Respiratory therapists (RTs) work alongside allied health staff, nurses, and physicians during stressful and traumatic events that can be associated with emotional and physiological implications known as second victim (SV) experiences (SVEs). This study aimed to evaluate SVEs of RTs, including both positive and negative implications.
METHODS:
RTs within a large academic health care organization across Minnesota, Wisconsin, Florida, and Arizona were asked to participate in an anonymous survey that included the validated Second Victim Experience and Support Tool-Revised to assess SVEs as well as desired support services.
RESULTS:
Of the RTs invited to participate, 30.8% (171/555) completed the survey. Of the 171 survey respondents, 91.2% (156) reported that they had been part of a stressful or traumatic work-related event as an RT, student, or department support staff member. Emotional or physiologic implications experienced by respondents as SVs included anxiety 39.1% (61/156), reliving of the event 36.5% (57/156), sleeplessness 32.1% (50/156), and guilt 28.2% (44/156). Following a stressful clinical event, 14.8% (22/149) experienced psychological distress, 14.2% (21/148) experienced physical distress, 17.7% (26/147) indicated lack of institutional support, and 15.6% (23/147) indicated turnover intentions. Enhanced resilience and growth were reported by 9.5% (14/147). Clinical and non-clinical events were reported as possible triggers for SVEs. Nearly half of respondents 49.4% (77/156) indicated feeling like an SV due to events related to COVID-19. Peer support was the highest ranked form of desired support following an SVE by 57.7% (90/156).
CONCLUSIONS:
RTs are involved in stressful or traumatic clinical events, resulting in psychological/physical distress and turnover intentions. The COVID-19 pandemic has had a significant impact on RTs’ SVEs, highlighting the importance of addressing the SV phenomenon among this population.
PhamJC, AswaniMS, RosenM, LeeH, HuddleM, WeeksK, et al. Reducing medical errors and adverse events. Annu Rev Med, 2012; 63(1):447-463.
2.
ScottSD, HirschingerLE, CoxKR, McCoigM, BrandtJ, HallLW. The natural history of recovery for the health care provider “second victim” after adverse patient events. Qual Saf Health Care, 2009; 18(5):325-330.
3.
BurlisonJD, QuillivanRR, ScottSD, JohnsonS, HoffmanJM. The effects of the second victim phenomenon on work-related outcomes: connecting self-reported caregiver distress to turnover intentions and absenteeism. J Patient Saf, 2021; 17(3):195-199.
4.
SeysD, WuAW, Van GervenE, VleugelsA, EuwemaM, PanellaM, et al. Health care professionals as second victims after adverse events: a systematic review. Eval Health Prof, 2013; 36(2):135-162.
5.
WuAW. Medical error: the second victim: the doctor who makes the mistake needs help too. BMJ, 2000; 320(7237):726-727.
6.
GazoniFM, AmatoPE, MalikZM, DurieuxME. The impact of perioperative catastrophes on anesthesiologists: results of a national survey. Anesth Analg, 2012; 114(3):596-603.
7.
ShanafeltTD, BalchCM, BechampsG, RussellT, DyrbyeL, SateleD, et al. Burnout and medical errors among American surgeons. Ann Surg, 2010; 251(6):995-1000.
8.
FinneyRE, CzinskiS, FjerstadK, ArteagaGM, WeaverAL, RigganKA, et al. Evaluation of a second victim peer support program on perceptions of second victim experiences and supportive resources in pediatric clinical specialties using the second victim experience and support tool (SVEST). J Pediatr Nurs, 2021; 61:312-317.
9.
FinneyRE, TorbensonVE, RigganKA, WeaverAL, LongME, AllyseMA, et al. Second victim experiences of nurses in obstetrics and gynecology: a second victim experience and support tool survey. J Nurs Manag, 2021; 29(4):642-652.
10.
Rivera-ChiauzziE, FinneyRE, RigganKA, WeaverAL, LongME, TorbensonVE, et al. Understanding the second victim experience among multidisciplinary providers in obstetrics and gynecology. J Patient Saf, 2022; 18(2):e463-e469.
11.
ScottSD, HirschingerLE, CoxKR, McCoigM, Hahn-CoverK, EpperlyKM, et al. Caring for our own: deploying a systemwide second victim rapid response team. Jt Comm J Qual Patient Saf, 2010; 36(5):233-240.
12.
McHenryKL, WingTJ, LesterJ, InabnitL, YongG. Assessing burnout and resiliency in online degree advancement respiratory care students during a pandemic. Internet J Allied Health Sci Pract, 2022; 20(2):1-9.
13.
MillerAG, RobertsKJ, HinksonCR, DavisG, StricklandSL, RehderKJ. Resilience and burnout resources in respiratory care departments. Respir Care, 2021; 66(5):715-723.
14.
MillerAG, RobertsKJ, SmithBJ, BurrKL, HinksonCR, HoerrCA, et al. Prevalence of burnout among respiratory therapists amid the COVID-19 pandemic. Respir Care, 2021; 66(11):1639-1648.
15.
