Willingness to Pay for a Climate Backstop: Liquid Fuel Producers and Direct CO 2 Air Capture

Abstract

We conduct a sensitivity analysis to describe conditions under which liquid fuel producers would fund the development of a climate backstop. We estimate (1) the cost to develop competitively priced direct CO₂ air capture technology, a possible climate backstop and (2) the effect of this technology on the value of liquid fuel reserves by country and fuel. Under most assumptions, development costs exceed individual benefits. A particularly robust result is that carbon prices generate large benefits for conventional oil producers—making a climate backstop unappealing for them. Unilateral investment does become more likely under: stringent carbon policy, social discount rates, improved technical outcomes, and high price elasticity of demand for liquid fuels. Early stage investment is inexpensive and could provide a hedge against such developments, particularly for fuels on the margin, such as tar sands and gas-to-liquids. Since only a few entities benefit, free riding is not an important disincentive to investment, although uncertainty about who benefits probably is.

doi: 10.5547/ISSN0195-6574-EJ-Vol33-No1-3

Keywords

Air capture Backstop technology Climate policy Learning by doing R&D Unconventional oil

References

Azar

Lindgren

Obersteiner

Riahi

Van Vuuren

den Elzen

Moellersten

Larson

(2010). “The feasibility of low CO₂ concentration targets and the role of bio-energy with carbon capture and storage (BECCS).” Climatic Change 100(1): 195-202.

Baker

Chon

Keisler

(2009). “Carbon capture and storage: combining economic analysis with expert elicitations to inform climate policy.” Climatic Change 96(3): 379-408.

Barker

Scrieciu

S.S.

(2010). “Modeling Low Climate Stabilization with E3MG: Towards a ‘New Economics’ Approach to Simulating Energy-Environment-Economy System Dynamics.” The Energy Journal 31(SI-1): 137-164.

Barrasso

Bingaman

Enzi

(2009). “Carbon Dioxide Capture Technology Act of 2009 (S.2744).”

Barrett

(2009). “The Coming Global Climate-Technology Revolution.” Journal of Economic Perspectives 23(2): 53-75.

Barrett

(2010). “Climate Treaties and Backstop Technologies.” Cesifo working paper series no. 3003.

Boucher

Folberth

G.A.

(2010). “New Directions: Atmospheric methane removal as a way to mitigate climate change?” Atmospheric Environment 44(27): 3343-3345.

Brandt

A.R.

(2011). “ROMEO model documentation: The Regional Optimization model for Environmental impacts from Oil substitutes.” Technical report, Department of Energy Resources Engineering, Stanford University.

Brandt

A.R.

Farrell

A.E.

(2007). “Scraping the bottom of the barrel: Greenhouse gas emission consequences of a transition to low-quality and synthetic petroleum resources.” Climatic Change 84(3): 241-263.

10.

Brandt

A.R.

Farrell

A.E.

(2008). “Dynamics of the oil transition: modeling capacity, costs, and emissions.” Technical report, Univeristy of California Energy Institute.

11.

Brandt

A.R.

Plevin

R.J.

Farrell

A.E.

(2010). “Dynamics of the oil transition: modeling capacity, depletion, and emissions.” Energy 35(7): 2852-2860.

12.

Caldeira

Keith

D.W.

(2010). “The Need for Climate Engineering Research.” Issues in Science and Technology 27(1): 57-62.

13.

Caldeira

Wood

(2008). “Global and Arctic climate engineering: numerical model studies.” Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society a-Mathematical Physical and Engineering Sciences 366(1882): 4039-4056.

14.

Cao

Caldeira

(2010). “Atmospheric carbon dioxide removal: long-term consequences and commitment.” Environmental Research Letters 5(2): 024011.

15.

Chichilnisky

Eisenberger

(2009). “How air capture could help to promote a Copenhagen solution.” Nature 459(7250): 1053-1053.

16.

Considine

T.J.

Dalton

(2008). “Peak Oil in a Carbon Constrained World.” International Review of Environmental and Resource Economics 1(4): 327-365.

17.

Cooper

J.C.

(2003). “Price elasticity of demand for crude oil: Estimates for 23 countries.” OPEC Review 27(1): 1-8.

18.

Farrell

Plevin

R.J.

Turner

B.T.

Jones

A.D.

O’Hare

Kammen

D.M.

(2006). “Ethanol can contribute to energy and environmenal goals.” Science 311(5760): 506-508.

19.

Fourer

Gay

D.M.

Kernighan

B.W.

(2003). AMPL: A modeling language for mathematical programing. Pacific Grove, CA: Brooks/Cole Thomson Learning, second edition.

20.

Gately

(2002). “The politics of oil-producer cooperation.” The Energy Journal 23(1): 136-138.

21.

Gerard

Wilson

E.J.

(2009). “Environmental bonds and the challenge of long-term carbon sequestration.” Journal of Environmental Management 90(2): 1097-1105.

