Are Health Risks Related to Medical Care Charges in the Short-Term? Challenging Traditional Assumptions

Abstract

Purpose.

This study examines the association between self-reported health risks and short-term use of medical resources.

Design.

Cross-sectional study comparing responses from a mailed survey with medical encounter and expenditure data. Bivariate analyses and multivariate linear and logistic regressions controlling for age, gender, and health status were conducted to illustrate the relationship between selected risk factors and resource use.

Setting.

A group network model health maintenance organization (HMO) in Minneapolis, Minnesota.

Subjects.

The study population was comprised of a randomly selected sample of nonsenior adults (18 to 64 years old, n = 3825) and seniors (65 years and older, n = 1955) who were enrolled in an HMO. The response rate was 72%.

Measures.

Five independent variables: smoking alcohol use, obesity, lack of physical activity, and unhappiness were derived from a questionnaire designed to assess health status and health risks. Outcome measures were medical care charges and use of hospital services.

Results.

Obesity, physical inactivity, and unhappiness were related to higher charges among seniors. These relationships dissipated to some degree after controlling for age, gender, and health status. Unexpected differences were found for alcohol use among both age groups, with those considered to be “not at risk” accruing higher charges and demonstrating a higher likelihood of using inpatient hospital services than those defined to be at risk.

Conclusions.

Bivariate and multivariate regression results demonstrated that traditional risk factors are weak and inconsistent predictors of short-term medical charges. Charging smokers and other high risk individuals a higher annual insurance premium than is offered for those at low risk raises questions about fairness when such risk factors are not necessarily good predictors of short-term resource use. The rationale for insurance cost-shifting should be supported with reliable data connecting risks to charges.

Keywords

Health Behavior Risk Factors Medical Charges Health Maintenance Organizations

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Last

. Public Health and Preventive Medicine. 11th ed. Norwalk, Connecticut: Appleton-Century-Croft, 1980.

McGinnis

Foege

. Actual causes of death in the United States. JAMA. 1993;270: 2207–12.

Sciacca

Seehafer

Reed

. The impact of participation in health promotion on medical costs: A reconsideration of the Blue Cross and Blue Shield of Indiana study. Am J Health Promot 1993;7:374–83, 395.

Warner

. Wellness at the worksite. Health Affairs 1990;9:63–79.

Light

. The practice and ethics of risk-rated health insurance. JAMA 1992;267:2503–8.

Terry

. A case for no-fault health insurance: From the “worried well” to the “guilty ill.” Am J Health Promot 1994;8:165–8.

Stokes

. Why not rate health and life insurance premiums by risks? N Engl J Med 1983; 308:393–5.

Leigh

Fries

. Health habits, health care use and costs in a sample of retirees. Inquiry 1992;29:44–54.

Anderson

Brink

. Health Risks and Behavior: The Impact on Medical Costs. Brookfield, Wisconsin: Milliman and Robertson, Inc., 1993:1–24.

10.

Foote

Erfurt

. The benefit to cost ratio of work-site blood pressure control programs. JAMA 1991;265:1283–6.

11.

Erfurt

Foote

Heirich

. The cost-effectiveness of work-site wellness programs for hypertension control, weight loss, and smoking cessation. J Occup Med 1991;33:962–70.

12.

Bertera

. The effects of workplace health promotion on absenteeism and employment costs in a large industrial population. Am J Public Health 1990;80:1101–5.

13.

Leutzinger

Goetzel

Richling

. Projecting the impact of health promotion on medical costs. Business Health 1993;11:38–44.

14.

Wagner

Curry

Grothaus

. The impact of smoking and quitting on health care use. Arch Intern Med 1995;155:1789–95.

15.

Baun

Bernack

Tsai

. A preliminary investigation: Effect of a corporate fitness program on absenteeism and health care cost. J Occup Med 1986;28:18–22.

16.

Bertera

. Behavioral risk factor and illness day changes with workplace health promotion: Two-year results. Am J Health Promot 1993;7:365–73.

17.

Burton

Eggum

Keller

. “High-cost” employees in an occupational alcoholism program. J Occup Med 1981;23:259–62.

18.

Fries

Parcell

. Health risk changes with a low-cost individualized health promotion program: Effects at up to 30 months. Am J Health Promot 1992;6:364–71.

19.

