This article presents a comparative analysis of the institutional trajectories traced by women's policy agencies within government in the province of British Columbia in Canada and in the state of New South Wales in Australia. In both cases, a period during which the principal women's policy agency took the form of a freestanding government ministry was followed by a period during which that ministry (along with an array of women's policy agencies located elsewhere in government) was dismantled. The partisan complexion of the governments undertaking these initiatives has been quite different in the two cases, and presents an apparent paradox. The article explores this paradox, as well as other patterns observable across the two cases, and provides an assessment of their implications.
Ball, Wendy and Charles, Nickie (2006). “Feminist Social Movements and Policy Change: Devolution, Childcare and Domestic Violence Policies in Wales,” Women's Studies International Forum29: 172—83.
2.
Bashevkin, Sylvia (1998). Women on the Defensive: Living Through Conservative Times. Toronto: University of Toronto Press.
3.
Bashevkin, Sylvia (2002). Welfare Hot Buttons: Women, Work, and Social Policy Reform. Toronto: University of Toronto Press.
4.
BC CEDAW Group (2003). British Columbia Moves Backwards on Women's Equality, URL (consulted August 18, 2006): http://www.fafia-afai.org/images/pdf/BC_CEDAW_report_012103.pdf.
5.
Brodie, Janine (1995). Politics on the Margins: Restructuring and the Canadian Women's Movement. Halifax: Fernwood.
6.
Carroll, William K. and Ratner, R.S. (2005). “The NDP Regime in British Columbia, 1991— 2001: A Post-Mortem,” Canadian Review of Sociology and Anthropology42(2): 167—96.
7.
Chappell, Louise (1995). “Women's Policy,” in Martin Laffin and Martin Painter (eds), Reform and Reversal: Lessons From the Coalition Government in New South Wales, 1988—1995. Melbourne : Macmillan.
8.
Chappell, Louise (2002a). “The `Femocrat' Strategy: Expanding the Repertoire of Feminist Activists,” Parliamentary Affairs55: 85—98.
9.
Chappell, Louise (2002b). Gendering Government: Feminist Engagement with the State in Australia and Canada. Vancouver and Toronto: UBC Press.
10.
Chappell, Louise (2006). “Working from Within: Women in the NSW Bureaucracy ,” in Deborah Brennan and Louise Chappell (eds), “No Fit Place for Women”? Women in New South Wales Politics. Sydney : University of New South Wales Press.
11.
Cohen, Marjorie Griffin (1994). “British Columbia: Playing Safe is a Dangerous Game,” Studies in Political Economy43: 149—59.
12.
Creese, Gillian and Strong-Boag, Veronica (2005). Losing Ground: The Effects of Government Cutbacks on Women in British Columbia, 2001—2005, URL (consulted June 15, 2005): http://www.3.telus.net/bcwomen/archives .
13.
DFW (Department for Women) (1996). Annual Report 1995—6. Sydney: DFW, Government of New South Wales.
14.
DFW (Department for Women) (1998). Annual Report for the Year Ended 30 June 1998. Sydney: DFW, Government of New South Wales.
15.
Earle, J., Herron, A., Secomb, L. and Stubbs, J. (1990). “The National Domestic Violence Education Program: A Commentary,” Refractory Girl36: 2—6.
16.
Fuller, S., Fuller, C. and Cohen, M. (2003). Health Care Restructuring in BC. Vancouver: Canadian Centre for Policy Alternatives — BC Office.
17.
Garcia, Luis (1988). “Women's Unit Accused of Politicking.” Sydney Morning Herald, May 3: 9.
18.
Giddens, Anthony (2000). The Third Way and its Critics. Cambridge: Polity Press.
19.
Goodwin, Sue (2006). “Working From the Outside In: NSW Women's Advisory Committees,” in Deborah Brennan and Louise Chappell (eds), “No Fit Place for Women”? Women in New South Wales Politics. Sydney: University of New South Wales Press.
20.
Grace, Joan (2005). “Challenges and Opportunities in Manitoba: The Social Democratic `Promise' and Women's Equality,” in William K. Carroll and R.S. Ratner (eds), Challenges and Perils: Social Democracy in Neoliberal Times. Halifax: Fernwood .
21.
