Collectors of Natural Knowledge: The Edinburgh Medical Society and the Associational Culture of Scotland and the North Atlantic World in the 18Th Century
Available accessOtherFirst published online June, 2018
Collectors of Natural Knowledge: The Edinburgh Medical Society and the Associational Culture of Scotland and the North Atlantic World in the 18Th Century
This paper reappraises the role of medical clubs and societies in the production and consumption of knowledge in 18th-century Scotland and the wider North Atlantic world. It focuses on the Edinburgh Medical Society, founded in 1731 by Alexander Monro primus; and on the student Medical Society, founded in 1734 and constituted in 1737 as the Medical Society of Edinburgh, ultimately becoming the Royal Medical Society of Edinburgh in 1778. The paper examines how Monro, as editor of the transactions of the Edinburgh Medical Society, sought to adapt medical learning to a world of polite sociability; and how that world came under pressure in the student Medical Society, where prevailing orthodoxies, such as the system of Herman Boerhaave and, later, William Cullen, were challenged. In the febrile atmosphere of the 1790s, William Thomson accused the Royal Medical Society of Edinburgh of promoting visionary theories and abandoning the proper experimental method in medical science. Yet with its overarching commitment to the sceptical and empirical principles laid down by the Royal Society of London (founded in 1660), the Royal Medical Society of Edinburgh provided a model for the establishment of similar clubs and societies on both sides of the Atlantic.
McElroyDD. Scotland's Age of Improvement: A Survey of Eighteenth-Century Literary Clubs and Societies. Pullman: Washington State University Press; 1969.
2.
PhillipsonN. Hume as Moralist: A Social Historian's Perspective. In: BrownSC, editor. Philosophers of the Enlightenment. Brighton: Harvester Press; 1979. p.140–61.
3.
PhillipsonN. Adam Smith as Civic Moralist. In: HontI, IgnatieffM, editors. Wealth and Virtue: The Shaping of Political Economy in the Scottish Enlightenment. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press; 1983. p.179–202.
4.
EmersonRL. The Philosophical Society of Edinburgh, 1737–1747. Br J Hist Sci1979; 12: 154–91.
5.
EmersonRL. The Philosophical Society of Edinburgh, 1748–1768. Br J Hist Sci1981; 14: 133–76.
6.
EmersonRL. The Philosophical Society of Edinburgh, 1768–1783. Br J Hist Sci1985; 18: 255–303.
7.
EmersonRL. The Scottish Enlightenment and the End of the Philosophical Society of Edinburgh. Br J Hist Sci1988; 21: 33–66.
8.
ClarkP. British Clubs and Societies 1580–1800: The Origins of an Associational World. Oxford: Oxford University Press; 2000.
9.
MeeJ. Conversable Worlds: Literature, Contention, and Community 1762 to 1830. Oxford: Oxford University Press; 2011.
10.
BroadieA. Introduction: What was the Scottish Enlightenment? In: BroadieA, editor. The Scottish Enlightenment: An Anthology. Edinburgh: Canongate Classics; 1997. p. 3–31.
11.
JenkinsonJ. Scottish Medical Societies 1731–1939: Their History and Records. Edinburgh: Edinburgh University Press; 1993.
12.
EmersonRL, WoodP. Science and Enlightenment in Glasgow, 1690–1802. In: WithersCWJ, WoodP, editors. Science and Medicine in the Scottish Enlightenment. East Linton: Tuckwell Press; 2002. p.79–142.
13.
ErlanHD. Alexander Monro, primus. University of Edinburgh Journal1954; 17: 77–105.
14.
GrayJ. History of the Royal Medical Society 1737–1937. Edinburgh: Edinburgh University Press; 1952. p. 2,25.
15.
ShapinS. The Audience for Science in Eighteenth-Century Edinburgh. History of Science1974; 12: 95–121.
16.
[MonroA.] Medical Essays and Observations, Revised and Published by a Society in Edinburgh. 5 vols in 6 (vol. 5 in 2 parts). Edinburgh: Ruddimans, 1733–44; 2: iii–iv (p. iii) (The Preface).
17.
PrestonC. The Poetics of Scientific Investigation in Seventeenth-Century England. Oxford: Oxford University Press; 2015. p. 78.
