Strengths-based parenting research involving Aboriginal fathers is scarce. This study centralises the knowledge and experiences of Aboriginal fathers and father figures living on Darkinjung Country, Central Coast of New South Wales, Australia. Yarning methodology was used to explore the roles and experiences of Aboriginal fathers living on Darkinjung Country and discuss what it means to be a healthy father as defined by Aboriginal men. Role modelling positive behaviours, connecting with other Aboriginal men, and fulfilling cultural obligations were identified as distinct elements of being an Aboriginal father. Processing trauma, healing, and disconnection from culture were identified as factors that can negatively impact fathering, while caring for others, making healthy choices, and strong relationships can positively impact fathering. This study addresses the omission of Aboriginal fathers in the parenting conversation and findings should be factored in the provision of care of Aboriginal fathers and their children.