Adolescence is identified as a key period for identity development, but anthropological literature hints at cross-cultural variations. Past research suggests Japanese adolescents may experience more identity exploration/confusion compared to Western counterparts, but the reasons behind these findings remain unclear. This comparative study investigates how adolescents in England and Japan perceive and engage with their environments, and aims to identify similarities/differences that could explain cross-cultural variations in identity development. Using autophotography, 98 teenagers aged 13 to 15 years across 10 schools in England and Japan documented important aspects of their lives. We applied template analysis to qualitatively analyze these photographs/texts. Overall, we identified two shared themes between countries: “This Is Me,” reflecting personal identity through self-discovery and skill development, and “Connectedness,” emphasizing relationships and belonging. A Japan-specific theme, “Reflections Through Time,” captured the broader temporal lens of Japanese adolescents, sometimes with a sense of melancholy. This notably differed from English adolescents in our study, who focused on the present in a positive manner. These findings suggest cultural differences in how adolescents engage with their environments, which may contribute to cross-cultural variations in identity development. Our findings point to the importance of biocultural approaches in developmental research by considering the role of culture.
Plain language summary
Past research from Euro-Western populations has found that adolescence is a key period of identity development, but studies suggest there could be some differences in the way identity develops across cultures. For example, in Japan, studies suggest teenagers may be less likely to be certain about “who they are.” To understand cultural variations in developmental processes, we need to understand cultural differences in the developmental environment. In this project, we asked teenagers aged 13-15 years in England and Japan to photograph the important things, people, and places in their lives. We qualitatively analysed the photographs and accompanying texts through a template analysis, identifying shared topics and themes across multiple photographs.
In both countries, we found that adolescents photographed things to showcase who they were (This is me), including what kinds of skills they were developing. They also photographed their connections to their family, friends, school, local area, and beyond (Connectedness), showcasing how they engaged with and valued different aspects of their environment. However, we found that adolescents in Japan were more likely to consider and refer to time (Reflections Through Time), and not all reflections were positive. These were in distinct contrast to photographs from England, which were overwhelmingly positive and focused on the present.
Our results show that, in both England and Japan, identity development seems to be an important part of being a teenager, and connectedness to the wider world underpins their developmental environment. However, teenagers in Japan may think about themselves and their lives differently than teenagers in England, which may explain why teenagers in Japan may be less certain about their identity. Our results highlight the importance of understanding and considering culture when thinking about developmental processes and pathways.