18.
SmithPH, SchmidtB. Introduction: Knowledge and Its Making in Early Modern Europe. In: SmithPH, SchmidtB, editors. Making Knowledge in Early Modern Europe: Practices, Objects, and Texts, 1400–1800. Chicago: University of Chicago Press; 2007. p.1–16.
19.
[MonroA.] Medical Essays. 1: iii–iv (Dedication).
20.
SwannM. Curiosities and Texts: The Culture of Collecting in Early Modern England. Philadelphia: University of Pennsylvania Press; 2001. p. 81–90.
21.
HansonCA. The English Virtuoso: Art, Medicine, and Antiquarianism in the Age of Empiricism. Chicago and London: University of Chicago Press; 2009.
22.
UnderwoodEA. Boerhaave's Men: At Leyden and After. Edinburgh: Edinburgh University Press; 1977.
23.
GoslingsWRO. Leiden and Edinburgh: The Seed, the Soil and the Climate. In: AndersonRGW, SimpsonADC, editors. The Early Years of the Edinburgh Medical School. Edinburgh: Royal Scottish Museum; 1976. p.1–18.
24.
SwanC. Making Sense of Medical Collections in Early Modern Holland: The Uses of Wonder. In: SmithPH, SchmidtB, editors. Making Knowledge in Early Modern Europe: Practices, Objects, and Texts, 1400–1800. Chicago and London: University of Chicago Press; 2007. p.199–213.
25.
HuismanT. The Finger of God: Anatomical Practice in 17th-century Leiden. Leiden: Primavera Press; 2009.
26.
LawrenceC. Alexander Monro primus and the Edinburgh Manner of Anatomy. Bull Hist Med1988; 62: 193–214.
27.
AlbertiSJMM. A History of Edinburgh's Medical Museums. J R Coll Physicians Edinb2016; 46: 187–97.
28.
[Anon.] An Essay on Mr. Garengeot's good Manners and universal Learning, inscrib'd to the Memory of Dr. Friend [sic], by Prentice to a Surgeon Apothecary in Edinburgh. In: [Monro A, editor.] Medical Essays. 1: 242–57.
29.
MonroA. Remarks on the Articulation, Muscles and Luxation of the Lower Jaw, In: [Monro A, editor.] Medical Essays1: 124–56 (insert to p. 156).
30.
RockJ. Richard Cooper Sr and Scottish Book Illustration. In: BrownSW, McdougallW, editors. The Edinburgh History of the Book in Scotland: Volume 2: Enlightenment and Expansion 1707–1800. Edinburgh: Edinburgh University Press; 2012. p.81–90.
31.
HansenJV. Resurrecting Death: Anatomical Art in the Cabinet of Dr. Frederik Ruysch. Art Bulletin1996; 78: 663–79.
[MonroA.] Medical Essays and Observations: Revised and Published by a Society in Edinburgh. 2nd ed, corrected, 5 vols in 6 (Edinburgh: Ruddimans, 1737–44), 2: iii–iv (p. iii) (The Preface).
34.
PorterfieldW. An Essay concerning the Motions of Our Eyes. In: [Monro A, editor.] Medical Essays3: 160–262; 4:124–294.
35.
WrightJP. Materialism and the Life Soul in Eighteenth-Century Scottish Physiology. In: WoodP, editor. The Scottish Enlightenment: Essays in Reinterpretation. Rochester: University of Rochester Press; 2000. p.177–97.
36.
CampbellN, SmellieRMS. The Royal Society of Edinburgh (1783–1983): The First Two Hundred Years. Edinburgh: The Society; 1983.
37.
WoodP. Introduction. In: Essays and Observations, Physical and Literary. Reprint edition: Bristol: Thoemmes Press; 2002(Edinburgh: Hamilton and Balfour, 1754–71). p. v–xvii.
38.
[Anon.] Article VII. Bibliothèque raisonée des ouvrages des savans de l'Europe 1739. 20: 451–78.
39.
SmellieW. A Life of the Celebrated Dr Monro, Late Professor of Anatomy in the College of Edinburgh. Edinburgh Magazine and Review1774; 1: 302–306, 337–43.
40.
