Hospitals' Care of Uninsured Patients during the 1990s: The Relation of Teaching Status and Managed Care to Changes in Market Share and Market Concentration
Free accessResearch articleFirst published online February, 2003
Hospitals' Care of Uninsured Patients during the 1990s: The Relation of Teaching Status and Managed Care to Changes in Market Share and Market Concentration
Competitive forces in health care make it difficult for hospitals to shift the costs of caring for poor and uninsured patients onto paying patients. The care of uninsured patients in teaching hospitals may have been especially affected by increased levels of managed care during the 1990s. We found that the market share of uninsured patients during the 1990s grew at academic health center hospitals relative to other hospitals in their service areas, and these increases occurred primarily in areas with high levels of managed care. More generally, in urban areas, the care of uninsured patients was twice as concentrated as that of all patients, and the ratio of concentration (uninsured patients vs. all patients) was greater in areas with high managed care levels than in areas with low managed care levels (p < .01). These results have implications for the design of payment policies for indigent care.
References
1.
AshbyJ. L.AshbyJ. L.Jr., 1992. The Burden of Uncompensated Care Grows. Healthcare Finance Management46 (4): 66, 68, 70–72.
2.
AtkinsonG.HelmsW. D.NeedlemanJ., 1997. State Trends in Hospital Uncompensated Care. Health Affairs16 (4): 233–241.
3.
BanksD. A.PatersonM.WendelJ., 1997. Uncompensated Hospital Care: Charitable Mission or Profitable Business Decision?Health Economics6 (2): 133–143.
4.
Commonwealth Fund Task Force on Academic Health Centers. 2001. A Shared Responsibility: Academic Health Centers and the Provision of Care to the Poor and Uninsured. New York: The Commonwealth Fund.
5.
CoughlinT. A.KuL.KimJ., 2000. Reforming the Medicaid Disproportionate Share Hospital Program in the 1990s. Washington, D.C.: Urban Institute.
6.
CunninghamP. J.GrossmanJ. M.St. PeterR. F.LesserC. S., 1999. Managed Care and Physicians' Provision of Charity Care. Journal of the American Medical Association281 (12): 1087–1092.
7.
CunninghamP. J.TuH. T., 1997. A Changing Picture of Uncompensated Care. Health Affairs16 (4): 167–175.
8.
DranoveD.ShanleyM.WhiteW., 1996. Price and Concentration in Local Hospital Markets: The Shift form Patient Driven to Payer Driven Competition. Journal of Law and Economics36: 199–204.
9.
FrankR. G.SalkeverD. S., 1991. The Supply of Charity Services by Nonprofit Hospitals: Motives and Market Structure. Rand Journal of Economics22 (3): 430–445.
10.
FronstinP.2000. Sources of Health Insurance and Characteristics of the Uninsured: Analysis of the March 1997 Current Population Survey. Washington, D.C.: Employee Benefit Research Institute.
11.
GaskinD. J.1997. Altruism or Moral Hazard: The Impact of Hospital Uncompensated Care Pools. Journal of Health Economics16 (4): 397–416.
12.
GrayB. H.1998. Hospital Ownership Form and Care of the Uninsured. In The Future U.S. Healthcare System: Who Will Care for the Poor and Uninsured?AltmanS. H.ReinhardtU. E.ShieldsA.E., eds. Chicago, Ill.: Health Administration Press.
13.
GruberJ.1994. The Effect of Competitive Pressure on Charity: Hospital Responses to Price Shopping in California. Journal of Health Economics13 (2): 183–212.
14.
Institute of Medicine. 2000. America's Health Care Safety Net: Intact But Endangered. Washington, D.C.: National Academy Press.
15.
LewinL. S.EckelsT. J.MillerL. B., 1988. Setting the Record Straight. The Provision of Uncompensated Care by Not-for-Profit Hospitals. New England Journal of Medicine318 (18): 1212–1215.
16.
MannJ. M.MelnickG. A.BamezaiA.ZwanzigerJ., 1997. A Profile of Uncompensated Hospital Care, 1983–1995. Health Affairs16 (4): 223–232.
17.
Medicare Payment Advisory Commission (MedPAC). 2001. Report to the Congress: Medicare Payment Policy. March. Washington, D.C.: MedPAC.
18.
MoyE.ValenteE.Jr.LevinR. J.GrinerP. F., 1996. Academic Medical Centers and the Care of Underserved Populations. Academic Medicine71 (12): 1370–1377.
19.
NortonE. C.StaigerD. O., 1994. How Hospital Ownership Affects Access to Care for the Uninsured. Rand Journal of Economics25 (1): 171–185.
20.
PhibbsC. S.RobinsonJ. C., 1993. A Variable-Radius Measure of Local Hospital Market Structure. Health Services Research28 (3): 313–324.
21.
Prospective Payment Assessment Commission (ProPAC). 1996. Medicare and the American Health Care System: Report to Congress June 1996. Washington, D.C.: ProPAC.
22.
RobinsonJ. C.2001. The End of Managed Care. Journal of the American Medical Association285 (20): 2622–2628.
23.
ScullyT. A.1998. The Role of Investor-Owned and Not-for-Profit Organizations in Providing Healthcare to the Poor and Uninsured: A Perspective. In The Future U.S. Healthcare System: Who Will Care for the Poor and Uninsured?AltmanS. H.ReinhardtU. E.ShieldsA. E., eds. Chicago, Ill.: Health Administration Press.
24.
SloanF. A.BlumsteinJ. F.PerrinJ. M., 1986. Uncompensated Hospital Care: Rights and Responsibilities. Baltimore: Johns Hopkins University Press.
25.
SulvettaM. B.SwartzK., 1986. The Uninsured and Uncompensated Care. Washington, D.C.: National Health Policy Forum, George Washington University.
26.
ThorpeK. E.FlorenceC. S.SeiberE. E., 2000. Hospital Conversions, Margins, and the Provision of Uncompensated Care. Health Affairs19 (6): 187–194.
27.
WeissmanJ. S.1996. Uncompensated Care: Will It Be There When We Need It?Journal of the American Medical Association276 (10): 823–828.
28.
WeissmanJ. S.DryfoosP.LondonK., 1999. Income Levels of Bad-Debt and Free-Care Patients in Massachusetts Hospitals. Health Affairs18 (4): 156–166.
WyattS. M.MoyE.LevinR. J.LawtonK. B.WitterD. M.Jr.ValenteE.Jr.LalaR.GrinerP. F., 1997. Patients Transferred to Academic Medical Centers and Other Hospitals: Characteristics, Resource Use, and Outcomes. Academic Medicine72 (10): 921–930.
31.
ZwanzigerJ.MelnickG. A.MannJ. M., 1990. Measures of Hospital Market Structure: A Review of the Alternatives and a Proposed Approach. Socioeconomic Planning in Science24 (2): 81–95.