Hancock, Linda, ed. (1999). Women, Public Policy and the State. South Yarra: Macmillan.
22.
Hankivsky, Olena (2005). “Gender vs. Diversity Mainstreaming: A Preliminary Examination of the Role and Transformative Potential of Feminist Theory,” Canadian Journal of Political Science38(4): 977—1001.
23.
Harder, Lois (2003). State of Struggle: Feminism and Politics in Alberta . Edmonton: University of Alberta Press.
24.
Hudspith, Maria (1999). Caring for Lesbian Health: A Resource for Health Care Providers, Policy Makers and Planners. Victoria: Ministry of Health and Ministry Responsible for Seniors.
25.
Kelsey, Jane (2002). At the Crossroads: Three Essays. Wellington: Bridget Williams Books.
26.
Kingfisher, Catherine, ed. (2002). Western Welfare in Decline: Globalization and Women's Poverty. Philadelphia: University of Pennsylvania Press.
27.
Laffin, Martin and Painter, Martin (1995). “Introduction,” in Martin Laffin and Martin Painter (eds), Reform and Reversal: Lessons from the Coalition Government in New South Wales, 1988—1995. Melbourne : Macmillan.
28.
McFerren, Lois (1989). “Can Men Change? What to do with Batterers? ” Refractory Girl33: 3—4.
29.
McRobbie, Angela (2000). “Feminism and the Third Way,” Feminist Review64: 97—112.
30.
Malloy, Jonathan (1999). “What Makes a State Advocacy Structure Effective? Conflicts Between Bureaucratic and Social Movement Criteria,” Governance12(3): 267—88.
31.
Malloy, Jonathan (2003). Between Colliding Worlds: The Ambiguous Existence of Government Agencies for Aboriginal and Women's Policy. Toronto: University of Toronto Press.
32.
Mazur, Amy G. (2001). “Introduction,” in Amy G. Mazur (ed.), State Feminism, Women's Movements, and Job Training: Making Democracies Work in the Global Economy. New York and London: Routledge.
33.
Mazur, Amy G. (2002). Theorizing Feminist Policy. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
34.
MCAWS (Ministry of Community, Aboriginal and Women's Services) (2003). Guide to Best Practices in Gender Analysis, URL (consulted July 18, 2006): http://www.cserv.gov.bc.ca/womens_services/best_practices/best_practices_web.pdf . Victoria, BC: MCAWS, Government of British Columbia.
35.
MCAWS (Ministry of Community, Aboriginal and Women's Services) (n.d.). Quick Reference Guide to Best Practices in Gender Analysis, URL (consulted July 18 2006): http://www.cserv.gov.bc.ca/womens_services/best_practices/gender_analysis_ref_guide.pdf . Victoria, BC: MCAWS, Government of British Columbia.
36.
MCS (Ministry of Community Services) (2006 ). 2006/07—2008/09 Service Plan, URL (consulted August 8, 2006): http://www.bcbudget.gov.bc.ca/2006/sp/cs/cs.pdf . Victoria, BC: MCS, Government of British Columbia.
37.
Ministry of Health (2006). 2006/07—2008/09 Service Plan, URL (consulted August 18, 2006): http://www.bcbudget.gov.bc.ca/2006/sp/hlth/hlth.pdf. Victoria, BC: Government of British Columbia.
38.
Morrow, Marina and Varcoe, Colleen (2000). Violence Against Women: Improving the Health Care Response. Victoria, BC: Ministry of Health, Women's Bureau.
39.
Morrow, M., Hankivsky, O. and Varcoe, C. (2004). “Women and Violence: The Effects of Dismantling the Welfare State,” Critical Social Policy24(3): 358—84.
40.
MSAW (Ministry for the Status and Advancement of Women) (1994). New South Wales Government Working for Women. Sydney: MSAW, Government of New South Wales.
41.
MWE (Ministry of Women's Equality) (1995). British Columbia Initiatives for Women's Equality. Victoria, BC: MWE, Government of British Columbia.
42.
MWE (Ministry of Women's Equality) (1997). Gender Lens: A Guide to Gender-Inclusive Policy and Program Development. Victoria, BC: MWE, Government of British Columbia.
43.