PettigrewTJ. Memoirs of the Life and Writings of the Late John Coakley Lettsom. 3 vols. London: Longman, 1817. 3: 289,290.
41.
National Register of Archives (Scotland): Royal Medical Society of Edinburgh, NRA(S)/3882
42.
KaufmanMH. Medical Teaching in Edinburgh during the 18th and 19th Centuries. Edinburgh: Royal College of Surgeons of Edinburgh; 2003. p. 153–63.
43.
Minutes of the Royal Medical Society of Edinburgh, 4 August 1778; cited in [Stroud W]. History of the Medical Society of Edinburgh. In: List of Members, Laws, and Library Catalogue of the Medical Society of Edinburgh. Edinburgh: William Aitken; 1820. p. iii–ci (p. xviii).
44.
FothergillJ. The Works of John Fothergill, M.D. [.] With Some Account of His Life. By Coakley LettsomJohn. London: Dilly; 1784. p. 425–38.
45.
RushBenjamin. In: Laws and List of the Members of the Medical Society of Edinburgh. Edinburgh: William Smellie; 1788. p. 74.
46.
HookH. Scotland and America: A Study of Cultural Relations 1750– 1835. Glasgow and London: Blackie; 1975, p. 22.
47.
FranklinBenjamin. In: Laws and List of the Members of the Medical Society of Edinburgh. Edinburgh: William Smellie; 1788. p. 108.
48.
BlaneG. Address to the Medical Society of Students at Edinburgh, Upon Laying the Foundation of their Hall, April 21st 1775. In: A Short Account of the Commencement, Progress, and Present State, of the Buildings Belonging to the Royal Medical Society of Edinburgh. Edinburgh: Neill; 1819. p. 21–32.
49.
National Register of Archives (Scotland): Royal Medical Society Edinburgh: NRA(S)/3882/5/1, 3882/5/2, 3882/5/3, 3882/5/8, 3882/5/9, 3882/5/10, 3882/5/15. The surviving manuscript dissertations date back to 1751.
50.
ChristieJ. Edinburgh Medicine in the Eighteenth Century: The View from the Students. Bull Soc Social Hist Med1976; 19: 13–5.
51.
DuncanA. Introductory Address to the Medical Society of Students at Edinburgh Read 2d of November 1771. In: A Short Account of the Commencement, Progress, and Present State, of the Buildings Belonging to the Royal Medical Society of Edinburgh. Edinburgh: Neill; 1819. p. 5–19.
52.
LawrenceC. Medicine as Culture: Edinburgh and the Scottish Enlightenment. Unpublished PhD thesis, University College London; 1984.
53.
[DuncanA Medical and Philosophical Commentaries. By a Society in Edinburgh. 20 vols. London: Murray; 1773–95 (title pages vary [v.7 onwards entitled Medical Commentaries]).
54.
ChalmersI, TröhlerU, ChalmersJ. Medical and Philosophical Commentaries and its Successors. In: ChalmersJ, editor. Andrew Duncan Senior, Physician of the Enlightenment. Edinburgh: National Museums Scotland; 2010. p.36–55.
55.
BrownSW. William Smellie: A Printer's Life. In: BrownSW, McDougallW, editors. The Edinburgh History of the Book in Scotland: Volume 2: Enlightenment and Expansion 1707–1800. Edinburgh: Edinburgh University Press; 2012. p.52–60.
56.
RisseGB. The Royal Medical Society versus Campbell Denovan: Brunonianism, The Press, and the Medical Establishment. In: New Medical Challenges During the Scottish Enlightenment. Amsterdam: Rodopi; 2005. p. 105–32.
57.
PercivalT. Medical Ethics: or, A Code of Institutes and Precepts, Adapted to the Professional Conduct of Physicians and Surgeons. Manchester: Russell; 1803.
58.
[ThomsonW.] Prospects and Observations; on a Tour in England and Scotland: Natural, Oeconomical, and Literary. By Thomas Newte, Esq. London: Robinson; 1791. p.365–66.
59.
SimpsonD. Romanticism, Nationalism, and the Revolt against Theory. Chicago and London: University of Chicago Press; 1993.
60.
