Confinement is a major life event with far-reaching consequences for an individual, which may also influence personality change, but data on this topic are fragmented across disciplines. Therefore, this review aims to provide a comprehensive synthesis of the evidence on personality change in confined individuals. A systematic literature search covering publications up to March 2024 was conducted using EBSCOhost, PubMed, and Web of Science. Peer-reviewed original articles examining personality changes associated with any form of confinement were included. They examined a wide range of personality traits, which we categorized within the Big Five. Thirteen observational studies focused on personality change during confinement irrespective of specific interventions. They most consistently reported increases in emotional stability and conscientiousness, while findings for agreeableness, extraversion, and openness were mixed or limited. Twenty-seven intervention studies examined change in the context of interventions in confinement. They mostly found increases in emotional stability and agreeableness, whereas openness, extraversion, and conscientiousness yielded mixed results or were rarely targeted, especially in forensic settings. Our findings suggest that confinement, especially when combined with targeted interventions, may potentially promote personality changes. However, highly heterogeneous designs, methods, and trait definitions, together with other limitations, reduced the interpretability and generalizability of the findings.
Plain language summary
Why was this study done? Being in confinement, such as in prison or forensic psychiatry, is a life-changing experience. It may lead to changes in personality traits but the evidence on this is scarce and scattered across different fields. This study aimed to gather and summarize all the available research on personality changes observed in individuals during confinement.
What did the researchers do? The researchers looked at studies published between 1979 and 2024 using a standardized search term in scientific databases. They included studies that tracked personality changes in confined individuals over time to see if their personalities changed while they were confined.
What did the researchers find? They identified 40 studies that met the criteria for inclusion in their review. Of these, 13 focused on personality changes observed during confinement without targeted interventions. These studies most often found increases in traits related to emotional stability and conscientiousness from the beginning to the end of confinement, whereas results for agreeableness, extraversion, and openness were mixed or rare. The other 27 studies explored personality changes associated with specific interventions in confinement settings. The most common intervention-related changes were improvements in emotional stability and agreeableness. Openness, extraversion, and conscientiousness showed inconsistent results and were less often targeted, especially in forensic settings. The studies used very different methods, definitions, and participant groups, which made it hard to draw clear conclusions.
What do the findings mean? The findings indicate that certain patterns of personality changes are observed during confinement, especially when specific interventions (e.g., therapy programs) are involved. However, because of differences in how the studies were done and possible biases, more research is needed to better understand these patterns and what might contribute to them.