MWE (Ministry of Women's Equality) (2001a). Annual Performance Report 2000—2001. Victoria, BC : MWE, Government of British Columbia.
44.
MWE (Ministry of Women's Equality) (2001b). A Decade of Accomplishments: 1991—2001. Victoria, BC: MWE, Government of British Columbia.
45.
New South Wales Parliamentary Debates (2004). April 6: 8083.
46.
Niland, Carmel (2006). “Women's Policy: Courage with Caution — The Decade in which NSW Led the World in Women's Rights,” in Troy Bramston (ed.), The Wran Era. Sydney: Federation Press.
Parella, Lucia (1993). “Participation in Government Structures: Progress or Co-optation?” Australian Feminist Studies18: 67—85.
49.
Rankin, L. Pauline and Vickers, Jill (2001). Women's Movements and State Feminism: Integrating Diversity into Public Policy. Ottawa: Status of Women Canada.
50.
Sawer, Marian (1990). Sisters in Suits: Women and Public Policy in Australia. Sydney: Allen and Unwin.
51.
Sawer, Marian (1996). Femocrats and Ecorats: Women's Policy Machinery in Australia, Canada and New Zealand. Geneva: United Nations Research Institute for Social Development.
52.
Sawer, Marian (1999). “ Women's Ministries: An Australian Perspective,” Feminist Review63, Fall: 91—107.
53.
Squires, Judith (2005). “Is Mainstreaming Transformative? Theorizing Mainstreaming in the Context of Diversity and Deliberation,” Social Politics12(3): 366—88.
54.
Squires, Judith and Wickham-Jones, Mark (2002). “Mainstreaming in Westminster and Whitehall: From Labour's Ministry for Women to the Women and Equality Unit,” Parliamentary Affairs55: 57—70.
55.
Squires, Judith and Wickham-Jones, Mark (2004). “New Labour, Gender Mainstreaming and the Women and Equality Unit,” British Journal of Politics and International Relations6: 81—98.
56.
Stephen, Kylie (2000). “Catalysts for Change? The Effectiveness of State Agencies in Promoting Equality,” in Fiona Beveridge, Sue Nott and Kylie Stephen (eds), Making Women Count: Integrating Gender into Law and Policy-Making. Aldershot: Ashgate .
57.
Susskind, Anne (1988). “Unions Back Teachers' Case.” Sydney Morning Herald, July 20: 11.
58.
Teghtsoonian, Katherine (2000). “Gendering Policy Analysis in the Government of British Columbia: Strategies, Possibilities and Constraints,” Studies in Political Economy61: 105—27.
59.
Teghtsoonian, Katherine (2003). “W(h)ither Women's Equality? Neoliberalism, Institutional Change and Public Policy in British Columbia,” Policy, Organisation and Society22(1): 26—47.
60.
Teghtsoonian, Katherine (2005). “Disparate Fates in Challenging Times: Women's Policy Agencies and Neoliberalism in Aotearoa/New Zealand and British Columbia ,” Canadian Journal of Political Science38(2): 307—33.
61.
Teghtsoonian, Katherine and Grace, Joan (2001). “`Something More Is Necessary': The Mixed Achievements of Women's Policy Agencies in Canada,” in Amy G. Mazur (ed.), State Feminism, Women's Movements, and Job Training: Making Democracies Work in the Global Economy. New York and London: Routledge.
62.
True, Jacqui and Mintrom, Michael (2001). “Transnational Networks and Policy Diffusion: The Case of Gender Mainstreaming,” International Studies Quarterly45: 27—57.
63.
Vickers, Jill (2006). “The Problem with Interests: Making Political Claims for `Women',” in Louise Chappell and Lisa Hill (eds), The Politics of Women's Interests: New Comparative Perspectives. London: Routledge.
64.
Wainwright, Robert (2005). “Meet the Man in Charge of Women's Affairs .” Sydney Morning Herald, September 26: 3.
65.
Weldon, S. Laurel (2002). “Beyond Bodies: Institutional Sources of Representation for Women in Democratic Policymaking,” Journal of Politics64(4): 1153—74.
66.
Woodward, Alison (2003). “European Gender Mainstreaming: Promises and Pitfalls of Transformative Policy,” Review of Policy Research20(1): 65—88.
