European Carbon Prices and Banking Restrictions: Evidence from Phase I (2005-2007)

Abstract

The price of European Union Allowances (EUAs) has been declining at far lower levels than expected during Phase I (2005-2007). Previous literature identifies among its main explanations over-allocation concerns, early abatement efforts in 2005, and possibly decreasing abatement costs in 2006. We advocate low allowance prices may also be explained by banking restrictions between 2007 and 2008. Based on a Hotelling-CAPM analysis, we provide statistical evidence that the French and Polish decisions to ban banking contribute to the explanation of low EUA Phase I prices. Besides, we provide the first rigorous empirical verification that the cost-of-carry relationship between EUA spot and futures prices for delivery during Phase II does not hold after the enforcement of the inter-period banking restrictions. This situation may be interpreted as a sacrifice of the temporal flexibility offered to industrials in Phase I to correct design inefficiencies, and achieve an efficient price pattern in Phase II.

Keywords

Carbon emissions trading EU ETS Banking Borrowing Hotelling Ellerman-Parsons Ratio

References

Alberola

Chevallier

Cheze

(2008). “Price Drivers and Structural Breaks in European Carbon Prices 2005-2007”. Energy Policy 36(2): 787-797.

Bessembinder

Coughenour

J.F.

Seguin

PJ.

Smoller

M. Monroe

(1995). “Mean Reversion in Equilibrium Asset Prices: Evidence from the Futures Term Structure”. The Journal of Finance 5(1): 361-375.

Bosetti

Carraro

M Galeotti

Massetti

Tavoni

(2006). “WITCH: A World Induced Technical Change Hybrid Model”. The Energy Journal Special Issue #2: 13-38.

Bosetti

Carraro

Massetti

(2009). “Banking Permits: Economic Efficiency and Distributional Effects”. Journal of Policy Modeling Special Issue An Economic Model-Based Analysis of Climate and Energy Policy: forthcoming.

Brennan

(1958). “The Supply of Storage”. The American Economic Review 48(1): 50-72.

Cason

T.N.

Gangadharan

(2006). “Emissions Variability in Tradable Permit Markets with Imperfect Enforcement and Banking”. Journal of Economic Behavior and Organization 61(2): 199-216.

Ehrhart

K.M.

Hoppe

Schleich

Seifert

(2005). “The Role of Auctions and Forward Markets in the EU ETS: Counterbalancing the Cost- Inefficiencies of Combining Generous Allocation with a Ban on Banking”. Climate Policy 5: 31-46.

Ellerman

A.D.

Buchner

B.K.

(2008). “Over-Allocation or Abatement? A Preliminary Analysis of the EU ETS Based on the 2005-2006 Emissions Data”. Environmental and Resource Economics 41: 267-287.

Ellerman

A.D.

Montero

J.P.

(2002). “The Temporal Efficiency of SO2 Emissions Trading”. Cambridge MIT Institute Working Paper #13.

10.

Ellerman

A.D.

Montero

J.P.

(2007). “The Efficiency and Robustness of Allowance Banking in the U.S. Acid Rain Program”. The Energy Journal 28(4): 205-233.

11.

Ellerman

A.D.

Joskow

P.L.

Schmalensee

Montero

J.P.

Bailey

(2000). Markets for Clean Air: The US Acid Rain Program. Cambridge University Press, 2nd edn.

12.

Fama

F.F.

French

K.R.

(1987). “Commodity Futures Prices: Some Evidence on Forecast Power, Premiums, and the Theory of Storage”. The Journal of Business 60: 55-73.

13.

Godby

R.W.

Mestelman

Muller

R.A.

Welland

D. (1997). “Emissions Trading with Shares and Coupons when Control of Discharges is Uncertain”. Journal of Environmental Economics and Management 32(3): 359-381.

14.

Heal

(2007). “A Celebration of Environmental and Resource Economics”. Review of Environmental Economics and Policy 1: 7-24.

15.

Helfand

G.E.

Moore

M.R.

Liu

(2006). “Testing for dynamic efficiency of the Sulfur Dioxide Allowance Market”. Working Paper, University of Michigan.

16.

Hotelling

(1931). “The Economics of Exhaustible Resources”. Journal of Political Economy 39: 137-175.

17.

Kling

Rubin

(1997). “Bankable Permits for the Control of Environmental Pollution”. Journal of Public Economics 64: 101-115.

18.

Kronenberg

(2006). “Should we worry about the failure of the Hotelling rule?” Working Paper, Maastricht University.

19.

Lee

Strazicich

M.C.

(2001). “Testing the Null of Stationarity in the Presence of a Structural Break”. Applied Economics Letters 8: 377-382.

20.

Lee

Strazicich

M.C.

(2003). “Minimum LM Unit Root Test with Two Structural Breaks”. Review of Economics and Statistics 85(4): 1082-1089.

21.

Leiby

Rubin

(2001). “Intertemporal Permit Trading for the Control of Greenhouse Gas Emissions”. Environmental and Resource Economics 19: 229-256.

22.

Liski

Montero

J.P.

(2006). “On Pollution Permit Banking and Market Power”. Journal of Regulatory Economics 29(3): 283-302.

23.

Maeda

(2004). “Impact of Banking and Forward Contracts on Tradable Permit Markets”. Environmental Economics and Policy Studies 6: 81-102.

24.

Mansanet-Bataller

Pardo

Valor

(2007). “CO2 Prices, Energy and Weather”. The Energy Journal 28(3): 67-86.

25.

Pindyck

R.S.

(1993). “The Present Value Model of Rational Commodity Pricing”. The Economic Journal 103: 511-530.

26.

Rubin

(1996). “A model of Intertemporal Emission Trading, Banking, and Borrowing”. Journal of Environmental Economics and Management 31: 269-286.

27.

Schennach

S.M.

(2000). “The Economics of Pollution Permit Banking in the Context of Title IV of the 1990 Clean Air Act Amendments”. Journal of Environmental Economics and Management 40: 189-210.

28.

Schleich

Ehrhart

K.M.

Hoppe

Seifert

(2006). “Banning Banking in EU Emissions Trading?” Energy Policy 34(1): 112-120.

29.

Slade

M.E.

Thille

(1997). “Hotelling Confronts CAPM: A Test of the Theory of Exhaustible Resources”. The Canadian Journal of Economics 30(3): 685-708.

30.

Working

(1949). “The Theory of the Price of Storage”. The American Economic Review 39, 1254-1262.