The Community Méntal Health Centers (CMHC) legislation in the early 1960s was the first real attempt at a national mental health policy in the United States of America. Federal funding was made available for the establishment of 1500 centers across the country. The goal was to provide access to quality mental health care for all US citizens by 1980. As a result of prolonged criticisms, the legislation was repealed by the incoming Reagan Administration in the early 1980s, In this paper, the twenty-year lifespan of this ‘innovation’ in mental health policy is reviewed and an evaluation of some of its most pervasive criticisms are presented.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
AlbrittonR B, 1979, “Social amelioration through mass insurgency? A reexamination of the Piven and Cloward thesis”The American Political Science Review731003–1011
2.
BaconREltisW, 1976Britain's Economic Problem: Too Few Producers (Macmillan, London)
3.
BassukE LGersonS, 1978, “Deinstitutionalization and mental health services”Scientific American23845–53
4.
BiegelA, 1982, “Community mental health centers: A look ahead”Hospital and Community Psychiatry33741–746
5.
BlockF, 1981, “The fiscal crisis of the capitalist state”Annual Review of Sociology71–27
6.
BloomB L, 1977Community Mental Health: A General Introduction (Brooks/Cole, Monterey, CA)
7.
BoomsB HHallsdorsonJ R, 1973, “The politics of redistribution: A reformation”The American Political Science Review67924–933
8.
BreakeyW RKaminskyM J, 1982, “An assessment of Jarvis' law in an urban catchment area”Hospital and Community Psychiatry33661–663
9.
BrownP, 1979, “The transfer of care: US mental health policy since World War II”International Journal of Health Services9645–662
10.
BrownP, 1981, “The mental patients' rights movement and mental health institutional change”International Journal of Health Services11523–540
11.
BrownP, 1983, “Marxism, social psychology, and the sociology of mental health” research paper; copy available in mimeograph form from P Brown, Department of Sociology, Brown University, Providence, RI 02912, USA
12.
CatalanoRDooleyD, 1981, “The behavioral costs of economic instability”Policy Studies Journal10338–349
13.
ChuF DTrotterS, 1974The Madness Establishment (Grossman, New York)
14.
CohenS, 1979, “The punitive city: Notes on the dispersal of social control”Contemporary Crises3339–363
15.
ConradPSchneiderJ W, 1980Deviance and Medicalization: From Badness to Sickness (Mosby, St Louis, MO)
16.
CorriganPLeonardP, 1978Social Work Practice Under Capitalism: A Marxist Approach (Macmillan, London)
17.
DearM J, 1977, “Locational factors in the demand for mental health care”Economic Geography53223–240
18.
DearM J, 1981, “Social and spatial reproduction of the mentally ill” in Urbanization and Urban Planning in Capitalist Society Eds DearMScottA J, (Methuen, Andover, Hants) pp 481–497
19.
DearM JTaylorS M, 1982Not on Our Street (Pion, London)
20.
DohrenwendB PDohrenwendB SGouldM SLinkBNeugebauerRWunsch-HitzigR, 1980Mental Illness in the United States: Epidemiological Estimates (Praeger, New York)
21.
DoidgeJ RRodgersC W, 1976, “Is NIMH's dream coming. true? Wyoming centers reduce state hospital admissions”Community Mental Health Journal12399–404
22.
DollW, 1976, “Family coping and the mentally ill: An unanticipated problem of deinstitutionalization”Hospital and Community Psychiatry27183–185
23.
DoyalL, 1979The Political Economy of Health (Pluto Press, London)
24.
EstesC LHarringtonC A, 1981, “Fiscal crisis, deinstitutionalization and the elderly”American Behavioral Scientist24811–826
25.
FriedlandR, 1976, “Class power and social control: The war on poverty”Politics and Society6459–489
26.
GarfinkelIHavemanR H, 1977Earnings, Capacity, Poverty and Inequality (Academic Press, New York)
27.
GilderG F, 1980Wealth and Poverty (Basic Books, New York)
28.