WardC, BanfieldJ, BrousseauP. A survey of Canadian RRTs working in the COVID-19 pandemic. The RRT perspective. Can J Respir Ther, 2021; 57:4-5.
16.
CoughlanB, PowellD, HigginsMF. The second victim: a review. Eur J Obstet Gynecol Reprod Biol, 2017; 213:11-16.
17.
EdreesHH, PaineLA, FeroliER, WuAW. Health care workers as second victims of medical errors. Pol Arch Med Wewn, 2011; 121(4):101-108.
18.
KrzanKD, MerandiJ, MorvayS, MirtalloJ. Implementation of a “second victim” program in a pediatric hospital. Am J Health Syst Pharm, 2015; 72(7):563-567.
19.
EdreesH, ConnorsC, PaineL, NorvellM, TaylorH, WuAW. Implementing the RISE second victim support program at the Johns Hopkins Hospital: a case study. BMJ Open, 2016; 6(9):e011708.
20.
BurlisonJD, ScottSD, BrowneEK, ThompsonSG, HoffmanJM. The second victim experience and support tool: validation of an organizational resource for assessing second victim effects and the quality of support resources. J Patient Saf, 2017; 13(2):93-102.
21.
MiraJJ, CarrilloI, LorenzoS, FerrúsL, SilvestreC, Pérez-PérezP, et al. on behalf of the Research Group on Second and Third Victims. The aftermath of adverse events in Spanish primary care and hospital health professionals. BMC Health Serv Res, 2015; 15(1):151.
22.
El HechiMW, BohnenJD, WestfalM, HanK, CauleyC, WrightC, et al. Design and impact of a novel surgery-specific second victim peer support program. J Am Coll Surg, 2020; 230(6):926-933.
23.
Rivera-ChiauzziEY, SmithHA, Moore-MurrayT, LeeC, GoffmanD, BernsteinPS, et al. Healing our own: a randomized trial to assess benefits of peer support. J Patient Saf, 2022; 18(1):e308-e314.
24.
FinneyRE, JacobA, JohnsonJ, MessnerH, PulosB, SviggumH. Implementation of a second victim peer support program in a large anesthesia department. AANA J, 2021; 89(3):235-244.
25.
WinningAM, MerandiJM, LeweD, StepneyLMC, LiaoNN, FortneyCA, et al. The emotional impact of errors or adverse events on healthcare providers in the NICU: the protective role of coworker support. J Adv Nurs, 2018; 74(1):172-180.
26.
WinningAM, MerandiJ, RauschJR, LiaoN, HoffmanJM, BurlisonJD, et al. Validation of the second victim experience and support tool-revised in the neonatal intensive care unit. J Patient Saf, 2021; 17(8):531-540.
27.
RassinM, KantiT, SilnerD. Chronology of medication errors by nurses: accumulation of stresses and PTSD symptoms. Issues Ment Health Nurs, 2005; 26(8):873-886.
28.
WatermanAD, GarbuttJ, HazelE, DunaganWC, LevinsonW, FraserVJ, et al. The emotional impact of medical errors on practicing physicians in the United States and Canada. Jt Comm J Qual Patient Saf, 2007; 33(8):467-476.
29.
SchelbredAB, NordR. Nurses’ experiences of drug administration errors. J Adv Nurs, 2007; 60(3):317-324.
30.
McIntyreN, PopperK. The critical attitude in medicine: the need for a new ethics. Br Med J (Clin Res Ed), 1983; 287(6409):1919-1923.
31.
LeapeLL, BrennanTA, LairdN, LawthersAG, LocalioAR, BarnesBA, et al. The nature of adverse events in hospitalized patients: results of the Harvard medical practice study II. N Engl J Med, 1991; 324(6):377-384.
32.
ArmitageG. Human error theory: relevance to nurse management. J Nurs Manag, 2009; 17(2):193-202.
33.
SameeraV, BindraA, RathGP. Human errors and their prevention in health care. J Anaesthesiol Clin Pharmacol, 2021; 37(3):328-335.
34.
OzekeO, OzekeV, CoskunO, BudakogluII. Second victims in health care: current perspectives. AMEP, 2019; Volume 10:593-603.
35.
QuillivanRR, BurlisonJD, BrowneEK, ScottSD, HoffmanJM. Patient safety culture and the second victim phenomenon: connecting culture to staff distress in nurses. Jt Comm J Qual Patient Saf, 2016; 42(8):377-386.
36.
NydooP, PillayBJ, NaickerT, MoodleyJ. The second victim phenomenon in health care: a literature review. Scand J Public Health, 2020; 48(6):629-637.
37.
Pereira-LimaK, MataDA, LoureiroSR, CrippaJA, BolsoniLM, SenS. Association between physician depressive symptoms and medical errors: a systematic review and meta-analysis. JAMA Netw Open, 2019; 2(11):e1916097.
38.
BrunsbergKA, LandriganCP, GarciaBM, PettyCR, SectishTC, SimpkinAL, et al. Association of pediatric resident physician depression and burnout with harmful medical errors on inpatient services. Acad Med, 2019; 94(8):1150-1156.
39.