WodrowR. Analecta; or, Materials for a History of Remarkable Providences; Mostly Relating to Scotch Ministers and Christians. 4 vols. Edinburgh: Printed for the Maitland Club; 1842–43. 3: 183.
61.
JohnsonJ. A Guide for Gentlemen Studying Medicine at the University of Edinburgh. London: Robinson; 1792. p. 53.
62.
BrockCH. Scotland and American Medicine. In: BrockWH. Scotus Americanus: A Survey of the Sources for Links between Scotland and America in the Eighteenth Century. Edinburgh: Edinburgh University Press; 1982. p.114–26.
63.
RendallJ. The Influence of the Edinburgh Medical School on America in the Eighteenth Century. In: AndersonRGW, SimpsonADC. The Early Years of the Edinburgh Medical School. Edinburgh: Royal Scottish Museum; 1976. p.95–124.
64.
MorganJ. A Discourse upon the Institution of Medical Schools in America. Philadelphia: Bradford; 1765. p. 2, p.29.
65.
BruntonDC. The Edinburgh and Philadelphia Medical Schools. In: SherRB, SmittenJR, editors. Scotland and America in the Age of the Enlightenment. Edinburgh: Edinburgh University Press; 1990. p.242–58.
66.
Philadelphia Medical Society to Dr Charles Moore, nd, Gilbert Collection of MSS Letters, III, 289, College of Physicians of Philadelphia; cited in Bell WJ. For Mutual Improvement in the Healing Art: Philadelphia Medical Societies of the 18th Century. JAMA1971; 216: 125–9.
67.
BellWJ. For Mutual Improvement in the Healing Art: Philadelphia Medical Societies of the 18th Century. JAMA1971; 216: 125–9.
68.
HamiltonA. Specimen medicum inaugurale, de morbis ossium ipsam substantiam afficientibus, ex causis internis oriundis (Edinburgh: Ruddiman, 1737). The manuscript thesis is held in Edinburgh University Library (Special Collections, ATT.74.7.1/18).
69.
HamiltonA, author; BridenbaughC. Gentleman's Progress: The Itinerarium of Dr. Alexander Hamilton 1744. Chapel Hill: Published for the Institute of Early American History and Culture, Williamsburg, by the University of North Carolina Press; 1948. p. 131, 132,137.
70.
EmersonRL. Numbering the Medics. In: EmersonRL. Essays on David Hume, Medical Men and the Scottish Enlightenment: ‘Industry, Knowledge and Humanity’. London and New York: Routledge; 2009. p.162–224.
71.
HamiltonA, author; MicklusR. The History of the Ancient and Honorable Tuesday Club. 3 vols. Chapel Hill and London: Published for the Institute of Early American History and Culture, Williamsburg, Virginia, by the University of North Carolina Press; 1990.
72.
BreslawEG. Introduction: In: BreslawEG, editor. Records of the Tuesday Club, ed. Breslaw, Records of the Tuesday Club of Annapolis, 1745–56. Chicago: University of Chicago Press; 1988. p. xiii–xxxii (p. xxi).
73.
BreslawEG. Records of the Tuesday Club. Chicago: University of Chicago Press; 1988. p. 26, 36, 229,447.
74.
ShieldsDS. British-American Belles Lettres. In: BercovitchS, editor. The Cambridge History of American Literature: Volume 1: 1590–1820. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press; 1994. p.309–43.
75.
ButterfieldLH. The Letters of Benjamin Rush. 2 vols. Princeton University Press; 1951. 2: 1038.
76.
DingwallH. The Importance of Being Edinburgh: The Rise and Fall of the Edinburgh Medical School in the Eighteenth Century. In: GrellOP, CunninghamA, ArrizbalagaJ, editors. Centres of Medical Excellence? Medical Travel and Education in Europe, 1500–1789. Farnham: Ashgate; 2010. p.305–24.
77.
[MudieR.] The Modern Athens: A Dissection and Demonstration of Men and Things in the Scottish Capital. By a Modern Greek. London: Knight and Lacey; 1825. p.221.
78.
[SmellieW.] A Life of the Celebrated Dr Monro, Late Professor of Anatomy in the College of Edinburgh. In: Edinburgh Magazine and Review 1 (March and April 1774), 302–306, 337–43.