Bly

Jones

Richardson

. Impact of worksite health promotion on health care costs and utilization. JAMA 1986;256:3235–40.

20.

Golaszewski

Snow

Lynch

. A benefit-to-cost analysis of a work-site health promotion program. J Occup Med 1992;34: 1164–72.

21.

Logan

Milne

Achber

. Cost-effectiveness of a worksite hypertension treatment program. Hypertension 1981;3:211–8.

22.

Pelletier

. A review and analysis of the health and cost-effective outcome studies of comprehensive health promotion and disease prevention programs at the worksite: 1991–1993 update. Am J Health Promot 1993;8:50–62.

23.

Windsor

Lowe

Perkins

. Health education for pregnant smokers: Its behavioral impact and cost benefit. Am J Public Health 1993;83:201–6.

24.

Opatz

Chenoweth

Kaman

. Economic impact of worksite health promotion. In: Proceedings of the “Economic Impact of Worksite Health Promotion” Conference. May 1990, Fort Worth. Indianapolis: Association for Fitness in Business, 1990.

25.

Lynch

Gilfillan

Jennett

. Health risks and health insurance claims costs: Results for health hazard appraisal responders and nonresponders. J Occup Med 1993;35:28–33.

26.

Yen

Edington

Witting

. Prediction of prospective medical claims and absenteeism costs for 1284 hourly workers from a manufacturing company. J Occup Med 1992; 34:428–35.

27.

Schauffler

Howland

Cobb

. Using Chronic Disease Risk Factors to Adjust Medicare Capitation Payments. Report prepared under NCHSR Grant HS 06113–01, 1990.

28.

Fowles

Weiner

Knutson

. Taking health status into account when setting capitation rates: A comparison of risk-adjustment methods. JAMA 1996;276:1316–21.

29.

Wright

Harwood

Coulter

. Health and Lifestyles in the Oxford Region. Oxford, England: Horgan Print Partnership, 1992.

30.

Dwyer

. Policy and healthy weight. Am J Clin Nutr 1996;63(Suppl.):415S–8S.

31.

Manning

Keeler

Newhouse

. The Costs of Poor Health Habits. Cambridge, Massachusetts: Harvard University Press, 1991.

32.

McHorney

Ware

Rogers

. The validity and relative precision of MOS short-and long-form health status scales and Dartmouth COOP charts: Results from the Medical Outcomes Study. Med Care 1992; 30(Suppl.):MS253–65.

33.

McHorney

Ware

Raczek

. The MOS 36-Item Short-Form Health Survey (SF-36): II. Psychometric and clinical tests of validity in measuring physical and mental health constructs. Med Care 1993;31: 247–63.

34.

Ware

Sherbourne

. The MOS 36-Item Short-Form Health Survey (SF-36): I. Conceptual framework and item selection. Med Care 1992;30:473–83.

35.

Howland

Stokes

Crane

. Adjusting capitation using chronic disease risk factors: A preliminary study. Health Care Finance Rev 1987;9:15–23.

36.

Schauffler

D'Agostino

Kannel

. Risk for cardiovascular disease in the elderly and associated Medicare costs: The Framingham Study. Am J Prev Med 1993;9:146–54.

37.

Bowne

Russell

Morgan

. Reduced disability and health care costs in an industrial fitness program. J Occup Med 1984;26:809–16.

38.

Patton

. Work-site health promotion: An economic model. J Occup Med 1991;33:868–73.

39.

Fuhrman

Lavy

Aviram

. Consumption of red wine with meals reduces the susceptibility of human plasma and low-density lipo-protein to lipid peroxidation. Am J Clin Nutr 1995;61:549–54.

40.

Newhouse

Manning

Keeler

. Adjusting capitation rates using objective health measures and prior utilization. Health Care Finance Rev 1989;10:41–54.

41.

Dowd

Feldman

. Insurer competition and protection from risk redefinition in the individual and small group health insurance market. Inquiry 1992;29:148–57.

42.

Yen

Edington

Witting

. Associations between health risk appraisal scores and employee medical claims costs in a manufacturing company. Am J Health Promot 1991;6:46–54.

43.

Wachtel

. The connection between health promotion and health-care costs: Does it matter? Am J Med 1993;94:451–4.

44.

Kelsey

Thompson

Evans

. Methods in Observational Epidemiology. New York: Oxford University Press, 1986.