WestCP, HuschkaMM, NovotnyPJ, SloanJA, KolarsJC, HabermannTM, et al. Association of perceived medical errors with resident distress and empathy: a prospective longitudinal study. Jama, 2006; 296(9):1071-1078.
40.
SchwappachDL, BoluarteTA. The emotional impact of medical error involvement on physicians: a call for leadership and organizational accountability. Swiss Med Wkly, 2009; 139(1-2):9-15.
41.
YanL, TanJ, ChenH, YaoL, LiY, ZhaoQ, et al. Experience and support of Chinese health care professionals as second victims of patient safety incidents: a cross-sectional study. Perspect Psychiatr Care, 2022; 58(2):733-743.
42.
WahlbergÅ, SachsMB, JohannessonK, HallbergG, JonssonMS, SvanbergA, et al. Self-reported exposure to severe events on the labor ward among Swedish midwives and obstetricians: a cross-sectional retrospective study. Int J Nurs Stud, 2017; 65:8-16.
43.
AdelmanJS, GandhiTK. COVID-19 and patient safety: time to tap into our investment in high reliability. J Patient Saf, 2021; 17(4):331-333.
44.
RosenthalLJ, ByerlyA, TaylorAD, MartinovichZ. Impact and prevalence of physical and verbal violence toward health care workers. Psychosomatics, 2018; 59(6):584-590.
45.
BuschIM, MorettiF, CampagnaI, BenoniR, TardivoS, WuAW, et al. Promoting the psychological well-being of healthcare providers facing the burden of adverse events: a systematic review of second victim support resources. Int J Environ Res Public Health, 2021; 18(10).
46.
XuH, CaoX, JinQX, WangRS, ZhangYH, ChenZH. The impact of the second victim’s experience and support on the career success of psychiatric nurses: the mediating effect of psychological resilience. J Nursing Management, 2022; 30(6):1559-1569.
47.
StricklandSL, RobertsKJ, SmithBJ, HoerrCA, BurrKL, HinksonCR, et al. Burnout among respiratory therapists amid the COVID-19 pandemic. Respir Care, 2022; 67(12):1578-1587.
48.
HuYY, FixML, HeveloneND, LipsitzSR, GreenbergCC, WeissmanJS, et al. Physicians’ needs in coping with emotional stressors: the case for peer support. Arch Surg, 2012; 147(3):212-217.
49.
JoestenL, CipparroneN, Okuno-JonesS, DuBoseER. Assessing the perceived level of institutional support for the second victim after a patient safety event. J Patient Saf, 2015; 11(2):73-78.
50.
DukhaninV, EdreesHH, ConnorsCA, KangE, NorvellM, WuAW. Case: A second victim support program in pediatrics: successes and challenges to implementation. J Pediatr Nurs, 2018; 41:54-59.
51.
EdreesHH, MorlockL, WuAW. Do hospitals support second victims? Collective insights from patient safety leaders in Maryland. Jt Comm J Qual Patient Saf, 2017; 43(9):471-483.
52.
KlattTE, SachsJF, HuangCC, PilarskiAM. Building a program of expanded peer support for the entire health care team: no one left behind. Jt Comm J Qual Patient Saf, 2021; 47(12):759-767.
53.
TorbensonVE, RigganKA, WeaverAL, LongME, FinneyRE, AllyseMA, et al. Second victim experience among OBGYN trainees: what is their desired form of support?. South Med J, 2021; 114(4):218-222.
54.
van PeltF. Peer support: health care professionals supporting each other after adverse medical events. Qual Saf Health Care, 2008; 17(4):249-252.
55.
HanS, ShanafeltTD, SinskyCA, AwadKM, DyrbyeLN, FiscusLC, et al. Estimating the attributable cost of physician burnout in the United States. Ann Intern Med, 2019; 170(11):784-790.
56.
MoranD, WuAW, ConnorsC, ChappidiMR, SreedharaSK, SelterJH, et al. Cost-benefit analysis of a support program for nursing staff. J Patient Saf, 2020; 16(4):e250-e254.
57.
BlatterM, MuehlemannS, SchenkerS. The costs of hiring skilled workers. Eur Econ Rev, 2012; 56(1):20-35.
58.
ZhangX, LiQ, GuoY, LeeSY. From organizational support to second victim-related distress: Role of patient safety culture. J Nurs Manag, 2019; 27(8):1818-1825.
59.
LaneMA, NewmanBM, TaylorMZ, O’NeillM, GhettiC, WoltmanRM, et al. Supporting clinicians after adverse events: development of a clinician peer support program. J Patient Saf, 2018; 14(3):e56-e60.
60.
MerandiJ, LiaoN, LeweD, MorvayS, StewartB, CattC, et al. Deployment of a second victim peer support program: a replication study. Pediatr Qual Saf, 2017; 2(4):e031.
61.
MokWQ, ChinGF, YapSF, WangW. A cross-sectional survey on nurses’ second victim experience and quality of support resources in Singapore. J Nurs Manag, 2020; 28(2):286-293.
62.
ShapiroJ, GalowitzP. Peer support for clinicians: a programmatic approach. Acad Med, 2016; 91(9):1200-1204.
