A Dynamic Incentive Mechanism for Transmission Expansion in Electricity Networks: Theory,Modeling,and Application

Abstract

We propose a price-cap mechanism for electricity-transmission expansion based on redefining transmission output in terms of financial transmission rights. Our mechanism applies the incentive-regulation logic of rebalancing a two-part tariff. First, we test this mechanism in a three-node network. We show that the mechanism intertemporally promotes an investment pattern that relieves congestion, increases welfare, augments the Transco’sprofits, and induces convergence of prices to marginal costs. We then apply the mechanism to a grid of northwestern Europe and show a gradual convergence toward a common-price benchmark, an increase in total capacity, and convergence toward the welfare optimum.

Keywords

Electricity transmission expansion incentive regulation

References

Bertoletti

Poletti

(1997). “Welfare effects of discriminatory two-part tariffs constrained by price caps.” Econ Let 56: 292-298.

Blumsack

(2006). “Network Topologies and Transmission Investment under Electric Industry Restructuring.” Ph.D. diss., Carnegie Mellon University.

Blumsack

Lave

Ilic

(2007). “A Quantitative Analysis of the Relationship between Congestion and Reliability in Electric Power Networks.” The Energy Journal 28(4):73-100.

Brakelmann

(2004). “Netzverstarkungs-Trassen zur Ubertragung von Windenergie: Freileitung oder Kabel?” Commissioned by Bundesverband WindEnergie e.V.

Brennan

T. J.

(1989). “Regulating by Capping Prices.” Journal of Regulatory Economics 1:133-47.

Brooke

Kendrick

Meeraus

(2008). “GAMS: A User’s Guide.” Washington, DC: GAMS Development Cooperation.

Bushnell

J. B.

Stoft

S. E.

(1996). “Electric Grid Investment under a Contract Network Regime.” Journal of Regulatory Economics 10:61-79.

Bushnell

J. B.

Stoft

S. E.

(1997). “Improving Private Incentives for Electric Grid Investment.” Resource and Energy Economics 19:85-108.

Crew

M. A.

Fernando

C. S.

Kleindorfer

P. R.

(1995). “The Theory of Peak-Load Pricing: A Survey.” Journal of Regulatory Economics 8:215-48.

10.

DENA (2005). Dena-Netzstudie, Energiewirtschaftliche Planung fur die Netzintegration von Windenergie in Deutschland an Land und Offshore bis zum Jahr 2020. Deutsche Energie-Agentur: Koln, Germany.

11.

Dyer

Jim

(2003). “U.S. Department of Energy Transmission Bottleneck Project Report.” Consortium for Electric Reliability Technology Solutions (CERTS).

12.

EC (2007). “Towards a Common Co-Ordinated Regional Congestion Management in Europe.” Con-sentec study commissioned by the European Commission, Directorate-General of Energy and Transport, Aachen, Germany.

13.

Ekelof

(2001). “The Genesis of the Wheatstone Bridge.” Engineering Science and Education Journal 10(1): 37-40.

14.

Fraser

(1995). “The Relationship between the Costs and Prices of a Multi-Product Monopoly: The Role of Price-Cap Regulation.” Journal of Regulatory Economics 8:23-31.

15.

Hogan

(1992). “Contract Networks for Electric Power Transmission.” Journal of Regulatory Economics 4:211-42.

16.

Hogan

(2000). “Flowgate Rights and Wrongs.” Harvard Electricity Policy Group, Harvard University, available at http://www.ksg.harvard.edu/people/whogan.

17.

Hogan

(2002a). “Financial Transmission Right Incentives: Applications beyond Hedging.” Paper presented at the HEPG Twenty-Eighth Plenary Session, May 31, available at http://www.ksg.harvard.edu/people/whogan.

18.

Hogan

(2002b). “Financial Transmission Right Formulations,” Harvard Electricity Policy Group, Harvard University, available at http://ww.ksg.harvard.edu/people/whogan.

19.

