 33–34.

60.

Ponomarenko

E.V.

2007. ‘Resul'taty diagnostiki v oblasti ekologicheskogo obrazova-niia studentov’. Menedzhment v obrazovanii No. 4: 28–32.

61.

Ponomarenko

E.V.

and Pak

, 2009. ‘Nekotorie didakticheskie aspekty ekologich-eskogo vospitaniia starsheklassnikov’. Ekologicheskoe obrazovaniie v Kazakhstane (January–February): 32–33.

62.

Prokhorenko

2004. ‘Kazakhstan: ekologiia i partiitsy’. Novoe pokolenie 4 June http://sovet.environement.ru/greensabroad/news.html?cmd%5B91%5D=I-85–2724 (accessed 23 February, 2009).

63.

Rakhimbergenov

M. M.

and Belyi

A.V.

, 2007. ‘Obshchestvennaia otsenka ekologich-eskoi situatsii v g. Astana’. Ekologiia i obshchestvo No. 4–5: 22–24.

64.

Riabchenko

2001. ‘Puti formirovaniia ekologicheskoi kul'tury v obshchestvennom soznanii kazakhstanstev’. Ekologiia i ustoichivoe razvitie (December): 34–36.

65.

Riaguzov

V. V.

and Bisarieva

Sh.

, 2002. ‘Sostoianie, perspektivy i puti razvitiia eko-logicheskogo obrazovaniia v stranakh Tsentral'noi Azii’. Ekologiia i ustoichivoe razvitie 9: 4–22.

66.

Saiko

Tatyana

, 2001. Environmental Crises: Geographical Case Studies in Post-socialist Eurasia. Harlow: Prentice Hall.

67.

Samakova

Aitkul’

, 2004. ‘K ekologicheskomu kodeksu Respubliki Kazakhstan’. Ekologiia i ustoichivoe razvitie (December): 2–3.

68.

Shakirova

, 2001. ‘Orkhusskaia Konventsiia: dostup k informatsii’. Ekologiia i ustoichivoe razvitie (December): 36–39.

69.

Shukputov

2001. ‘Okruzhaiushchaia sreda i nashe budushchee’. Ekologiia i ustoichivoe razvitie (July): 2–14.

70.

Stapp

William B.

. 1969. ‘The concept of environmental education’. The Journal of Environmental Education 1(1): 30–32.

71.

Sydykhova

Tolegena Seidomarovicha

, 2009. ‘Tema: Sotsial'nyi zakaz gosudarstva i razvitiie grazhdanskogo obshchestva’. http://dp-adilet.kz/ru/769.html (accessed 9 November, 2009).

72.

UNDP/GRID-Arendal, 2000. ‘Osnovnye predposylki dlia realizatsii ekologicheskoi politiki’. http://enrin.grida.no/htmls/kazakhst/soe2/soe/nav/info/ecopol.htm (accessed 25 February, 2009).

73.

Van Buren

Lisa

, 1995. ‘Citizen participation and environment in Russia’. In DeBardeleben

Joan

and Hannigan

John

(eds.), Environmental Security and Quality After Communism, pp. 127–137. Boulder: Westview Press.

74.

Verzhbitskaia

Natal'ia

, 2008. ‘Deputaty ozabochenie ekologiei’. Vechernii Almaty 27 (March): 29.

75.

Weinthal

Erika

and Luong

Pauline Jones

, 2002. ‘Environmental NGOs in Kazakhstan: democratic goals and nondemocratic outcomes’. http://www.ciaonet.org/book/mes01_152_176_ch6.pdf (accessed 8 May, 2009).

76.

Whitehead

Mark

, 2010. ‘Hollow sustainabilities? Perspectives on Sustainable Development in the post-socialist world’. Geography Compass No. 11, 1618–1634. CrossRef.

77.

Welling Hall

Barbara

, 1990. ‘Soviet perceptions of global ecological problems: an analysis of three patterns’. Political Psychology 11(4): 653–680. CrossRef.

78.

Zhirkova

M. G.

2007. ‘Proekt “Shkoly-Kazakhstan”: 5 let sushchestvovaniia, trud-nosti, dostizheniia i novye gorizonty’. Ekologicheskoe obrazovanie v Kazakhstane (May-June): 5–6.

79.

Zhunusova

1996. ‘Environmental Information Systems in Kazakhstan’. Ministry of Ecology and Bioresources of the Republic of Kazakhstan. http://enrin.grida.no/htmls/kazahst/kazakh_e.htm (accessed 27 February, 2009).

80.

Ziegler

Charles

, 1987. Environmental Policy in the USSR. New York: John Dekker and Sons.