The Future of Electricity (and Gas) Regulation in a Low-carbon Policy World

Abstract

This paper discusses whether a new paradigm is necessary for independent economic regulation of electricity (and closely associated natural gas) systems. We begin by summarizing the nature of the traditional model of electricity reform and the place of economic regulation within it. Next we outline the drivers for changing the current model of electricity regulation, namely, the maturity of the existing model, the reality of changing circumstances, and the coming of age of climate change concern. We go on to discuss the premises on which a new model of regulation should be based. These are: remembering the successes of the current system of regulation; a new focus on processes not just outcomes; a recognition of the economics of climate change; and the appropriate management of uncertainty. We then highlight the key elements of a new model for regulation: new processes of regulation; new models of competition and the issues raised by a focus on climate change. The paper draws heavily on the experience of the UK, but has direct implications for the rest of the European Union countries and for other countries whose regulatory systems mirror them.

Keywords

Electricity markets Natural gas markets Regulation UK Europe uncertainty Climate change

References

BERR (2007a). The UK Fuel Poverty Strategy: 5thAnnual Progress Report. London: BERR and DE-FRA.

BERR (2007b). Severn Tidal Power Q & A. London: Department for Business Enterprise and Regulatory Reform. Available at http://www.berr.gov.uk/files/file43809.pdf

BERR (2007c). Digest of UK Energy Statistics. London: Department for Business Enterprise and Regulatory Reform.

BERR (2008). Digest of UK Energy Statistics. London: Department of Business Enterprise and Regulatory Reform.

Brophy Haney

Jamasb

Pollitt

, (2008). “Smart Metering and Electricity Demand: Technologies, Economics and International Experience.” EPRG Working Paper series, forthcoming.

Buchanan

(2008). “Ofgem’s ‘RPI at 20’ project”, Speech to SGBI Conference, 6 March 2008. Available at www.ofgem.gov.uk

Bush

, (2007). “Some Issues in Airport Regulation”, Presentation at Hertford Seminars in Regulation, 11 May 2007.

CAA (2008a). CAA Statement on the process for the remaining stages of the Review of Heathrow and Gatwick Price Controls. January, London: CAA.

CAA (2008b). Economic Regulation of Heathrow and Gatwick Airports, CAA Decision, 11 March 2008. London: CAA.

10.

CAA (2005). Airport Regulation: The Process for Constructive Engagement. London: Civil Aviation Authority.

11.

Carbon Trust (2004). The European Emissions Trading Scheme: implications for industrial competitiveness. London: Carbon Trust.

12.

Cronin

Garnsey

(2007). “Daylight Saving in GB; Is there evidence in favor of clock time on GMT?” 19 October 2007, mimeo.

13.

Dasgupta

(2007). “Commentary: The Stern Review’s economics of climate change”, National Institute Economic Review, 199: 4-7.

14.

DEFRA (2007). UK Energy Efficiency Action Plan 2007. London: DEFRA.

15.

Devine-Wright

, (2006). “Prospects for Smart Metering in the UK.” In Ja-mash

Pollitt

M.G.

Nuttall

W.J.

, (eds.) Future Electricity Technologies and Systems. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, pp. 403-17.

16.

Domah

P.D.

Pollitt

M.G.

, (2001). “Restructuring and privatization of electricity distribution and supply businesses in England and Wales: a social cost-benefit analysis”, Fiscal Studies, 22(1):107-146.

17.

Doucet

Littlechild

S.C.

, (2006). “Negotiated settlements and the National Energy Board in Canada.” Electricity Policy Research Group Working Paper No. EPRG 06/29.

18.

Egenhofer

(2007). “Looking for the Cure-all. Targets and the EU’s New Energy Strategy.” CEPS Policy Brief, No.118.

19.

Evans

(2008). “Social Project Appraisal and Discounting for the Very Long Term.” Economic Issues, 13(1): 61-70.

20.

Elders

Ault

Galloway

McDonald

Kohler

Leach

Enteric

, (2006). “Electricity network scenarios for the United Kingdom in 2050.” In Jamasb

Nuttall

W.J.

Pol-litt

M.G.

(eds.), Future Electricity Technologies and Systems. Cambridge: Cambridge: University Press. pp.24-79.

21.

European Commission (2007). DG Competition Report on Energy Sector Inquiry. Brussels: European Commission.

22.

European Commission (2008). Draft Directive of the European Parliament and of the Council on the promotion of the use of energy from renewable sources. Brussels: European Commission available at http://ec.europa.eu/energy/climate_actions/doc/2008_res_directive_en.pdf

23.

Foreman-Peck

(2003). “Review of The Rise and Fall of State-Owned Enterprise in the Western World by Pier Angelo Toninelli.” Journal of Economic Literature, 41(3): 931-932.

24.

Glaesar

E.L.

(2001). “Public Ownership in the American City.” NBER Working Papers, No.8613.

25.

Greater London Authority (2007). Action Today to Protect Tomorrow: The Mayor's Climate Change Action Plan. London: Greater London Authority.

26.

Green

Lorenzoni

Perez

Pollitt

(2006). “Benchmarking electricity liberalization in Europe.” Electricity Policy Research Group Working Papers, No. EPRG 0609.

27.

Grubb

Jamasb

Pollitt

(eds.) (2008). Delivering a low carbon electricity system. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

28.

Helm

(2005). A new British Energy Policy. London: Social Market Foundation.

29.

Hope

Newbery

(2007). “Calculating the Social Cost of Carbon”, Electricity Policy Research Group Working Papers, No. EPRG 0720.

30.