22.

Gill

Murray

Saunders

(2002). “SNOPT: An SQP algorithm forlarge-scale constrained optimization.” Siam Journal on Optimization 12(4): 979-1006.

23.

Greene

D.L.

Hopson

(2003). “Running out of and into oil: Analyzing global oil depletion and transition through 2050.” Technical Report ORNL/TM-2003/259, Oak Ridge National Laboratory.

24.

Grubler

Nakicenovic

Victor

D.G.

(1999). “Modeling technological change: Implications for the global environment.” Annual Review of Energy and the Environment 24: 545-569.

25.

Haberl

Erb

K.H.

Krausmann

Gaube

Bondeau

Plutzar

Gingrich

Lucht

Fischer-Kowalski

(2007). “Quantifying and mapping the human appropriation of net primary production in earth’s terrestrial ecosystems.” Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences 104(31): 12942-12947.

26.

Herzog

(2003). “Assessing the Feasibility of Capturing CO₂ from the Air.” Working paper, MIT Laboratory for Energy and the Environment.

27.

IEA (2009). World Energy Outlook 2009. Paris: International Energy Agency.

28.

Imhoff

M.L.

Bounoua

Ricketts

Loucks

Harriss

Lawrence

W.T.

(2004). “Global patterns in human consumption of net primary production.” Nature 429(6994): 870-873.

29.

IPCC (2005), IPCC Special Report on Carbon Dioxide Capture and Storage. Prepared by Working Group III of the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

30.

IPCC (2007), Climate Change 2007: Mitigation. Contribution of Working group III to the Fourth Assessment Report of the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

31.

Jaffe

A.B.

Newell

R.G.

Stavins

R.N.

(2005). “A tale of two market failures: Technology and environmental policy.” Ecological Economics 54(2-3): 164-174.

32.

Johansson

D.J.

Azar

Lindgren

Persson

T.A.

(2009). “OPEC Strategies and Oil Rent in a Climate Conscious World.” The Energy Journal 30(3): 23-50.

33.

Keith

Ha-Duong

Stolaroff

(2006). “Climate Strategy with CO₂ Capture from the Air.” Climatic Change 74(1-3): 17-45.

34.

Keith

D.W.

(2009). “Why Capture CO₂ from the Atmosphere?” Science 325(5948): 1654-1655.

35.

Kharecha

Hansen

J.E.

(2008). “Implications of ‘peak oil’ for atmospheric CO₂ and climate.” Global Biogeochemical Cycles 22(GB3012): 10.

36.

Kintisch

(2010). “Asilomar 2 Takes Small Steps Toward Rules for Geoengineering.” Science 328(5974): 22-23.

37.

Knapp

K.E.

(1999). “Exploring energy technology substitution for reducing atmospheric carbon emissions.” The Energy Journal 20(2): 121-143.

38.

Lackner

K.S.

(2010). “Washing carbon out of the air.” Scientific American 302(6): 66-71.

39.

Lackner

K.S.

Grimes

Ziock

H.J.

(1999). “Carbon dioxide extraction from air: is it an option?” In: 24th Annual Technical Conference on Coal Utilization and Fuel Systems. pp. 885-896.

40.

Lackner

K.S.

Sachs

J.D.

(2005). “A Robust Strategy for Sustainable Energy.” Brookings Papers on Economic Activity 2005(2): 215-269.

41.

Lemoine

D.M.

Fuss

Szolgayova

Obersteiner

Kammen

D.M.

(2011). “The Influence of Negative Emission Technologies and Technology Policies on the Optimal Climate Mitigation Portfolio.” SSRN eLibrary (1558744).

42.

Levi

B.G.

(2008). “Will desperate climates call for desperate geoengineering measures?” Physics Today 61(8): 26-28.

43.

MacCracken

(2009). “Beyond Mitigation: Potential Options for Counter-Balancing the Climatic and Environmental Consequences of the Rising Concentrations of Greenhouse Gases.” Policy research working paper 4938, The World Bank.

44.

Morrow

D.R.

Kopp

R.E.

Oppenheimer

(2009). “Toward ethical norms and institutions for climate engineering research.” Environmental Research Letters 4(4): 045106.

45.

Nemet

G.F.

(2009). “Interim monitoring of cost dynamics for publicly supported energy technologies.” Energy Policy 37(3): 825-835.

46.

Nemet

G.F.

Baker

(2009). “Demand Subsidies Versus R&D: Comparing the Uncertain Impacts of Policy on a Pre-commercial Low-carbon Energy Technology.” The Energy Journal 30(4): 4980.

47.

Nemet

G.F.

Holloway

Meier

(2010). “Implications of incorporating air-quality co-benefits into climate change policymaking.” Environmental Research Letters 5(1): 014007.

48.