GoldblattP BBerberianRGoldbergBKlermanGTischlerGZonanaH, 1973, “Catchmenting and the delivery of mental health services”Archives of General Psychiatry28478–482
29.
GoldenbergI, 1982, “On the creation of the new social settings” in Mental Health Services in Transition: A Policy Sourcebook Eds VallanceT RSabreR M, (Human Sciences Press, New York) pp 83–96
30.
GoldmanH HAdamsN HTaubeC A, 1983, “Deinstitutionalization: The data demythologized”Hospital and Community Psychiatry34129–134
31.
GordonD M, 1977, “Class struggle and the stages of American urban development” in The Rise of the Sunbelt Cities Eds PerryD DWatkinsA J, (Sage, Beverly Hills, CA) pp 55–82
32.
GoughI, 1979The Political Economy of the Welfare State (Macmillan, London)
33.
GrossM L, 1978The Psychological Society (Simon and Schuster, New York)
34.
HarveyD, 1981, “The urban process under capitalism: A framework for analysis” in Urbanization and Urban Planning in Capitalist Society Eds DearM JScottA J, (Methuen, Andover, Hants) pp 91–121
35.
HirschornL, 1978, “The political economy of social service rationalization: A developmental view”Contemporary Crises263–81
36.
HirschornL, 1979, “The theory of social services in disaccumulationist capitalism”International Journal of Health Services9295–311
37.
HollingsheadA BRedlichF C, 1958Social Class and Mental Illness (John Wiley, New York)
38.
HuffineC LCraigT J, 1973, “Catchment and community”Archives of General Psychiatry28438–488
39.
JWK International Corporation, 1979A Study of the Costs and Benefits of Alcoholism Treatment in Selected Communities final report under contract ADM 281-77-0013 to the National Institute on Alcohol Abuse and Alcoholism; copy available from JWK International Corporation, 7617 Little River Turnpike, Suite 800, Annandale, VA 22003, USA
40.
KatzM, 1978, “Origins of the institutional state”Marxist Perspectives Winter issue, pp 6–22
41.
KatznelsonI, 1976, “The crisis of the capitalist city: Urban politics and social control” in Theoretical Perspectives on Urban Politics Eds HawleyW DLipskyM, (Prentice-Hall, Englewood Cliffs, NJ)
42.
KenigS, 1981Limits on Theory: A Case Study of the Relationships of Market and State to Theory in the Community Mental Health Movement PhD dissertation, Department of Sociology, University of Connecticut, Storrs, Connecticut, USA
43.
KennistonK, 1969, “How community mental health stamped out the riots (1968–78)”Trans-Action521–29
44.
KirbyA, 1982The Politics of Location (Methuen, Andover, Hants)
45.
KirkS ATherrienM E, 1976, “Community mental health myths and the fate of former hospitalized patients”Psychiatry38209–217
46.
KnoxP, 1982Urban Social Geography: An Introduction (Longman, Harlow, Essex)
47.
KoumjianK, 1981, “The use of valium as a form of social control”Social Science and Medicine15E245–249
48.
KovelJ, 1980, “The American mental health industry” in Critical Psychiatry: The Politics of Mental Health Ed. InglebyD, (Pantheon Books, New York) pp 72–101
49.
LandsbergGHammerR, 1977, “Possible programmatic consequences of community mental health center funding arrangements: Illustrations based on inpatient utilization data”Community Mental Health Journal1363–67
50.
LeeR, 1979, “The economic basis of social problems in the city” in Social Problems and the City: Geographical Perspectives Eds HerbertD FSmithD M, (Oxford University Press, London) pp 47–62
51.
LermanP, 1982Deinstitutionalization and the Welfare State (Rutgers University Press, New Brunswick, NJ)
52.
LevineM, 1981The History and Politics of Community Mental Health (Oxford University Press, New York)
53.
LongestJKonanMTweedD, 1976A Study of Deficiencies and Differentials in the Distribution of Mental Health Resources in Facilities National Institute of Mental Health Series B, number 15, Department of Health, Education and Welfare publication number ADM 79-517; copy available from the Division of Biometry and Epidemiology, National Institute of Mental Health, 5600 Fishers Lane, Rockville, MD 20857, USA
54.
