Incorporating Extrinsic Goals Into Decision and Cost-Effectiveness Analyses

Abstract

It has not been widely recognized that medical patients as individuals may have goals that are not easily expressed in terms of quality-adjusted life years (QALYs). The QALY model deals with ongoing goals such as reducing pain or maintaining mobility, but goals such as completing an important project or seeing a child graduate from college occur at unique points in time and do not lend themselves to easy expression in terms of QALYs. Such extrinsic goals have been posited as explanations for preferences inconsistent with the QALY model, such as unwillingness to trade away time or accept gambles. In this article, the authors examine methods for including extrinsic goals in medical decision and cost-effectiveness analyses. As illustrations, they revisit 2 previously published analyses, the management of unruptured intracranial arteriovenous malformations (AVMs) and the evaluation of preventive strategies for BRCA + women.

Keywords

theories of quality of life utility inconsistencies utility measurement multiattribute utility function health state preferences utilities and valuations health-related quality of life cancer prevention.

References

Pliskin JS , Shepard DS , Weinstein MC Utility functions for life years and health status. Operations Res. 1980;28:206-24.

Gold MR , Patrick DL , Torrence GW , et al. Identifying and valuing outcomes. In: Gold MR , Siegel JE , Russell LB , Weinstein MC , eds. Cost-Effectiveness in Health and Medicine. Oxford, UK: Oxford University Press; 1996.

Tsevat J.

What do utilities measure?

Med Care. 2000;38(suppl II):II-160-4.

Hazen GB Adding extrinsic goals to the QALY model. Decis Anal . 2007;4:3-16.

Schwartz A. , Hazen GB , Leifer A. , Heckerling PS Life goals and health decisions: what will people live or die for ? Med Decis Making. 2008;28:209-19.

Miyamoto JM , Wakker PP , Bleichrodt H. , Peters HJM. The zero-condition: a simplifying assumption in QALY measurement and multiattribute utility. Manage Sci. 1998;44:839-49.

Sutherland HJ , Llewellyn-Thomas H. , Boyd NF , Till JE Attitudes towards quality of survival: the concept of maximal endurable time. Med Decis Making. 1982;2:299-309.

Dolan P. , Stalmeier P. The validity of time trade-off values in calculating QALYs: constant proportional time trade-off versus the proportional heuristic. J Health Econ. 2003;22:445-58.

Stalmeier PFM . , Chapman GB , de Boer Agem , van Lanschot JJB. A fallacy of the multiplicative QALY model for low-quality weights in students and patients judging hypothetical health states. Int J Technol Assess Health Care. 2001;17:488-96.

10.

Miyamoto JM , Eraker SA A multiplicative model of the utility of survival duration and health quality. J Exp Psychol Gen . 1988;117:3-20.

11.

van der Pol M. , Shiell A. Extrinsic goals and time trade-off . Med Decis Making. 2007;27:406-13.

12.

Schwartz A. , Hazen GB , Leifer A. , Heckerling PS Development of goal-sensitive health-related utility assessment procedures. Med Decis Making. In press.

13.

Auger RG , Weibers DO Management of unruptured intracranial arteriovenous malformations: a decision analysis. Neurosurgery. 1992;4:561-9.

14.

Hazen GB Stochastic trees: a new technique for temporal medical decision modeling . Med Decis Making. 1992;12:163-78.

15.

Hazen GB Factored stochastic trees: a tool for solving complex temporal medical decision models. Med Decis Making. 1993;13:227-36.

16.

Hazen GB Stochastic trees and the StoTree modeling environment: models and software for medical decision analysis. J Med Systems. 2002;26:399-413.

17.

Anderson K. , Jacobson JS , Heitjan DF , et al. Cost-effectiveness of preventive strategies for women with a BRCA1 or a BRCA2 mutation. Ann Intern Med . 2006;144:397-406.

18.

Ibrahim JG , Chen M-H. , Sinha D. Bayesian Survival Analysis. New York: Springer; 2001.

19.

Surveillance, Epidemiology, and End Results (SEER) Program (www.seer.cancer.gov) SEER*Stat Database: Incidence-SEER 17 Regs Limited-Use, Nov 2005 Sub (1973-2003 varying)-Linked to County Attributes-Total U.S., 1969-2003 Counties, National Cancer Institute, DCCPS, Surveillance Research Program, Cancer Statistics Branch, released April 2006, based on the November 2005 submission.