IPCC (2007). Climate Change 2007: Synthesis Report. Contribution of Working Groups I, II and III to the Fourth Assessment Report of the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change. [Core Writing Team, Pachauri, R.K and Reisinger, A. (eds.)] IPCC, Geneva, Switzerland.

31.

Jamasb

Pollitt

(2005). “Electricity market reform in the European Union: review of progress toward liberalization and integration.” The Energy Journal, 26(Special Issue): 11-41.

32.

Jamasb

Pollitt

(2007). “Incentive regulation of electricity distribution networks: lessons of experience from Britain.” Energy Policy, 35(12): 6163-6187.

33.

Jamasb

Pollitt

(2008). “Deregulation and R&D in Network Industries: The Case of the Electricity Industry.” Research Policy, 37: 995-1008.

34.

Joskow

P.L.

(2008). “Lessons Learned from Electricity Market Liberalization.” The Energy Journal, this issue.

35.

Larsen

Pedersen

L.H.

Sorensen

E.M.

Olsen

O.J.

(2005). “Independent Regulatory Authorities in Europe.” Presented to SESSA Conference on Regulation, Bergen, March.

36.

Littlechild

S.C.

(2006). “Foreword: the market versus regulation.” In Sioshansi

Pfaffen-berger

(eds.): Electricity market reform: an international perspective. Oxford: Elsevier: xvii-xxix.

37.

Littlechild

S.C.

(2007). “Bird in hand: stipulated settlements and electricity regulation in Florida,” Electricity Policy Research Group Working Papers, No. 0705.

38.

Littlechild

S.C.

Ponzano

E.A.

(2008). “Transmission Expansion in Argentina 5: the Regional Electricity Forum of Buenos Aires province.” Energy Economics, 30(4): 1491-1526.

39.

Littlechild

S.C.

Skerk

C.J.

(2008). “Transmission Expansion in Argentina 1: the origins of policy”, Energy Economics, 30(4):1367-1384.

40.

London Energy Partnership (2007). Making ESCOs Work: Guidance and Advice on Setting Up & Delivering an ESCO. London: Greater London Authority.

41.

Maugis

Nuttall

(2008). “Metapolicy Options for Energy in England.” EPRG Working Paper series, forthcoming.

42.

Millward

Ward

(1993). “From Private to Public Ownership of Gas Undertakings in England and Wales, 1851-1947: Chronology, Incidence and Causes.” Business History, 35(3):1-21.

43.

Newbery

(2006). “Electricity liberalization in Britain and the evolution of market design”, in Sioshansi

F.P.

Pfaffenberger

(eds.) Electricity Market Reform: An International Perspective, Oxford: Elsevier. pp.109-44.

44.

Newbery

D.M.G.

Pollitt

M.G.

(1997). “The restructuring and privatization of Britain’s CEGB: was it worth it?” Journal of Industrial Economics, 45(3): 269-303.

45.

Nordhaus

(2007). “A Review of the Stern Review on the Economics of Climate Change.” Journal of Economic Literature, 45(September): 686-702.

46.

Ofcom (2007). The Communications Market 2007. London: Ofcom.

47.

Ofgem (2007a). Gas Distribution Price Control Review: Final Proposals. London: Ofgem.

48.

Ofgem (2007b). Renewables Obligation - Annual Report 2006-07. London: Ofgem.

49.

Ofgem (2006). Transmission Price Control: Final Proposals. London: Ofgem.

50.

Ofgem (2004). Electricity Distribution Price Control Review: Final Proposals. London: Ofgem.

51.

Patterson

(2007). Keeping the lights on: Towards sustainable electricity. London: Earthscan.

52.

Pollitt

(1997). “The impact of liberalization on the performance of the electricity supply industry: an international survey.” Journal of Energy Literature, 3(2): 3-31.

53.

Pollitt

(2005). “The role of efficiency estimates in regulatory price reviews: Ofgem’s approach to benchmarking electricity networks.” Utilities Policy, 13(4): 279-288.

54.

Pollitt

(2008a). “Liberalization and Regulation in Electricity Systems: How can we get the balance right?” In Sioshansi

F.P.

(ed.), Competitive Electricity Markets: Design, Implementation and Performance, Oxford: Elsevier, pp. xvii-xxxiv.

55.

Pollitt

(2008b). “The arguments for and against ownership unbundling of energy transmission networks.” Energy Policy, 36(2): 704-713.

56.

Pollitt

Bialek

(2007). “Electricity Network Investment and Regulation For A Low Carbon Future.” Electricity Policy Research Group Working Papers, No. EPRG 0721.

57.

Sustainable Development Commission (2007). Lost in Transmission: The role of Ofgem in a changing climate. London: Sustainable Development Commission.

58.

Reiner

(2008). “A Looming Rhetorical Gap: A Survey Of Public Communications Activities For Carbon Dioxide Capture And Storage Technologies.” Electricity Policy Research Group Working Paper, No. EPRG 0801.

59.

Weitzman

(2007). “A Review of The Stern Review on the Economics of Climate Change.” Journal of Economic Literature, 45(September): 703-724.

60.

Weitzman

(2008). “On Modeling and Interpreting the Economics of Catastrophic Climate Change.” mimeo, available at http://www.economics.harvard.edu/faculty/weitzman/files/REStatModeling.pdf

61.

Wiltshire

(2006). The UK potential for community heating with combined heat and power. London: Building Research Establishment.

62.

Yago

Atkins

J.P.

Bhattarai

Green

R.J.

Trotter

S.D.

(2008). “Modeling the economic impact of low-carbon electricity.” In Grubb

Jamasb

Pollitt

M.G.

(eds.) Delivering a low carbon electricity system, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, pp. 394-413.