MeierR F, 1982, “Perspectives on the concept of social control”Annual Review of Sociology834–55
55.
MeyersWDorwartRKlineD, 1977, “Social ecology and citizen boards: A problem for planners”Journal of the American Institute of Planners43169–177
56.
MollicaR FRedlichF C, 1980, “Equity and changing patient characteristics—1950–1975”Archives of General Psychiatry371257–1263
57.
MoseleyH, 1979, “Monopoly capital and the state: Some critical reflections on O'Connor's fiscal crisis of the state”The Review of Radical Political Economy1152–61
58.
NaiermanNHaskinsBRobinsonG, 1978Community Mental Health Centers—A Decade Later (Abt Books, Cambridge, MA)
59.
NavarroV, 1977, “The political economy of medical care—an explanation of the composition, nature, and functions of the present health sector of the United States” in Health and Medical Care in the US: A Critical Analysis VA. V Navarro (Haywood, Farmingdale, NY) pp 85–112
60.
NavarroV, 1981, “The economic and political determinants of human (including health) rights” in Imperialism, Health and Medicine Ed. NavarroV, (Baywood, Farmingdale, NY) pp 53–76
61.
O'ConnorJ, 1973The Fiscal Crisis of the State (St Martins Press, New York)
62.
PattersonJ T, 1981America's Struggle Against Poverty 1900–1980 (Harvard University Press, Cambridge, MA)
63.
PepperBKirschnerM CRyglewiczH, 1981, “The young adult chronic patient: An overview of a population”Hospital and Community Psychiatry32463–469
64.
PerryD CWatkinsA J, 1977, “People, profit, and the rise of the sunbelt cities” in The Rise of the Sunbelt Cities Eds. PerryD CWatkinsA J, (Sage, Beverly Hills, CA) pp 277–306
65.
PinchS, 1979, “Territorial justice in the city: A case study of the social services for the elderly in Greater London” in Social Problems and the City: Geographical Perspectives Eds HerbertD TSmithD M, (Oxford University Press, London) pp 201–224
66.
PivenF FClowardR A, 1971Regulating the Poor: The Functions of Public Welfare (Vintage Books, New York)
67.
PivenF FClowardR A, 1979, “Electoral instability, civil disorder, and relief rises: A reply to Attrition”The American Political Science Review731012–1019
68.
PivenF FClowardR A, 1982The New Class War (Pantheon Books, New York)
69.
RabkinJ G, 1979, “Ethnic density and psychiatric hospitalization: Hazards of minority status”American Journal of Psychiatry1361562–1566
70.
RedickR W, 1976Addition Rates to Federally Funded Community Mental Health Centers, US 1973 Mental Health Statistical Note 126, Department of Health, Education and Welfare publication number ADM 76–158; copy available from the National Institute of Mental Health, 5600 Fishers Lane, Rockville', MD 20857, USA
71.
RegesterD, 1974, “Community mental health—for whose community?”American Journal of Public Health64886–893
72.
RoseS M, 1979, “Deciphering deinstitutionalization: Complexities on policy and program analysis”Milbank Memorial Fund Quarterly: Health and Society57429–460
73.
ScullA T, 1981, “A new trade in lunacy: The recommodification of the mental patient”American Behavioral Scientist24741–754
74.
ScullyDWindleC, 1973An Empirical Study of the Impact of Federally Funded Community Mental Health Centers on State Hospital Utilization report to the National Institute of Mental Health on contract HSM 42-73-70 (National Technical Information Service, Springfield, VA)
SegalS P, 1978, “Attitudes toward the mentally ill: A review”Social Work23211–217
77.
SegalS PBaumohlJMoylesE W, 1980, “Neighborhood types and community reaction to the mentally ill: A paradox of intensity”Journal of Health and Social Behavior21345–359
78.
SmithC J, 1978, “Recidivism and community adjustment in former mental patients”Social Science and Medicine1217–27
79.