Hogan

Rosellon

Vogelsang

(2010). “Toward a Combined Merchant-Regulatory Mechanism for Electricity Transmission Expansion.” Journal of Regulatory Economics, published online on 23 June 2010, DOI 10.1007/s11149-010-9123-2.

20.

Joskow

. (2005). “The Difficult Transition to Competitive Electricity Markets in the U.S.” In Electricity Deregulation: Choices and Challenges. Edited by J. Griffin and S. Puller. University of Chicago Press: Chicago, IL.

21.

Joskow

Tirole

(2002). “Transmission Investment: Alternative Institutional Frameworks.” Conference Proceedings: Wholesale Markets for Electricity, November. 22-23, 2002, Toulouse, France, available at http://www.idei.fr/doc/conf/wme/tirole.pdf.

22.

Joskow

Tirole

(2005). “Merchant Transmission Investment.” The Journal of Industrial Economics 53(2):233.

23.

Kristiansen

Rosellon

(2006). “A Merchant Mechanism for Electricity Transmission Expansion.” Journal of Regulatory Economics 29(2):167-93.

24.

Laffont

J. J.

Tirole

(1996). “Creating Competition through Interconnections: Theory and Practice.” Journal of Regulatory Economics 10:227-256.

25.

Law

P. J.

(1995). Welfare Effects of Pricing in Anticipation of Laspeyres Price Cap Regulation: An Example. Mimeo, Department of Economics, University of Warwick, Coventry, Great Britain.

26.

Leautier

T. O.

(2000). “Regulation of an Electric Power Transmission Company.” The Energy Journal 21(4):61-92.

27.

Lesieutre

Hiskens

and I.

, (2005). “Convexity of the Set of Feasible Injections and Revenue Adequacy in FTR Markets.” IEEE Transactions on Power Systems 20:1790-98.

28.

Loeb

Magat

W. A.

(1979). “A Decentralized Method of Utility Regulation.” Journal of Law and Economics 22, pp.:399-404.

29.

Neu

(1993). “Allocative Inefficiency Properties of Price-Cap Regulation.” Journal of Regulatory Economics 5:159-82.

30.

Neuhoff

Maroeska

J. B.

Bootsc

Ehrenmannd

Hobbs

B. F.

Rijkersf

F. A. M.

Vazquez

(2005). “Network-Constrained Cournot Models of Liberalized Electricity Markets: The Devil Is in the Details.” Energy Economics 27:495-525.

31.

Rosellon

(2007). “A Regulatory Mechanism for Electricity Transmission in Mexico.” Energy Policy 35(5):3003-14.

32.

Rosellon

Vogelsang

Weigt

(2009). “Long-run Cost Functions for Electricity Transmission” Electricity Markets Working Papers WP-EM-36, Social Science Research Network, available at http://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm7abstract_id=1504042).

33.

Sappington

Sibley

(1988). “Regulating without Cost Information: The Incremental Surplus Subsidy Scheme,” International Economic Review 29:297-306.

34.

Schweppe

F. C.

Caramanis

M. C.

Tabors

R. D.

Bohn

R. E.

(1988). Spot Pricing of Electricity. Boston, Massachusetts, Kluwer Academic Publishers.

35.

Stigler

Todem

(2005). “Optimization of the Austrian Electricity Sector (Control Zone of VERBUND APG) under the Constraints of Network Capacities by Nodal Pricing.” Central European Journal of Operations Research 13(2):105-125.

36.

UCTE (2007). “Hourly Load Values of a Specific Country.” Document available at http://www.ucte.org/services/onlinedatabase/consumption.

37.

U.S. Department of Energy (2006). “National Electric Transmission Congestion Study.” U.S. Department of Energy.

38.

VGE (2006). “Yearbook of the European Energy and Raw Materials Industry 2006.” VGE Verlag, Essen, Germany.

39.

Vogelsang

(1989) “Two-part tariffs as regulatory constraints.” Journal of Public Economics 39(1): 45-66.

40.

Vogelsang

(2001). “Price Regulation for Independent Transmission Companies.” Journal of Regulatory Economics 20(2):141-65.