Nordhaus

(1991). “Economic Approaches to Greenhouse Warming.” In R. Dornbusch and J. M. Poterba, eds., Global warming: economic policy responses. Cambridge, MA:: MIT Press. pp. 3368.

49.

Nordhaus

(2008). A Question of Balance: Weighing the Options on Global Warming Policies. New Haven, CT: Yale University Press.

50.

Nordhaus

(2011). “Designing a friendly space for technological change to slow global warming.” Energy Economics 33(4): 665-673.

51.

Nordhaus

W.D.

(2010). “Economic aspects of global warming in a post-Copenhagen environment.” Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences 107(26): 11721-11726.

52.

NRC (2007). Prospective Evaluation of Applied Energy Research and Development at DOE (Phase Two). Washington: The National Academies Press.

53.

Parson

(2006). “Reflections on Air Capture: the political economy of active intervention in the global environment.” Climatic Change 74(1-3): 5-15.

54.

Pielke

R.A.

(2009). “An Idealized Assessment of the Economics of Air Capture of Carbon Dioxide in Mitigation Policy.” Environmental Science & Policy 12(3): 216-225.

55.

Plotkin

S.E.

Singh

Patterson

Ward

Wood

Kydes

Holte

Moore

Miller

Das

Greene

D.L.

(2009). “Multi-path transportation futures study: Vehicle characterization and scenario analyses.” Technical report ANL/ESD/09-5, Argonne National Laboratory.

56.

Robock

(2008). “20 reasons why geoengineering may be a bad idea.” Bulletin of the Atomic Scientists 64(2): 14.

57.

Rogers

E.M.

(1958). “Categorizing the adopters of agricultural practices.” Rural Sociology 23(4): 345-354.

58.

Rubin

E.S.

Yeh

Antes

Berkenpas

Davison

(2007). “Use of experience curves to estimate the future cost of power plants with CO₂ capture.” International Journal of Greenhouse Gas Control 1(2): 188-197.

59.

Searchinger

Heimlich

Houghton

R.A.

Dong

F.X.

Elobeid

Fabiosa

Tokgoz

Hayes

T.H.

(2008). “Use of US croplands for biofuels increases greenhouse gases through emissions fromland-use change.” Science 319(5867): 1238-1240.

60.

Sharp

J.D.

Jaccard

M.K.

Keith

D.W.

(2009). “Anticipating public attitudes toward underground CO₂ storage.” International Journal of Greenhouse Gas Control 3(5): 641-651.

61.

Shepherd

Caldeira

Cox

Haigh

Keith

Launder

Mace

MacKerron

Pyle

Rayner

Redgwell

Watson

(2009). “Geoengineering the climate: Science, governance and uncertainty.” Report RS Policy document 10/09, U.K. Royal Society.

62.

Smith

J.L.

(2005). “Inscrutable OPEC? Behavioral tests of the cartel hypothesis.” The Energy Journal 26(1): 51-82.

63.

Socolow

Desmond

Aines

Blackstock

Bolland

Kaarsberg

Lewis

Mazzotti

Pfeffer

Sawyer

Siirola

Smit

Wilcox

(2011). “Direct Air Capture of CO₂ with Chemicals: A Technology Assessment for the APS Panel on Public Affairs.” Report, American Physical Society (APS).

64.

Stephens

Keith

(2008). “Assessing geochemical carbon management.” Climatic Change 90(3): 217-242.

65.

Stolar‘off

(2006). “Capturing CO₂ from ambient air: a feasibility assessment.” PhD thesis, Carnegie Mellon University.

66.

Stolaroff

J.K.

Keith

D.W.

Lowry

G.V.

(2008). “Carbon dioxide capture from atmospheric air using sodium hydroxide spray.” Environmental Science and Technology 42(8): 2728-2735.

67.

van den Broek

Hoefnagels

Rubin

Turkenburg

Faaij

(2009). “Effects of technological learning on future cost and performance of power plants with CO₂ capture.” Progress in Energy and Combustion Science 35(6): 457-480.

68.

Victor

D.G.

(2008). “On the regulation of geoengineering.” Oxford Review of Economic Policy 24(2): 322-336.

69.

Victor

D.G.

Morgan

M.G.

Apt

Steinbruner

Ricke

(2009). “The Geoengineering Option: A Last Resort Against Global Warming?” Foreign Affairs 88(2): 64.

70.

Virgoe

(2009). “International governance of a possible geoengineering intervention to combat climate change.” Climatic Change 95(1): 103-119.

71.

Wetter

K.J.

(2009). “Geoengineering’s Governance Vacuum: Unilateralism and the Future of the Planet.” In: Geoengineering Options to Respond to Climate Change: Input to the Workshop and Suggested Reading. The National Academies.

72.

Wilson

E.J.

Friedmann

S.J.

Pollak

M.F.

(2007). “Research for deployment: Incorporating risk, regulation, and liability for carbon capture and sequestration.” Environmental Science and Technology 41(17): 5945-5952