SmithC J, 1981, “Urban structure and the development of natural support systems for service dependent populations”The Professional Geographer33457–465
80.
SmithC J, 1982, “Economic determinism and the provision of human services” paper presented at a symposium on public provision and urban politics, Falls Church, VA, 1–3 June: Copy available from the author
81.
SmithC J, 1983a, “Economic determinism and the provision of human services” in Public Provision and Urban Development Eds KnoxPKirbyAPinchS, (Croom Helm, Beckenham, Kent) forthcoming
SmithC J, 1983c, “The urban services paradox: Shrinking supply in times of rising demand”Population Research and Policy Review2149–160
84.
SmithC JHanhamR Q, 1981, “Deinstitutionalization of the mentally ill: A time path analysis of the American states, 1955–1975”Social Science and Medicine15361–378
85.
SmithC JHanhamR Q, 1982, “Deinstitutionalization and community acceptance of the mentally ill in the USA”Ekistics296358–368
86.
SmithD M, 1977Human Geography: A Welfare Approach (Edward Arnold, London)
87.
SpitzerS, 1975, “Toward a Marxian theory of deviance”Social Problems22641–651
88.
StevensonG, 1976, “Social relations and consumption in the human service occupations”Monthly Review July/August issue, pp 78–87
89.
StoeszD, 1981, “A wake for the welfare state: Social welfare and the neoconservative challenge”Social Service Review55398–410
90.
TischlerG L, 1977, “Ethnicity and the delivery of mental health services” in New Trends of Psychiatry in the Community Ed. SerbanG, (Ballinger, Cambridge, MA) pp 163–176
91.
TischlerG LHeniszJMyersJ K, 1972, “Catchmenting and the use of mental health services”Archives of General Psychiatry27389–392
92.
TischlerG LHeniszJMyersJ K, 1975, “The catchment area concept” in Progress in Community Mental Healthvolume 3, Eds BellakLBarrenH, (Brunner/Mazel Inc., New York) pp 59–83
93.
US Government, 1935, Social Security Act, 14 August 1935, C 531, 49, Statute 620
94.
US Government, 1963, Community Mental Health Centers Act: Title II, Section 200 of the Mental Retardation Facilities and Community Mental Health Centers Construction Act, 31 October 1936, PL 88–164, 77, Statute 282
95.
Van DusenK T, 1981, “Net widening and relabeling: Some consequences of deinstitutionalization”American Behavioral Scientist24724–740
96.
WeinerR SWoyJ RSharfsteinS SBassR D, 1979, “Community mental health centers and the ‘seed money’ concept: Effects of terminating federal funds”Community Mental Health Journal15129–138
97.
WeisbrodB A, 1979A Guide to Benefit-Cost Analysis as Seen Through a Controlled Experiment in Treating the Mentally Ill research report, Institute for Research on Poverty, University of Wisconsin, Madison, WI
98.
WindleC, 1980, “Correlates of community mental health center underservice to non-whites”Journal of Community Psychology8140–146
99.
WinslowW W, 1982, “Changing trends in CMHC's: Keys to survival in the eighties”Hospital and Community Psychiatry33273–277
100.
WohlenbergE H, 1976, “Interstate variations in AFDC programs”Economic Geography52254–265
101.
WolfeA, 1981America's Impass: The Rise and Fall of the Politics of Growth (South End Press, Boston, MA)
102.
WoyJ RWassermanD BWeiner-PomerantzR, 1981, “Community mental health centers: Movement away from the model?”Community Mental Health Journal17265–276
103.
YeeW K, 1975, “Dialectical materialism and community mental health programs: An analysis of the Lincoln Hospital Department of Psychiatry” in Topias and Utopias in Health Eds IngmanSThomasA, (Aldine, Chicago, IL) pp 141–158
104.
YoungJ, 1971, “The role of the police as amplifier of deviancy, negotiators of reality and translators of fantasy” in Images of Deviance Ed. CohenS, (Penguin Books, Harmondsworth, Middx) pp 27–61
